Ignoring the real Israel
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-06-12Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
in Motherwell In Motherwell South, the right wing his regular weekly columns in Mothermajority have joined the witch-hunt well Times and Wishaw Press, brandagainst Militant, aided and abetted by ink the young comrades around MiliCOMMENTS have appeared in the press which explicitly or implicitly accuse Socialist Organiser and some of its supporters active in student politics - who are part of Socialist Students in NOLS, SSiN - of either Jew-baiting (the Sunday Telegraph) or benefiting from anti-semitism in elections to the National Union of Students (NUS) Executive (the Guardian).
Nothing else can be understood from what the Guardian said but that Simon Pottinger, a SO supporter, beat Linzi Brand in the NUS elections because an anti-semitic campaign was waged against her.
"Ms Linzi Brand, the NUS antiracism officer, said that at the conference she had failed to be elected to a further sabbaticai cause she was Jewish Post largely beBrand directly, the Guardian continues Far left "'People were saying they weren't going to vote for a left-wing yid, that kind of thing. Anti-semitism can be a good recruiting agent for the far left".
It is not even excluded by these words that Simon Pottinger himself, or his SSiN and SO associates, were among the organisers of this supposed campaign.
The Sunday Telegraph cites Socialist Organiser, and only Socialist Organiser, as the 'outside agitator' source of the anti-semitism which it — correctly - says is rampant at South Bank Polytechnic.
*Linzi Brand is a Zionist. Like a beleaguered factory manager she blames 'outside agitators' for the troubles. By this she means Trotskyite splinter groups like Socialist Organiser, some of whom are powerful within the Labour Party's Walworth Road headquarters. But she also points to pro-Khomeini Iranians", Both papers cite Linzi Brand as the source of what they say or imply about SO.
The truth is very much the opposite of what is said in the Sunday Telegraph and Guardian about SO and its student supporters. We have campaigned against left-wing antisemitism openly, in the NUS and in the columns of SO.
Lose votes
If Linzi Brand did lose votes because of anti-semitism, and we think she probably did, then Simon Pottinger, who openly attacked the anti-semitism implicit in 'Israel-must-be-destroyed' anti-Zionism, cannot be held responsible for this in any way. And since he beat Linzi Brand by 100 votes, antisemitism alone cannot explain her lack of appeal.
On the same day Michele Carlisle — a Jewish SO supporter who defended the right of Israel to exist, and openly denounced left-wing anti-semitismtopped the poll in another election.
Smear
We protest at these smears and misrepresentations of SO and SSiN students. Linzi Brand, irresponsibly and small-spiritedly, has reduced the serious and increasingly important question of left-wing anti-semitism to factional trivia to excuse and explain her failure — as the right-wing candidate of the SDP, the Communist Party, and Labour Students leaders — to beat the left-wing candidate, Simon Pottinger, in the election for the post of NUS vice president welfare. Having accepted that "Israel's apologists attempt to morally blackjack critics of Israel into silence with cries of "anti-Semitism' " and having, quite correctly, described such behaviour as "contemptible" John O'Mahony is guilty of exactly the same behaviour himselt.
There can be no other interpretation of the phrase "some 'anti-Zionists' like Tony Greenstein, a prominent member of the LMCP" . Given the context of the article, the inverted commas can only mean that I am an anti-Semite masquerading as an anti-Zionist. I suggest that O'Mahony either substantiates this allegation or retracts it.
For the record I have been active in the anti-fascist movement all my political life.
Responsibility
Nor is it true that I smear the Zionists with some of the responsibility for the crimes of the Nazis for the holocaust of six million Jews." On the moral and political level, the responsibility is solely that of the Nazis.
There is no serious historian - Zionist or otherwise — who has not raised the question as to whether the Zionist goal of statehood did not act at cross purnoses to the need to rescue as many Jews as possible.
It is equally untrue to suggest that the Zionists tried to get "the best deals" from various anti-Semites from the Ottoman dignitaries to the Nazis. Unless you mean the best deal for the Zionist movement. In Czarist Russia they did their best to undermine Jewish participation in the revolutionary movement. In Weimar Germany they abstained from all anti-fascist activity, even the most minimal bourgeois kind.
local Mir Jeremy Dray.
The General Management Committee has decided to start an investigation into sellers of Militant newspaper.
During the debate, Dr. Bray named certain delegates present as members of Militant. By fingering young comrades in this way, most of whom he has known for years, Dr. Bray undoubtedly influenced the 30-23 vote decision.
Dr Bray then continued the attack in We welcome letters: 400 words or less, please. We may have to cut longer letters. Send to PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA. Palestinian refugees The tragedy is that with his talk of the Israeli army being a "citizen army" (i.e. a conscript army like South Africa) and being "extremely democratic" for its Jewish majority. O'Mahony has now adopted identical positions to those of traditional left Zionist apologists for Israel. Even for the Jews of Israel, the options are narrowing as Israel follows a path not unlike that of Nazi Germany and South Africa today. It is overtly racist and the fascist right is growing, not the left Zionists that O' Mahony identified with. Unfortunately O'Mahony ignores the reality of Israel today in favour of ideological abstractions, Yours sincerely, Tony Greenstein