Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Old contricks, new face

Socialist Organiser no. 275, 3 July 1986 · scan p. 10 · about 1,019 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

Kinnock and Dean, practitioners of new realism. Photo: Andrew Wiard. banal. Take the section on New patriarchal, organising itself in ways Technology, for instance: "For the which preserve and legitimise the trade unions to rise to the challenge hierarchies of capitalism, valuing in of new technology and industrial its formal and informal culture trarestructuring, a profound shift is ditional definitions of masculinity, required towards a much more stra- and even confusing these with militegic outlook. This needs, firstly, a tancy, and oblivious to moral preparedness to anticipate and social and cultural questions." logical change and identify the given a lairly clear indication as to more desirable options. Secondly, what Carter is really advocating. the social goals which the trade "increasing rank and file involveunions should seek to realise ment" and proposes the kind of Jim Denham reviews "Trade I gladly paid over my il for this little pamphlet, "Trade Unions: The New Reality" , and looked forward to a rattling good read.

Not that I expected to agree with what I read - quite the opposite, in fact. But I did expect to be confronted by some challenging new ideas. After all, the author, Pete Carter, is the National Industrial Organiser of the Communist Party (CP), His pamphlet is based upon a report made to the CP executive earlier this year.

It is also worth noting that Pete Carter is not some muesli-chewing sociology lecturer, but an experienced trade unionist with an honourable record of struggle in the building industry.

Trade Unions: The New Reality" is a great disappointment from any point of view. Carter addresses the crisis of the trade union movement and in particular its failure to develop a coherent response to what he calls "the Thatcher project" which he rightly defines as an attempt "to impose a new vision on British society in which socialist values are entirely absent, and support for collective responsibility is replaced by individual greed." The crisis is real and the failures obvious. A serious rethink of trade union strategies is long overdue. But Carter's answer to the problems of our movement is neither new nor socialist, as we shall see.

Banal

A lot or the pamphlet is simply assess the possible paths of technocareful attention must be given to through new technology."

I presume all that means new technology on our terms not on theirs."

Elsewhere, his reliance on jargon makes it virtually impossible to work out what exactly Carter is driving at. His favourite technique is to make a demonstrably true observation, and then to tack all sorts of vague and ambiguous ideas onto the end of it.

The section on women, for instance, correctly draws attention to the under-representation of democratic reforms that Socialist Organiser and others have long fought for (often in the face of opposition from the CP): election of officials; increased participation of members in debate and decision-making; full accountability of leaderships to the members; and so forth.

But his real concern is quite different, and it surfaces throughout the pamphlet: he wants a deal between the union leaderships and the next Labour government. The Britain's social and industrial base in new conditions after what could be almost a decade of devastating Tory rule."

Just what form such "recognition" of the government's "difficulties" would take is not spelled out, but you don't have to be a genius (or even the National Industrial Organiser of the CP) to make a guess. You could even go one better than Carter and suggest a nice name for such a deal: how about "Social Contract"?

Former Labour Prime Minister Harold Wilson and the union leaders who put together his "Socal Contract" in the mid-'70s would surely be willing to let them borrow the name.

problems which the labour movement has to tackle here and now."

Now, I wouldn't accept either Carter's definition of who makes up the hard lett', or his description of its 'principles' . But I certainly hope he's right that there is going to be a whole lot of opposition to any re-run of the "Social Contract" disaster.

Having named the "baddies" Carter proceeds to tell us who the "goodies" are: "Important examples of this approach are the Labour Co-ordinating Committee and individuals such as Rodney Bickerstaffe, Tom Sawyer of the public service union, Jimmy Knapp of the rail union, Ken Livingstone and David Blunkett of the Labour Party."

Cuddly

All good cuddly lefties, of course: just as Harold looked not to Frank Chapple, but to left wingers Jack Jones and Hugh Scanlon to force through the Social Contract, so Neil Kinnock will very likely look to Sawyer, Knapp and the cuddlies for his industrial salvation.

"Trade unionists" , says Carter, *will be familiar with many of the arguments outlined in this pamphlet. They have been discussed for many years. There is nothing new in many of the ideas advocated, so why all the fuss?" He is right to say there is nothing new in most of his ideas. The fuss is because someone who calls himself a "Communist" advocates such ideas so openly.

In practice, of course, the Communist Party (including the old Tankies at the Morning Star who denounce Carter bitterly) has long engaged in bureaucratic deals with employers and governments, at the expense of rank and file trade unionists willing to put up a fight. Carter's crime is that he theorises such practices so comprehensively.

Us "baddies" on the "hard left" do need to develop a coherent strategy in the face of the "New Realism" of the TUC leaders. We need to face up to some unpalatable truths about the weaknesses of "traditional" trade unionism that have been so effectively exploited by the Tories since 1979.

But Pete Cater's banal, pretentious little pamphlet will only be of use to us in so far as it represents a sort of manifesto for a current that could become even more dangerous than the Hammond/Jordan "hard right": class collaboration with a left face.

----- pull-quotes -----

Unions: the new reality" by Peter Carter, which outlines the Communist Party's per- spective for the trade unions.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 275

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →