Legal attacks on the unions are nothing new When unions were illeaal
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-06-12Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
Plan McCalman ATTACKS upon trade unionism by the government, acting on behalf of the employing class, have a long tradition in British history. Already by the end of the eighteenth century there were more than 40 Acts of Parliament to prevent workers from combining in defence of their wages and conditions. The employers had not hesitated to use these on many occasions.
But by the last decade of the eighteenth century these were seen to be inadequate, for, with the Industrial Revolution then in progress, came a rapid growth of 'combinations"
In face of the extreme, marked exploitation of that period, workers saw the need to build organisations for their defence. The alarm of the ruling class is expressed by two local Justices of the Peace in a letter to the Home Secretary in 1791:
*We have also now a very general spirit of combination amongst all sorts of labourers and artisans who are in a spirit of general disaffection to all legal control'.
It was in this atmosphere that the Combination Acts of 1799 and 1800 were introduced, making all combinations illegal, with sentences of fines and imprisonment.
The motives behind these Acts were not simply economic, but were directly political.
These were the years when the spectre of French Revolution, of Jacobinism, haunted European ruling class.
Revolutionary
Both landed aristocracy and manufacturers teared the revolutionary effect of a coming together of working-class unrest and the radical ideas of the Revolution.
The aristocracy wanted to suppress Jacobin "conspiracies" , while the manufacturers wanted to crush 'conspiracies' for more wages. The Combination Acts served both purposes.
But the response of the working class was also political. The Combination Acts only served to bring closer together the two strands, illegal Jacobinism and trade unionism.
In face of this repression the leading organisers of unions in different regions were naturally those most radical politically. Men who adhered to the democratic ideas of Thomas Paine and of Jacobinism became the most active and militant trade unionists.
Political radicalism thus became part of the heritage of the British working-class movement from an early date.
Political clubs became known as 'Union Societies' In the early nineteenth century workers began to read radical papers, such as The Political Register', "The Cup of Liberty' and "The Republican" , with their attacks on monarchy, aristocracy and industrialists.
This radical sentiment was not simply limited to demands for reform. The Jacobin tradition was revolutionary.
As early as 1801-1802 there are reports from spies in the Home Office papers of big meetings of workers on the Midland moors in the evenings, addressed by radical agitators, threatening the overthrow of the existing order.
This threat to the employing forms.
In its earlier phase, especially, some radicals thought in terms of a conspiratorial coup. There was a strong element of this in the politics of Thomas Spence and the organisers of the Cato Street conspiracy. [An unsuccessful radical plot to kill members of the Tory Cabinet in 1820. An agent provocateur may have been involved.
Roots
But radicalism had deep roots in the working class movement, as seen in the mass meetings held by radical orators after the end of the Napoleonic Wars in 1815, addressed by Orator Hunt and others. The reports of spies and government officials in the Home Office papers reveal the awareness of the ruling class of the extent to which the spirit of Jacobinism, or radical politics, gripped the working-class movement. By 1815 almost every industrial area of England was regarded by the authorities as 'disaffected'.
This radicalism grew up in a period of enormous upheaval and distress for the working class. The rapid acceleration of industrial change brought about the growth of an industrial proletariat as never before.
This, combined with the impact of the Napoleonic War, meant great deprivation for the working class, due to high prices, low wages and atrocious working conditions and housing.
The working class organised 'combinations' and strike actions. The ruling class struck back with their anti-trade union legislation.
It has sometimes been claimed that the Combination Acts were not very repressive, as they were not often implemented. But many employers preferred to use older laws, some dating back to the sixteenth century, as these could be made to. work more rapidly, carried heavier penalties, and put the onus of prosecution upon the government rather than the individual employer.
Moreover, like all such legislation, it gained its effectiveness by its use at critical points of working class development or action. It was used against the important strikes of the Glasgow weavers in 1813 and the Barnsley linen weavers in 1822, with great effect.
Despite the many defeats and oppressions inflicted upon the working class at this period, the trade union movement continued to grow.
Meetings of members were held in public houses in conditions of great secrecy. Their lives were constantly threatened by the prevalence of spies, and the caprice of local magistrates.
The workers matched the repressiveness of the authorities with increased vigilance and organisation.
Moors The Society of Ironfounders, founded in 1810, is traditionally stated to have had to meet at night on the moors in the Midland area, with its books and records buried in the ground.
Much oath-taking and ritual were involved in trade union membership in order to tighten security. Members were thus warned of the dangers which they would encounter if they comThe Cato Street Conspiracy promised with the class enemy in any way.
Blacklegs were dealt with severely. necessary Concede Realising they had gone too far, the terrified government rushed through the Act of 1825, which, while conceding the right of collective bargaining, the right to strike and other points, imposed new restrictions with the aim of protecting employers and non-unionists.
Lord Lansdowne declared 'that no manufacture could be carried on if workmen could dictate to the masters who should be employed, and prevent men from exercising their right of labouring on Whatever terms they might please'.
The employers of that age were certainly more candid in expression although little different in outlook from those of today.
Despite these restrictions, trade unionism, through a hard struggle, continued to grow. This independent struggle of the working class remained, as it had been throughout the period 18001825, the only true guarantee of the continuance of trade unionism.
Now, as then, political manipulation or legal wrangling by either political radicals or trade union bureaucrats are no substitute for the independent struggle of the working class.
The second lesson to be learned by Marxists from this period is the political nature of the conflict.
For the early trade unionists there was no separation between political and industrial struggles - their trade unionism was seen as part of their struggle for political democracy and social reform.
Political radicalism and trade inseparable.
Now, as then, we must train trade unionists to be primarily political in outlook, but on a higher level than ever before.
It is essential that trade unionists become revolutionaries. Only in this way can we fight for the independence of the trade unions from the state, and for the mobilisation of the working class for the purpose of taking power.