Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Can we change human nature?

Socialist Organiser no. 272, 12 June 1986 · scan pp. 10–11 · Martin Thomas · about 1,006 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

HUMAN nature is greedy and selfish. Therefore socialism is impossible.

So say the defenders of the status quo. If capitalism - society based on the drive for profit — did not exist, human nature would invent it.

Forms

Historically, however, it was not an eternally-fixed human nature that created capitalism. Capitalism, coming after many previous and different forms of society, has changed human nature.

Economically backward American Indian societies, for example, did not know the drive for profit. An early French explorer reported: "They think it strange that someone should have more goods than others, and that those who have moré should be more - than those who have less'* im such if a concept of private Socialist Organiser no.272 June 1986 Page 10 OF MARXISM wealth developed, the wealth played not by accumulating lavish gift ceremonies.

Money, exchange, commerce, the basic germs of capitalism, go back long betore capitalism itself, and have been remoulding human nature for thousands of years. It took them a long time to create the modern capitalist spirit.

In the Middle Ages, for example, merchants and craft workers had elaborate codes and regulations to curb the drive for profit. It was considered morally wrong for one to outdo the other by more efficient production or keener pricing. Established morality condemned lending money on interest as a sin.

As one historian summarises it, the idea was: "Society, like the human body, is an organism composed of different bodies. Each member has its own function... Each must receive the means suited to its station... Within classes there must be equality... Between classes there must be inequality; for otherwise a class cannot perform its function or enjoy its rights"

Even capitalism's 'human nature' has a split personality. At work, in the marketplace, we are supposed to be motivated entirely by money cost/benefit calculations; at home, within the family, our "human nature" is supposed to change. Love counts for everything, money calculations for nothing.

Yet the modern family is no more 'natural" than the modern marketplace. Previous societies have often had large extended family systems in which care for children is a shared responsibility. In the Middle Ages, though hospitality and social solidarity was often much warmer than today, people generally cared very little about children. It was not thought unnatural to kill unwanted babies.

Drives Today those who have money hire nursemaids and buy places in boarding schools so that their children are kept at a distance.

There may be some fixed drives underlying human personality. But history, and even the variety of human reactions within present day society, show that these drives can express themselves in very different ways. If we can change society, human nature will change with it

Scan page 11

BUILD FOR THE FUTURE By John POST Office bosses were unpleasantly surprised by the rapid spread of strikes after they locked out postal workers in Leeds two weeks ago.

By Tuesday morning, 3rd, 6000 workers in Yorkshire were on strike.

This panicked management into agreeing to reinstate the suspended workers. They quickly dropped their demand for a written statement that they would 'work normally' . Now the workers were offered a possible extra 1½ hours break a week in return for the work study proposals management had tried and failed to impose unilaterally.

But this offer, accepted by the union leaders, fell short of what the strikers asked for — an extra 2½ hours break a EEK week, as well as bonus from the new work-study-based scheme. Union leader Alan Tuffin accepted 1½ hours extra break to be negotiated locally against a proportion of the bonus.

Overtime is being cut by the new work study scheme, so the result of this agreement will be a dog-fight in each office between conditions and money. UCW members will be split and divided by different agreements.

It was not necessary to give management what Tuffin gave them. The strike made it possible for Post Office workers to beat them — perhaps for the first time in years.

For example, the dispute could have been tied to the demand for a reduction in the present 43 hour working week. The union leaders' cynical sellout threw all this away.

bosses nite because rably toot the too had been alarmed by the spread of the dispute. Tuffin bluntly explained why the deal was accepted and the strikers ordered back: "There was a genuine desire to avoid a national strike"

When Tuffin made this deal, a ballot on industrial action was being held in the 11 sorting offices next in line for work study. Reports that all favoured #PRINT action are backed up by the fact that in the Yorkshire area every suspension for refusing to cross picket lines was immediately answered by strikes.

Understandably union militants were very angry with their leaders. At a Sheffield mass meeting, the workers initially voted not to allow left' EC member Gerry Casey to speak. Then they relented, but they gave him a very rough time of it.

Shift

Attention now shifts to the 11 offices next in line — Belfast, Brighton, Cardiff, Derby, Edinburgh, Exeter, Liverpool, Norwich, Komford, Shetfield, and WDO London. These are some of the most militant UCW branches. The key to the future is to build up rank and file organisation and get regular coordination between union militants.

hunting MIGHT IS right, and those with the ear of Labour's National Executive Committee (NEC) can afford to gloss over the truth.

That's the only conclusion on offer from the latest round of bullying by the Democratic Left (DL) faction in Labour students. They have referred leading Socialist Students in NOLS (SSiN) supporters to the NEC., In the DL's usual style of asserting something, and then denouncing opponents who point out that when the actual details are taken into account their picture crumbles, the DL have accused SSiN of standing against official Labour candidates in National Union of Students (NUS) national executive elections and in the NUS London committee elections.

----- pull-quotes -----

WORKERS le sell out

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 272

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →