Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Palestine, Zionists and Jews

Socialist Organiser no. 276, 17 July 1986 · scan p. 11 · about 522 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →

Reader request 5 Nov 2026 (the Sunderland Poly and UJS articles): in the Socialist Students in NOLS column, unsigned; transcribed from the scan; the machine reading had run in other pieces on the page (Wapping and NUM conference items). "tht" as printed.

Proofed text: read against the scan word by word; spelling, punctuation and wording are as printed.

Scan page 11

We reprint a SSiN bulletin put out at Glasgow University. Part 2 next week.

The General Meeting held on May 15 at Glasgow University passed a number of important motions on the Middle East which are largely to be welcomed: these motions championed the right of the Palestinian Arabs to self-determination and instructed the SRC to establish a scholarship for a Palestinian refugee.

What is not good is that much of the rhetoric which accompanied the motions proved that (probably unconscious) anti-semitic assumptions had insinuated themselves once again into the discourse of the Left.

Jews in the hall were declared 'guilty' of the crimes of the Israeli state. The Socialist Workers Party was particularly blameworthy here. Once again, Jewish students felt under threat from a Left which seemed oblivious to the reality of anti-semitism. Once again, Jewish students — some of whom at least are on the Left — found themselves close to tears.

And once again, the arguments of much of the Left were pervaded by a demonological conception of Zionism as a hydra-headed conspiratorial beast — which, having copulated with 'imperialism', gave birth to the devil-child of the Israeli state.

Reference was repeatedly made to 'Zionist-Imperialism' — as if this were some special mutant form of imperialism. August Bebel once described anti-semitism as the 'socialism of idiots'; anti-'Zionist-Imperialism' is surely the 'anti-imperialism of idiots'.

Those who spoke for the Labour Club and for the Socialist Worker Student Society (SWSS) seemed to share three rather dubious assumptions: that Israel is simply the 'settler-colonial' offspring of 'Imperialism'; that the 'democratic secular state' bears the solution; and tht 'Zionism' simply equals 'racism'.

Before these are mopped up, some points have to be clarified. SSiN is not pro-Zionist; we do not argue that anti-Zionist rhetoric is always implicitly anti-semitic; and we do give unconditional support to the PLO.

Whilst it is true that Jewish settlers colonised areas of Palestine, that did not make them a colony of either Imperialism-in-general' (sic) or one imperialist power in particular.

Historic Zionism (1897-1948) was a stubbornly autonomous movement shot through with massive contradictions. The idea that 'Imperialism' kitted it out as its 'policeman' in the Middle East from Day One is simply ludicrous.

Consider the historical facts. The imperialist powers in the inter-war period were not exactly in a 'Three Musketeers' mood; thus, a joint 'plot' was not on. The one power which Israel could be said to have been the 'settler-colonial outpost' of was Britain.

But Britain spent 1948 warring against the Zionists. Indeed, the left-Zionist MAPAM saw that period as a 'war of independence' which would lead to socialist revolution. They were wrong, but that is what they thought.

Israel's earliest friend was the horribly reactionary but not (capitalist-) imperialist USSR. After Suez, in 1956, of course, Israel did become a stable pro-imperialist power amid the Nasserite Arab Revolution. However, it was not really until 1967 that Israel's pact with the coryphaeus of post-war imperialism — the USA — was firmly sealed.

These facts tend to belie the mythological view of Middle Eastern history that much of the Left has imbibed from bourgeois Arab nationalism.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 276

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →