Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

The left in Solidarnosc

Socialist Organiser no. 274, 26 June 1986 · scan p. 10 · about 1,499 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

The Workers' Opposition is a new alliance of left-wing groups within Solidarnosc, the Polish labour movement, which continues to operate underground despite havin been banned and repressed by martial law in December 1981. Solidarnosc emerged as a movement ten million strong from a strike wave against price rises in 1980, after several years of underground activity by small "free trade union" opposition groups, At its height it threatened the bureaucratic police state, and continues to be active and to debate policies.

Within the left wing of Solidarnose is being forged the leadership of the Polish workers' revolution that will bury Polish Stalinism.

This is the first part of an interview with a representative of the Workers' Opposition, sent to the Western left press.

What is the Alliance of the Workers Opposition (POR) and why was it set up?

The POR is an alliance of various groupings within the Polish oppos ition movement. These groups vary in both size and form - some are large, some are small, several represent the editorial boards of underground bulletins (it was four of these bulletins that originally launched the POR), while others are opposition groups organised at the level of plants, towns or regions.

The POR was set up to coordinate the activities of those in the opposition who believe we have to base ourselves firmly on the working class, both in our current strug gles and in our strategy, in the polltical perspective we present. Generally speaking, this means a strategy of developing the self-organisation of the working class.

I think the POR could best be described as that current in the opposition which sees the independent self-organisation of the working class as the key to success in our coming struggles, and at the same time the key to solving Poland's political and economic crises. How does the POR relate to Solidarnose?

On the one nand, we are all, as individuals, members of Solidarity, and all the structures involved in the POR either developed out of old Solidarity structures or contacts or were organised by Solidarity activists.

On the other hand, POR itselt, nomany of its constituent structures, are controlled by or responsible to the regional and national leadership bodies of Solidarity that still exist.

Some of the groups in the POR formally function as Solidarity structures, while others don't.

To understand the situation properly, you have to understand what Solidarity is today. 1 think the easiest way to explain that would be to say that Solidarity is simply the sum of the whole Polish opposition. With a few minor exceptions. all groups in the opposition regard themselves as being part of Solidarity, that is they identify themselves with the legal mass movement that existed in 1980-81, But Solidarity is a very heterogeneous movement. It includes the old leadership bodies, workplace structures in the factories and new inter-factory organisd. tions that have sprung up since martial law, groups of people organised on a neighbourhood basis, and perhaps most importantly - a whole host of underground bulletins: I've no idea how many of these there are at present - the last figure I heard quoted was around 600 coming out regularly - but it's these bulletins that are the lifeblood of the opposition.

Yet they represent widely differing political positions, which reflects the growing-politicisation of the movement. Nevertheless, the essential unity of the movement, expressed in the general identification with Solidarity, indeed in the very name 'Solidarity', has been maintained.

And of course, the POR, as a current within the opposition and Solidarity, represents no threat to that unity the independent workers' movement.

What do you mean by the "politicisation" of the movement?

The term "politicisation" is generally used in the Polish underground press to refer to the emergence of groups and currents on the basis of distict political programmes or positions. In other words, refers to a process of internal political differentiation within the movement.

This process is of course only natural; it would be absurd to think of Solidarity and the whole opposition as some sort of political monolith. To a large extent, this progess was already under way before martial law, but martial law speeded it up, because the independent press became the most important element in the opposition. Since the various bulletins had to fend for themselves in very difficult conditions,they inevitably began to develop their political positions independently.

As a result, while some bulletins; particularly factory ones, remained essentially informational in content, others began to represent distinct political lines. This whole process has again picked up speed recently, with many people in the opposition calling for a more clearcut political differentiation within the movement, for the establishment of political parties, etc.

For our part, we think this process is generally positive, since a healthy political pluralism can only strengthen Solidarity and the opposition. That pluralism should have a clear programmatic basis, with different groups and currents clearly explaining the tactics and strategy they are proposing for the movement as a whole.

In addition, the fact that many factory activists are calling for the increased politicisation of the movement reflects their rejection of any concept of forcing the authorities into a dialogue that would result in some sort of "historic compromise" , most probably involving a return to the status quo prior to December 13, 198l.

In other words, they recognise that Solidarity can never be forced back into a purely trade-unionist role, and that its legalisation cannot be won by simply putting pressure on the state power or negotiating with it.

Of course, the calls for politicisation also reflect dissatisfaction with the tactics currently being pursued by the Solidarity leadership, and its failure to put forward a coherent strategy. There is one danger here, however.

Certain sections of the opposition - the nationalistic wing and large parts of the intelligentsia -see the idea of "politicising the movement" as something counterposed to the idea of mass struggle. They have no perspective to offer the working class today. In fact, they are increasingly isolated from it, so they put forward the idea of politicisation as an alternative.

What they are actually saying is: there's nothing we can do now, so let's start organising political discussion clubs and our own little political parties, then at some point in the future, when the workers revolt again, we can force the state power into giving us political pluralism, and then our parties can start functioning. That concept is in our opinion totally ridiculous; it is a recipe for disaster.

It also reflects the instrumental way in which the nationalistic and intellectual opposition groups view the working class - as the "muscle" that is needed to bring the state power to its knees, after which the workers should go home and leave the politics to the intellectuals.

The POR sees politicisation in a completely different way. What we have to do is to combine day-to-day struggles with a developed political perspective. This means making the link between today's struggles and the strategy we need for the working class to achieve direct democratie control of and power over the economy and the state.

That all sounds very good, but what does it mean in practice? Your founding document, ie. the Draft Platform of the Workers' Opposition, which I've read, is very general. There's a lot about strategy in it and a number of praiseworthy political principles, but there's not much about the day-to-day struggles you're talking about.

That's true but then that was precisely the purpose of the document you are referring to - to serve as a declaration of principles. At that time, where the POR was being launched, the point was to present an overall outline of the strategy and positions that differentiate us from other currents in the opposition. But that doesn't mean we are not involved in concrete practical struggle.

As I've said, all the structures in the POR developed out of Solidarıty structures or were organised by Solidarity activists, mostly in the factories. And it's in the factories that the vast majority of our work takes place. In contrast to many other currents in Solidarity - and that includes a significant section of the old leadership - we believe that struggle in the factories, mines and shipyards is not something for the future, even the very near future, but something for today. This is in fact borne out by what is happening in Poland.

Despite the experience of the martial law, despite the repression and intimidation, despite the fact that many leading activists in the factories have been sacked, can't get new jobs, and are seeing their families lace severe hardship -scarcely a week goes by without some form of struggle or protest action in at least one major factory, often in several.

In our opinion, this is what we have to build up, and all our efforts are directed towards developing and supporting these struggles, and in particular developing the forms of workers' self-organsation that they immediately produce.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 274

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →