Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

'neo-colonial' Labour?

Socialist Organiser no. 273, 19 June 1986 · scan p. 4 · about 651 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 4

Black section members trying to speak at Labour Party Conference.

ISRAEL AND RACISM We welcome less, please. longer letters. London SE15 Dear Comrades, At Annual Party Conference last year the Labour leadership offered the Black and Asian Advisory Committee as an alternative to Black Sections._ The Labour Party's Black and Asian Advisory Committee attempts to divide black Labour Party members. The Black Section in contrast has united Africans, Caribbeans and Asians in constituency Black Sections across the country under their own selfdefinition of Black.

The British Labour Party's whole approach to black people in Britain has been fasioned by the colonial experience.

Consulted

The NEC Working Group had previously produced a consultation paper. The Labour Party and the Black Electorate' . This discussed the issues raised by Black Sections and invited comments from the whole labour movement. The consultation was one of the widest ever conducted by the Party. An overwhelming majority of the respondents, including constituency Labour Parties and trade unions favoured fully constituted Black Sections.

Nevertheless the Labour leader said on 23 May 1985, "I am adamantly against Black Sections It is a pity that Tony Greenstein has not bothered to read John O'Mahony's position on Palestine. Maybe then he wouldn't take isolated comments and give them ludicrous importance, inventing a political position that doesn't exist.

In fact O'Mahony's writings like those in Socialist Organiser generally, have persistently sought to condemn the nature of the current Israeli state. Indeed SO condemns racist policies in states all over the world, including Britain.

But condemning the racist nature of Israel does not mean that the Palestinian Jews are not a nation or that there cannot be a smaller non-racist Israel where Arabs have full rights, including regional rights to cecede to a Palestine Arab state.

Greenstein may be right to say that Israel "is overtly racist and the fascist right is growing" . It may even be true that "Israel follows a path not unlike that of Nazi Germany words or We may ha re to cut Send to PO Box 823. 4NA.

BL LACK would not give a damn if the whole Labour Party was against me on this" Indeed, two-thirds of those consulted were against Mr. Kinnock.

The last 25 years have seen the leadership produce one Bantustan advisory committee after another. All have closely followed the colonIt women, youth and Jewish people (through Poale Zion) can elect members to represent them, But then is he suggesting that Germany has no right to exist because of its Nazi past? That any state which is "overtly racist" forfeits its right to be a nation?

Considering the widespread occurance of racism in the world it appears to me there would be few people left with national rights in Tony Greenstein's world.

Jewish

Thus any solution in Palestine which fails to recognise the existence of two nations there is not a solution at all because it seeks to build class consciousness by trampling on the national rights of the Jewish workers.

Tony Greenstein sees no political difference between Jewish national rights and the present Israeli state. Greenstein is not an anti-semite but he fails to recognise the proposed secular democratic state has massive anti-semitic implications for the Jews in Palestine. Indeed, it is only achievable over the dead body of the Jewish nation, which is both impossible and undesirable TECTION why can't black people? Advisory committees to advise white policy makers is not good enough. We don't just want a slice of the cake, we want access to the recipe.

We ask all those who are sympathetic to Black Sections who have accepted membership of this committee to resign immediately. They are unwittingly collaborating in a neo-colonialist structure which history holds in contempt.

PAUL SHARMA, (Labour Party Black Section)

----- pull-quotes -----

ial models used in Africa and India, all have come to nothing.

CONWAY Photo: Andrew Wiard, (Report).

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 273

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →