Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

TATE WITH NOw OR GET CUT apolitics ianctions

Socialist Organiser no. 276, 17 July 1986 · scan pp. 7–8 · about 933 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 7

ca picket BTR headquarters in London demanding recognition for their union, MAWU. Photo: lan Swir recognition for their union, MAWU. Photo: lan Swindale.

«The first duty of socialist internationalism is for British workers to make contact with fellow workers in South Africa as a basis for solidarity action. general view on the Left was that it was no use calling on capitalists to solve the problem of apartheid, since apartheid functioned precisely to secure profits for the capitalists.

The left view was that if sanctions had any chance of working they had to be imposed by the labour movement, not by capitalists or the capitalist state. This did not rule out putting pressure on the state, but it represented a radical shift in the focus of the campaign.

Resolutions favouring sanctions were passed by several Labour Party conferences, but never translated into government policy (I was involved in an unsuccessful attempt to move the AAM into a position of support for the campaign for Labour Party democracy. That was ruled out of order by the AAM chairperson, Labour MP Bob Hughes, as interference in the internal affairs of a fraternal organisation).

Many of us on the Left thought that strategy had been turned into a moral what at best could have been a useful crusade of isolating South Africa Cavala A Saian regardless as to its actual effectiveness. At AA AGMs, the Western governments were castigated for their refusal to isolate South Africa; and year after year, the AAM plugged away at the exact same theme and nothing changed.

Faulted

Not only was the sanctions policy not working, it was also itself faulted. The basic message was that everything about South Africa should be boycotted - trade, investment, cultural links, sporting links, etc. This is all very well, but what did it ofter to those who were fighting back against the regime in South Africa itself?

They often wanted and needed links with supporters outside. Sanctions policy should have been aimed at the apartheid regime and its capitalist backers, not at its victims. In fact it tended to be aimed at 'South Africa' in general.

Thus the isolate South Africa' campaign meant in practice that all links with the resistance had to go through the ANC or otherwise be broken. This position was crucial, for example, in impeding solidarity with the newly emergent independent trade unions.

Duty

My view was and is that the first duty of socialist internationalism was for British workers to make contact with fellow workers in South Africa, as a basis for further solidarity action. This was a view shared by the independent unions in South Africa itself, including the Federation of South African Trade Unions, its affiliates, the General Workers' Union and so on. They called for direct links at all levels with British unions. AA, the ANC and its trade union wing, SACTU, bitterly opposed these union-to-union links in the name of the policy of isolation. Working class solidarity was subordinated to the sanctions campaign, which was treated, along with support for the ANC, as the exclusive goal of international solidarity.

When workers in Britain ask what they should do about apartheid, the aswer they receive was to "support sanctions'. They can boycott Barclays and South African food, they can call for the disinvestment of union, party and local authority funds from firms with investments in South Africa, they can call for sanctions from the government. There's little or no perspective on positive support for the organised labour movement, or for the wider resistance movement inside the countryOccasionally workers have taken more direct action. In Coventry, for example, I was part of a local AAM group which took a SACTU speaker round some factories in the 1970s during SACTU's week of action. As a result, BL shop stewards organised the blacking of Land Rovers to South Africa for a week.

This kind of direct action by workers received an ambivalent response from SACTU officials nationally, one of whom told us not to "queer his pitch" Generally, direct action was not favoured or promoted by AA, who prefered national pressures on the government.

The South African unions, meanwhile, were forming many links with British unions, despite the boycott campaign. When those links occured, British workers were armed not just with a more intimate knowledge of the struggle, but with a far richer array of options as to what to do - from sending material aid, to putting pressure on British companies, to moral support for black workers in struggle, to blacking actions.

Crisis

The intensity of the resistance in South Africa and a deep crisis of profitability has provided the opportunity for a renewed international sanctions campaign. Anti apartheid activists in America took the lead, and a popular movement was soon galvanised.

Small measures have been imposed in the US, but count for little in comparison to Western bankers' willingness to roll over South Africa's considerable short-term debt. A good number of American firms have withdrawn investments from South Africa, but it's not clear how much of this is due simply to economic recession. WORKERS' Breaking the chains Black workers and the struggle for liberation in South Africa Workers' Liberty special on South Africa: 75p plus 18p postage from SO, PO Box 823, London SE15

Scan page 8

and workers' struggles world wide, including the of workers and oppressed nationalities in the states against their anti-socialist bureaucracies.

For full equality for women, and social provision to free women from the burden of housework. For a mass working struggle Stalinist

----- pull-quotes -----

More on South Africa

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 276

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →