Bending genders
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-07-17Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
One Thursday evening in November 1974, 44-year-old Hughie Callaghan, an unemployed labourer, stood on the platform of the New Street Railway Station in Birmingham and waved off five of his friends. They were taking the train to the Heysham ferry and from there to Belfast.
Four of Callaghan's friends were, like him, natives of the Ardoyne, although they, like the fifth man, who was from Derry, had all been settled and married in England for a considerable number of years.
Loyalty
All of them had been fairly friendly with another Ardoyne man, James McDade, who, a few days previously, had been killed in a premature explo sion in England. McDade had been claimed as an IRA Volunteer and, out of some loyalty to the dead man and his convictions, the five republican sympathisers on the train were returning to Belfast for his funeral and to use the occasion to see relatives and old friends.
After their departure, Hughie Callaghan went off drinking. In the train, despite the cause of their Journey, the tive men were in fairly jovial mood (they had had a few drinks before boarding), and they smoked and lan Jameson reviews No general release.
BEFORE i saw this film, the left grapevine suggested that it was both 'ageist' and "disablist'. This, it was contended, made it a deeply upsetting film.
In fact it is nothing of the sort. And 1 suspect the reason why No Surrender' got such bad notices on the grapevine' is that it is a vinegar-bitter send-up of Northern Ireland politics.
It is about as far as you can get from the romantic view of Northern Ireland which is so widespread on the left.
Celebration
Set in Liverpool, and starring Bernard Hill (Yosser in Boys From The Blackstuff) and Michael Angelis (Lucian, the rabbit man from The Liverbirds), it deals with the events of a New Year's celebration in a pretty crappy night club.
Lucian runs this place and Yosser is the bouncer. Between them they end up managing an evening with the local Catholic and Orange OAPs' outings booked in together by accident.
Here are two factions imported from Ireland, still battling it out in Liverpool. They have made lowintensity war on each other all their lives - in Liverpool's pubs, in ritual Orange and "Taig' gang fights, and by way of rival gaudy religious parades.
Cut off long ago from the real roots of the conflict in Northern Ireland, they still hate each other, still remain steadfastly loyal to 'the cause', green or The the Danny Morrison reviews "Error of Judgement' Chris Mullin's latest book, which re-examines the evidence that convicted five men of the Birmingham pub bombings in 1974. This review is reprinted from An Phoblacht/ Republican played cards. Within three hours the lives of the five unsuspecting men -who were not in Sinn Fein and had no connections with the IRA — would be shattered as first they experienced a Kafkaesque nightmare of being brutally interrogated about incidents ot which they were completely ignorant.
No-one had even known that they were arrested. The following night, Hughie Callaghan, returning home from a pub, opened his door and was dragged inside by a police gunman, a dozen of whom had taken over his house seven hours previously. His nightmare was just beginning.
Within three days, Hughie Callag han, Patrick Hill, Gerry Hunter, many ways, is straightforwardly sick in the main, though it is dry Liverpudlian humour.
Bleasdale mercilessly caricatures and satirises the Catholic-Orange divide. One of the chief characters is Paddy, a blind fighting-cock ex-boxer who insists on taking on Billy, the Orange leader.
Pathos
As for pathos — the obvious meaning for us to take away is sorrow at communal hatred carried, literally in one case, to the grave... No Surrender!
In search of the meaning of the film, the feminist magazine Spare Rib, interestingly, turned the "disablist' tag right around. The only people not tainted by the 'madness' of sectarianism are the people on an outing from a psychiatric hospital who also arrive at the night club. This is the main theme of the film, or so Spare Rib claimed.
A possible flaw in the film is that seems it's all full of thing" Chris Mullin. Photo: Stefano Cagnoni, Report. Richard Kellkenny, Billy Power and Johnny Walker would appear in court charged with bombing the Mulberry Bush and the Tavern in the Town public houses in Birmingham in which 21 people were killed.
In his painstaking investigation, Chris Mullin has retraced the events of that night — how the physical assaults on the men by police interrogators, which resulted in all but one signing incriminating (and contradictory) statements were covered up by furthet beatings by prison officers and convicts when the men arrived at Winson Green to tnrow its hands in the air — crazy, a 'tale told by an idiot, sound and fury, signifying noMadness Of course it is madness, and yet it has sane roots. The original conflict of settlers and natives, then of Unionists and nationalists, has been brought by the descendants of both to Liverpool, where it assumes the form of a senseless fixed hatred.
Though what is happening in Northern Ireland is tragic and terrible, it is not madness. There is an unresolved conflict that must be democratically resolved.
On the other hand, 'No Surrender' might make some who see Northern Ireland through romantic spectacles think about it a little - if they don't fend off thinking about it by dismissing the film as 'ageist' or 'disablist or simply as impermissible satire. Prison.
The experiences of the six men, who between them have served the equivalent of 72 years in jail, are by now well documented. Their innocence is also attested to by the fact that their case has become a cause celebre for such 'humanitarians" as Peter Barry and former British Home Secretary Roy Jenkins, who introduced the Prevention of Terrorism Act after the Birmingham bombings.
Mullin's research was commissioned by Independent Television's World In Action programme, which was broadcast in October that pro- not in Natahan 100% In that nan gramme the tenuous forensic evidence which triggered off the police lynching party was completely discredited by new forensic evidence which showed that the hands of anyone using an ordinary pack of playing cards would have shown traces of explosives!
However, in his book, Mullin went a step further by interviewing (at not inconsiderable risk to themselves) one of the IRA Volunteers who planted the two bombs and the Volunteer who telephoned through the warning.
Confusion
For years there has been considerable confusion about what happene at Birmingham that night. This was complicated by the fact that a British agent provocateur, Kenneth Littlejohn, who had escaped from jail in Ireland (where he had a record of carrying out actions aimed at discrediting the IRA), was then in Birmingham, staying at the home of a man who was subsequently one of the crown's prosecution witnesses against the six men.
Republicans wanted to believe that the IRA was not responsible and the IRA in Ireland initially did not have the full details. Neither did the passage of time bury an unfulfilled IRA commitment that a full statement would be issued.
With the advancement in recent years in forensic science techniques, which the World In Action used last October to demonstrably demolish the central basis of the case against the men, the IRA used the opportunity, in an effort to help clear their names, to state that its Volunteers had carried out the bombings and that they were still free. Mullin interviewed two of these men, who gave exact and convincing details of what happened, and the man who made the telephone call who explained that an adequate warning was given but was not acted upon.
Mullin's book makes compelling reading and is a powerful argument for the release of the "Birmingham Six' not the only, but just some of the innocent victims of establishment hysteria. *Have you ever imagined being a member of the opposite sex?" asked Miriam Stoppard at the opening of Wednesday's episode of "Where There's Life". Judg. ing by the audience's reaction I'm surprised she bothered, because I've seen more life in an urgent note than in this lot put together.
It always fascinates me why people go on television to reveal their personal lives and problems. Let's hope that someone out there is comforted or can gain some knowledge from listening to complete strangers reveal the intimacies that usually unfold.
"Where There's Life" deals with both social and medical problems and Miriam Stoppard (despite having a face like Our Lady of the Sorrows when she talks to people) is better at it than the likes of Clare ("go on you can tell me if you're a lesbian and black and disabled and working class and understand you, luvy") Rayner.
This episode dealt with gender. Two people talked about how and why they changed their sex and then the audience talked of their feelings about their own gender. Firstly the transsexuals:
Judy used to be a high ranking officer in the army. She spent 53 years as a man and then left her family 15 years ago to become a woman.
Mark who used to be a secretary and spent the first 27 years of his life as a woman and has spent the last 14 as a man.
Both Judy and Mark expressed similar feelings of frustration, isolation and depression before their sex changes. Mark simply said: "I felt wrong in a woman's body." They both underwent counselling, hormone treatment and finally operations. I had to laugh (though it was said in all sincerity) when Miriam Stoppard asked Mark, "But you can't be a complete physical man"
I presume she meant have you got a willy? But let's not dwell on that. What struck me most about both Mark, Judy and the audience was the overtly sexist analysis and understanding they had of their own gender.
And the reasons they gave for wanting to be either a man or a woman made me think: God help a butch woman or an effeminate man amongst this audience or worse still a gender bender!
One woman said she enjoyed being a woman because you got pampered, you could be passive, subservient and romantic!!
So that's what it's all about. 1 knew I was going wrong somewhere. No wonder men don't ask me out on dates.
Miriam turned to a man. "Do you think men and women are different?" she asked.
To which he replied, "Yes, they look different"
About as bright as a 10 watt bulb you may think, which I did.
Well it's obviously true that there are differences but no one ever mentioned why — no one ever suggested that perhaps we could be conditioned into gender roles by family, friends or society.
Or is it that we somehow come into this world bearing a gun and a beer belly if you are a man and an apron and a doll if you are a woman? Are the differences so acute or do we create them ourselves?
Socialist Organiser no. 276 17 July
----- pull-quotes -----
Surrender', Alan Bleas- dale's latest film, now on
ERRO The truth about Nac
on the •Box