Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

How not to build socialism

Socialist Organiser no. 275, 3 July 1986 · scan pp. 7–8 · about 1,063 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 7

All serious socialists must condemn the Labour Party leadership's expulsion of Liverpool councillors and party activists because of their association with the Militant newspaper. However, as Baz Hardy argues, it would be wrong to react to these attacks from the right by holding up Liverpool as the example of what a fighting, campaigning socialist council should do.

LIVERPOOL'S MILITANTdominated Labour I Party kept control of the city council last May. Naturally, Militant presented this result as a 'victory' despite the fact that Labour's vote was down by over 10,000, and the Liberals' up by more than 11,000.

Of course the attitude of Labour's national leadership towards the coun cil had not helped to bring out the Labour vote. Expelled District Party chair Tony Mulhearn was right to condemn Kinnock and Hattersley for their attacks on the council's anti-rate-capping stand and their witch-hunt of Militant. These attacks were widely used in Liberal and Tory election propaganda.

But Liverpool council has been run on the basis of sectarian political dogma and worked to give narrow organisational advantages to Militant. That has offended sections of the working class community who really should be voting Labour. Mass Labour abstentions have occurred in Liverpool precisely because of Militant's sectarian approach.

Racist

Many in the black community regard our council as racist. In Granby ward, the independent black candidate, Delroy Burrows, polled 427 votes -way above any recorded by the Communist Party or the Greens, and in a ward where the labour candidate disagreed with the council line' on race.

The vote for Delroy Burrows was, therefore, a significant protest vote, which should be very worrying for genuine anti-racist socialists.

Another problem confronting Liverpool socialists has been the council's refusal to grant several groups of workers their pay increases! A dispute about paying members of GMBATU who make school dinners is still continuing, causing problems for those families whose children are entitled to free school meals.

Liverpool parents on subsistence income levels are being refused compensation because the council 'can't afford it'. Their children are presumably expected to starve in order that 'socialist' economies can be made. But the 'Militant' councillors fat expenses have not been subject to the same rigors! Derek Hatton logged up in excess of £11,000 expenses this year, not counting his travel warrants and the cost of his chauffeur-driven trips to the Grand National, and many other private exotic excursions.

Liverpool council pledged that jobs and services would not be cut, but cuts are being made by the back door.

The council has more than 500 unfilled vacancies, and takes at least four moths to fill a post.

Part-time and former employees have gone without pay increases and/ or full pay entitlement for many months.

The abysmal refuse collection service — bins are now emptied once a fortnight, if you are lucky - is the most obvious example of cuts in council services. A Labour candidate came across a dead rat wearing a "Vote Labour' sticker in one of the back entries during the election campaign.

Militant blame all this on the collapse of trade union support for the council. They do not understand that the situation is largely of their own making, and that their sectarian politics have effectively played into the hands of the right wing. It is not at all clear that they have any strategy right now, except to pass the responsibility for making cuts on to the Liberals. They are just hanging on waiting for the moment when the courts disqualify the 47 Labour councillors from office, on or after July 7th. Then they will be able to cover up their own record as Liverpool's rulers in streams ot rnetoric blaming Kinnock for his treachery. But in generating the grotesque series of fiascos in Liverpool, Kinnock's treacherous attacks on the council played only a secondary, though important, part.

The central responsibility rests with Militant. Militant has run Liverpool like the old-fashioned corrupt Tammany Hall Labour right wing ran it, only adding left posturing and left thetoric, a vicious, factional narrow-mindedness that even the old Catholic bigots never quite matched.

The Liverpool experience provides a tragic example of how not to build socialism at the local level. A mass movement of thousands of workers could have been organised and galvanised around an anti-capitalist political programme. It wasn't. Neil Kinnock could, with justice as well as hypocrisy, denounce "the Marxists' for making Liverpool workers redundant.

The sectarian course pursued by Militant has served only to produce demoralisation.

Militant's record in Liverpool must be accounted for, and we can only hope that genuine socialists who supported Militant in the past will participate in the process.

Scan page 8

and workers' struggles world wide, including the struggle of workers and oppressed nationalities in the Stalinist states against their anti-socialist bureaucracies.

For full equality for women, and social provision to free women from the burden of housework. For a mass working Against racism, and against deportations Socialist Organiser stands for workers' liberty, East and West. We aim to help organise the left wing in the Labour For a free and united Ireland, with some federal system Party and trade unions to fight to replace capitalism with protect the rights of the Protestant minority.

For left unity in action; clarity in debate and discussion.

We want public ownership of the major enterprises and For a labour movement accessible to the most oppresa planned economy under workers' control. We want demo- sed, accountable to its rank and file, and militant against cracy much fuller than the present Westminster system - a workers' democracy, with elected representatives recallable We want Labour Party and trade union members who at any time, and an end to bureaucrats' and managers" support our basic ideas to become supporters of the paper - to take a bundle of papers to sell each week and pay a Socialism can never be built in one country alone. The small financial contribution to help meet the paper's workers in every country have more in common with deficit. Our palicy is democratically controlled by our workers in other countries than with their own capitalist Porters through Annual General Meetings and an elected or Stalinist rulers. We support national liberation struggles SATURDAY 12 JULY. Third SOCIALIST ORGANISER World First conference for trade MEETINGS working class socialism. gration controls. class based women's movement.

For equality for lesbians and gays.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 275

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →