Tackle the root cause capitalism'
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-06-26Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 6
ON TOP of all their previous cuts, the Tories now plan to slash another £1000 million from the social security budget. Major cutbacks and extensive privatisation are also being used to attack other aspects of the welfare state.
Right-wing politicians throughout the world have long hated the very idea of a welfare state. Writing about Sweden, the 'model' welfare state, Roland Huntford claimed in his book, 'Welfare Dictatorship':
"Since the party has control of the state, its apparatchik rules the coun try... It controls and permeates society to such an extent that it can easily be compared with the Soviet Communist Party... Only Sweden can point to a direct and faultless descent from Marx...
Completely reasonable parents live in constant fear that their children will be taken away from them if their methods of upbringing do not completely agree with the conceptions current at that time".
Outlandish
With the rise of Thatcherite monetarism, similar outlandish claims are gaining currency in this country. "The moral fibre of our people has been weakened... The State spends all its energies taking money from the energetic, successful and thrifty to give it to the idle, the failures, and the feckless" claims Social Security minister Rhodes Boyson in his book 'Down With The Poor' For Tory backwoodsmen the welfare state smacks of giving people money for nothing. It is a redistribution of wealth, on a small scale. It weakens 'family responsibilities'; it undermines the notion of the 'self-made men'; it seems to pave the way for a 'Big Brother' state, and so on.
The welfare state must be defended against the Tories. But we cannot ignore the limitations of any welfare state under capitalism.
Last year's TUC congress affirmed *its commitment to the Beveridge principles of the Welfare State based on the redistribution of wealth..." But the 'Beveridge' welfare state which emerged in this country after World War 2 was not based on socialist ideas and policies.
Beveridge was a Liberal, committed to capitalism and opposed to any fundamental changes in the social structure. At best, he wanted 'capitalism with a human face*.
The inspiration of the welfare state in other countries has been similar. In "model' Sweden, for example, the SAP (Swedish Labour Party) laid the bases of the modern welfare state in the 1930s, at the very time when it was explicitly moving away from Marxism.
*From Class Struggle to Cooperation' was the symptomatic title of a book by Ernst Wigforss, the architect of the SAP's economic policies in the "30s. And the words socialisation' (of industry) and "socialism' failed " to appear in SAP election manifestos for the first time in 1932 and 1936.
Scan page 7
police in Mexico City.
----- pull-quotes -----
Stan Crooke By