Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

How boxers get punch-drunk

Socialist Organiser no. 276, 17 July 1986 · scan p. 8 · about 1,055 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

National Editorial Board.

from Labour Party and trade union organisations. 7.30 Centre, 190 Shepherds Bush pm. (room booked by Jeremy Road, London Wo. Tel: 01- Corbvn). 603 1831.

JARROW 86. March from MEETINGS Jarrow to London (Trafalgar Sq), October 5 to November MANCHESTER Sunday July 20. South The organisers Africa: Breaking the are asking for offers of help, sponsorships, affiliations Chains'. 7.30 p.m. Town and donations. Contact: Hall, (Lloyd St. entrance). Jarrow 86, The Electric Press IMPLEMENT PARTY Factory. 39 Cookridge St., POLICY Leeds Ls1 3DW. Petition now out reminding LOBBY THE TUC. Workers' the Labour leaders of the sanctions against apartheid. 1985 Labour Party confer8.30 am, July 23, Congress ence resolution on the minHouse, Great Russell St. ers and stating 'We believe Called by Birmingham that the Labour Party should Trades Council, Greater Lon- actively campaign for the don Association of Trades above rightful demands in Councils. the run-up to the next GenerCONFERENCE AGAINST al Election' THE WITCH-HUNT. Campaign meeting. Monday July Newcastle Ave., Horden Peterlee, Co. Durham. 21. Open to representatives the social at the school, organised by other donations. raising effort.

over the coming weeks.

Grand total to date: £12,275.66, or our £15,000 target. Send donations to Box 823, London SE15 £15,000 The controversy over boxing has been simmering for years now. Sometimes, the anti-boxers have the upper hand, as for example whan 00 nano AlA Stava Watt when 29 years old Steve died of a massive brain haemorrhage last March. The popularity of the sport tends to recover bright young star shines forth, like Barry McGuigan and Frank Bruno. in tact both boxers have been involved in clean in te mug:

To caricature both positions, the anti-boxing camp demands the banning of a "sport" whose sole purpose is to batter an ooponent mto unconscioustiess while the pro-boxing camp reject any criticism of the "noble art of self-defence". Let's look at their arguments.

The most publicised aspect of boxing are the occasional deaths. World-wide, some 300 showing extensive damage boxers have died over the last 20 years but the fatality rate of boxing is far less than many sports with a better reputation.

Boxers die at a rate of 13 per 100,000, compared with 30 for American college football, 510 for mountaineering and 1280 for norse-racing Now, before SO readers star thinking that it might be safer to get off the streets and into the ring, let's look at the other consequences of boxing. These include eye, kidney and liver. damage and, most importantly, brain damage.

A single punch can transmit such force that the recipients head accelerates at 100g - one hundred times the acceleration due to gravity.

The head consists essentially of two types of material hard bony container (the skull) and us soft jelly-like COTECH (the brain). As the skull is accelerated, the brain lags behinc due to its inertia and then accel erates to catch up the skull.

La punch STEE the face causes the front of mit ine orain waicn back to hit the back This bruises and front, back, top and brain, as well as cerebellum at the into the hole in the top of the neck.

A punch to the causes Copies from G. Scott, 34 SO, PO the skull to ten moves than .... of the skull. grazes the sides of the forcing the back down skull at the side the sides the brain to hit the insides of the skull. A punch that causes a twisting of the head will cause the brain to rotate slightly, causing grazing and tearing of attachments between brain and skull. This will make it easier for the brain to be bounced around in the future.

The result of all this bruising and grazing is frightening. The worst outcome is that blood vessels can stretch and tear. The resulting bleeding or haemorrhage compresses the brain and can be fatal. This is how Steve Watt died.

More usual is death or damage to nerve cells in specific parts of the brain; namely, the cerebral cortex, cerebellum and brain stem.

Damage to the frontal lobes of the cortex can have quite subtle effects on a boxer's behaviour. He may be less able to plan his life or may behave in an outrageous way in public. He will perform less well in psychological tests. The damage to cells appears similar to that found in certain types of dementia.

Damage to the cerebellum and the brain stem affects balance and coordination of movements. Similar damage is found in sufferers from Parkinson's disease.

In extreme cases, the boxer suffers from the "punch-drunk" syndrome ("dementia pugilistica"), with uncoordinated movements, impaired mental functions and slurred speech. Readers who have heard Muhammed Ali recently and remember him in his youth may recognise these symptoms.

Supporters of boxing deny that these types of damage occur in all boxers and suggest that they can be detected by brain scans. Affected boxers can then be retired before the damage goes too far. However, much damage will have occurred before it shows up on a brain scan and the damage steadily gets worse after the boxer has retired.

Horror

In terms of physical injury boxing is probably safer than, for example, football, but there is a particular horror about the sort of damage caused, since it actually alters, for the worse, the personality of the boxer.

So should boxing be banned? Both the British and American Medical Associations think it should.

I would not be unduly upset if it was but I must confess to a mixture of feelings when witnessing a match. On the one hand, I admire the skill, fitness and dedication of the fighters while on the other hand, I am revulsed by each braindamaging blow.

The fitness achieved by boxers is obviously worthwhile in itself as is the ability to defend oneself and the self-confidence that may go with it.

Some defenders of boxing say that it provides a way out of poverty and it is true that a few boxers end up rich or at least well off. Many will be mentally scarred in the process, though. Most of the money in professional boxing goes elsewhere, of course, and there must surely be better ways out of poverty.

----- pull-quotes -----

Top: Hemispheres of a normal brain. Above: Steve Watt's brain,

ighting UND

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 276

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →