Nukes, technology and the left
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-06-26Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
Many serious socialists are out of touch with the reality of civil nuclear power. It is argued, for instance, that opposition to nuclear power is a sort of Luddism - an anti-technology struggle; the problem is that safety cannot be guaranteed under capitalism, so what we really need is new technology and socialism.
But this doesn't make sense. Many independent scientists seriously doubt that this technology can ever be safe.
Of course we should not be Luddites about nuclear power. But it is far from clear that even workers' control would mean sate nuclear power.
In any case nothing is guaranteed under capitalism. So we must support movements against nuclear power now.
Better safety provision for rechnology is no answer. Before we reach "nuclear safety" there might have been four or five 'China Syndromes' and Chernobyls across the world. And no safety is mistakeproof.
Building
It is not like fighting for safety helmets on a building site or guards around dangerous machinery. A big accident in non-nuclear industries might kill hundreds or even thousands — but would the surrounding countryside, wildlife, water and thousands, perhaps millions of people be threatened with long-term pollution as they would with a major reactor explosion.
The idea that the enemy is not nuclear technology, but capitalism is simplistic and naive. There is clear evidence that even the peaceful use of atomic energy threatens us with nuclear catastrophe.
As socialists we should fight not only for working class control of technology, but for working class choice of technology. And, let's face it, there are other, better choices.
The coal industry not only provides relatively safe power, but also hapens to be home for many militant, class conscious workers. Safer still are wind, solar and water power. Surely the longterm prospects for these renewable sources of energy are better than the infinitesimal amounts of money capitalism invests in their research?
Yours fraternally.
LIAM CONWAY