Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Stop the witch hunt, start the fightback

Socialist Organiser no. 275, 3 July 1986 · scan pp. 3–4 · Pat Murphy · about 1,362 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 3

the blood of Militant and other socialists very long time ago, the left of the Party The present Labour Party purge differs from any of the many purges in the party's long history in that it is supported and sometimes organised by a section of Labour's left wing.

Many self-styled lefts have become bigoted and unashamed advocates and practitioners of purge and witchhunt. The first place in the ranks of 'left" wing purgers is held by Tribune.

As long ago as January 1982, Tribune was callina for a tribunal to investicate "some of the more secretive sectarian organisations". And of course Tribune is prominent in the recent assault on Militant in Liverpool.

But the Kinnockites wield a powerful argument that has helped at least to neutralise all but the hard left. Many Party members, and many more Labour voters, are convinced by the idea that Party unity is the number one priority if The partition of Ireland and the repressive Six County State in the North was given a much needed boost last week from the voters in the South. That is only one of the many tragic effects of the massive vote against legalised divorce, in last Thursday's referendum in the Irish Republic.

The Irish government is a coalition made up of the conservative Fine Gail and the Labour Party, and is led by one of the architects of the Anglo-Irish Accord, Garrett Fitzgerald, Fitzgerald has long promised a constitutional crusade in Ireland to reform the social laws, and assert the power of secular democracy over the authority of the Catholic Church.

Ironies The crusade's failure has only served to underline how powerful the Catholic Church is.

In 1983 a referendum ensured that abortion, already illegal, could never be made legal without changing the constitution.

The recent referendum, proposed by the government was intended to allow divorce under fairly tight conditions - when a married couple could show that their marriage had broken down for at least five years.

All that is available now are church and civil annullments after which separated people have no right to re-marry. It had been generally believed that legal divorce would go through easily. But the Church worked hard for a "no" vote. The opposition Fine Fail party campaigned against although it claimed to be neutral. And by two to one the voters rejected the proposal to heralise the law the Tories are ever to be replaced by a Labour government. In the interests of Party unity they will accept a purge of those who 'rock the boat', even if in their heart of hearts they are against it.

This, of course, is what the right wing always mean by Party unity: that the Left should keep its mouth shut. An end to internal faction-fighing always entails a factional victory for the right. The right wing makes no, or only small, concessions; the lett collapses.

Unity Unity essential, throughout labour movement. But unity does not and should not mean the suppression of debate about current or future tactics and policies. Nor should unity mean the outlawing of political criticism of the leadernick.

A vote for a Catholic Ireland To listen to the media afterwards you might think that the most important victim of this defeat was Garret Fitzgerald and his government. It is true that the coalition i now a minority government ship.

Debate is the life-blood of a democratic workers' movement; and it is right and proper that like-minded groups of people in the labour movement organise to put their ideas across, produce literature, and aim to convince others.

Unity therefore need not entail 100% agreement on policy. It should be unity in action, on things that all currents in the movements do agree about. so unity to do what? To appease the tari harana. not anhe haulina fAr since the resignation of a Labour TD (MP) earlier this year. It stays in power because a third party, the recently formed Progressive Democrats vote with it on crucial issues. The result underlines the instability in the Labour Party, but who howl for the blood of all socialists all the time?

Yet there is no doubt, surely, that a large part of the motivation behind the witch hunt is precisely an attempt to appeal safe' in the eyes of the pulp propagandists in Fleet St and wapping.

Or unity to fight the Tories? It is the Labour leaders and the witch-hunters who are creating disunity, not the left. If they try to expel Party members, the Party members have every right to fight them. If they try to ditch conference policy, they should be called to account.

Slogan

Years ago, and in the days of Kinnock's SIUT American Dream Labour Party, it seems Mraam lakaur Darke it anama Thatcher and Fitzgerald s of the minority government, and a general election can be expected in the next few months.

For us, however, there are more important victims. First there are the 70,000 Irish women thought to be affected by the ban on divorce. Women with no rights to maintenance or help, and yet no right to remarry.

United

Second there are the Northern Catholics. Their basic civil and democratic rights can not be won in the mainly Protestant and Sectarian Northern Ireland state. They need to break down that state and create a united Ireland.

The harsh reality is that this united Ireland will not come about without big defeats for the two traditions of Sectarianism. The referendum defeat shows the malignant vigour of Catholic sectarianism.

John Hulme, leader of the main Northern Catholic party, the SDLP, realised this. For the sake of the Anglo-Irish Accord he made a fina! appeal to Southern voters to say "yes" to divorce reformi.

Sinn Fein in a confusion tha reflects the populist politics of tha movement came out for a "yes" vote, but then went on to explain. how they could understand many of their supporters not being able to vote "yes". They evaded the whole issue.

Many socialists who are sympathetic to Irish nationalism will point to the reactionary attitudes of most Loyalist leaders on these issues, and say that it is all really irrelevant. They will be right about organised itself to win some important democratic reforms.

There was a slogan then: Never again" — never again a miserable, anti-working class government like that of 1974-9; never again a Labor government that came to power with radical promises and launched unprecedented attacks on the living standards of its own, working class supporters, That left has disintegrated. But the choice that we faced back then, in 1979 and afterwards, remains: either we radically transform the labour movement into a real force for socialism — a democratic, active, militant with a small 'm", internationalist movement; or it will go to future, yet more bitter defeats The transformation can begin serious campaign against the hunt. ign the deal the Loyalists. They will be wrong about the relevance of this vote.

What we were given a glimpse of last week was how the Irish Republic treats a minority. For non-Catholics, separated women, it doesn't really matter who the minority is, Since the whole of the national question in Ireland today revolves around the problem of a minority, the Northern Protestants, the point could hardly be more relevant.

So last week's vote was one which weakened women and strengthened partition.

One of the ironies of this is that many of the leading anti-divorce campaigners would see themselves as strident Irish nationalists. For us, as socialists, that just underlines the vast gulf between secular republicanism, whose aim was to remove the divisions between people and Ireland; and chauvinist Catholic nationalism.

In its explicit attempt to create *a Catholic state for a Catholic people" that nationalism simply mirrors the Unionist politics of the Unionist founders of Northern Uniting Ireland and uniting its working class are two things that have to go together. If you are not for both you are not for either.

Black workers and the struggle for liberation in South Africa Available from Socialist Organiser, PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA.

Socialist Organiser no.275 3 July 1986

Scan page 4

ETTERS

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 275

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →