Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

What kind of action against apartheid?

Socialist Organiser no. 277, 24 July 1986 · scan pp. 5–6 · about 3,182 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 5

We should link up with the black workers' movement: Transport and stand the function of sanctions in diff- unemployment which committed Last week Bob Fine k Rah Fine looked at the history of the demand for government sanctions against South Africa. While we should support sanctions, he argued, other forms of solidarity can be more effective. This week he looks at the views of South African workers on the issue.

Many international companies are now looking for more secure hunting grounds, but they can clothe this business decision in the respectable garb of abhorence for apartheid.

As the multinationals leave, so the South African monopolies tend to buy them up at cut-price rates. Thus Anglo-American, the gold-mining giant, bought up most of Ford's and Mazda's car works, and is building its own car industry.

One of the effects of economic crisis and disinvestment has been the concentration of manufacturing industry and the further integration of manufacturing, mining and finance. But this is another story.

For all the huffing and puffing about sanctions, Both's reign of terror has gone unsanctioned by most Western governments. But suppose something could be effectively imposed: what are the arguments for them?

The oft-repeated argument is that black people in South Africa call for sanctions and that we should respond to their call. The AN has long made this call on behalf of black people in South Africa; but the ANC in my view have shown little regard for black workers.

Blacks have suffered so much, the ANC often argue, that any further suffering caused by sanctions will be of no consequence.

The only significant question is whether sanctions would or would not shorten the life-expectancy of the regime.

Now, it is true that in any strike or political protest, people have to suffer to win. But to what extent have black workers discussed the sanctions issue? The answer, I think, is very little. The ANC is speaking 'on behalf of black workers, but without any substantial mandate.

Starve Second, the ANC's call is accompanied by glib rhetoric to the effect that the workers are prepared to starve for a hundred years to overthrow apartheid. The further you are from the factory floor and the wage packet, the easier it is to make this presumption.

But the issue is not only one of suffering, but also of political effectiveness. If the workers starve, then they will never overthrow apartheid. Disinvestment will hit the manufacturing section hardest, and this is precisely where the main strength of organised labour lies.

There needs to be some perspective as to what black workers are to do when the notice on the factory gate saying: "factory closed. Capital against apartheid — moved to the Philippines' One of the problems is that it has never been spelt out just how sanctions will work. It has, indeed, been defined in quite different ways.

*Are they to pressurise the existing government into reform to avoid civil war and revolution?

*Are they to force the government to negotiate with the ANC for a transfer of power!

*Are they to weaken the government and the state and thus make it easier to overthrow it from within?

Different political forces can all solidarity. favour sanctions, since they under...Glib rhetoric to the effect that the workers a prepared starve for hundred years to overthrow apartheid...

erent ways. What is the view of black workers on the front line?

At the Congress of South African Trade Unions' inaugural conference, a resolution was passed giving general support to the disinvestment campaign. It is worth looking carefully at the resolution. It reads as follows:

*This conference believes that all forms of international pressure on the South African government, including disinvestment or the threat of disinvestment is an essential and effective form of pressure on the South Africa regime and we support it.

*Further believes that if this government remains intransigent in its racist, anti-democratic and anti-worker practice, then this pressure will have to increase as an act of solidarity with our struggle for liberation...

*Commits ourselves to ensure that the social wealth of South Africa remains the property of the people of South Africa for the benefit of all, and further commits ourselves to the principle of international working class solidarity action as the most powerful form of solidarity action...

We see here three main elements:

*Support by the unions for international sanctions as a particular form of pressure on the regime, thugh the unions fall short of calling for sanctions.

A commitment to the wealth of the multinationals remaining in South Africa.

*A' commitment

pa

solidarity as the most powerful Pertinent also was the resolution on COSATU to "defend all jobs threatened by retrenchments" (redundancies) and "fight the closing of the factories in attempts to rationalise production".

Clause 6 of COSATU's constitution calls for COSATU to reinforce and encourage "progressive and international worker contacts".

Alec Erwin, education officer of one of COSATU's forerunners, FOSATU argued cogently that all the assets of foreign companies belong to the South African workers whose labour has produced and reproduced them. As far as the unions are concerned, the multinationals have no right to withdraw these assets. Erwin seems to support the withdrawal of foreign companies, but not of their assets.

What is to be done with these assets? They could be sold to South African monopolies — as is already happening (though Bishop Tutu has a rather hairbrained scheme to set up a trust to buy up foreign companies).

A further option is to place demands on the South African government to nationalise the multinationals: but I've not seen much evidence of the unions pushing in this direction, unsurprisingy in light of the 'civilised labour' policies persued by many industries already run by the racist state.

Finally, workers. could occupy factories threatened with closure and try to run them, under system of workers' control as happened in Russia in 1917 and in Italy two years later. For this option to work, however, there would have to be maior developments in both the economic and political wings of the workers" movement.

The only alternative to these options is yet more unemployment. So the nearer you get to the workers, the harder the disinvestment issue becomes. It's one thing to espouse disinvestment from London or Lusaka, and another to see the notice on the factory gate declaring the factory closed as a protest against apartheid.

Discussed

It appears from reports in the South African Labour Bulletin that the disinvestment issue was never widely discussed by workers before the COSATU conference.

The resolution was adopted partly due to ANC pressures via the United Democratic Front and its affiliated unions; and partly, I think, simply because the unions had not thought much about the question and were ready to adopt the only political programme at hand -that of the ANC. General AGM in Soweto form of Partly this was because the left wing metal union, MAWU, supported disinvestment on the basis of their terrible experience of the British company. BTR, and its anti-labour policies at Sarmacol (where it fired the entire workforce for striking for union recognition). The general feeling was that if this was how foreign companies behaved, better to do without them.

Since then, I've heard, MAWU -recognising the problem of redundancies — has called for a revision of the COSATU resolution, in order to prioritise the clauses on international working class solidarity and opposition to factory closures, before those on sanctions and disinvestment.

As I understand it this was ruled out of order by the COSATU executive, and will have to wait until the next conference.

Hunger

Buthelezi has been mobilising against both the ANC and COSATU on an anti-disinvestment position. Jobs not hunger' is Buthelezi's slogan, implying that a vote for COSATU is a vote for unemployment. How much resonance this line has among workers is hard to gauge. Certainly Buthelezi's intention is to lay the blame for unemployment at least in part on the sanctions campaign and the support it gets from the ANC and COSATU.

The main appeal of the sanctions campaign lies in the idea that something must be done in the face of apartheid terror. But the fact that sanctions appear to be the only weapon available and that they seem to be exclusive of other forms of action is a tribute to years of lack of imagination and lack of working class perspective induced by Workers' Liberty special on South Africa: 75p plus

by the AN and the Anti-Apartheid

by the ANC and Movement.

Sanctions have their place, but as a tactic not a fetish. The central problem with sanctions is that in place of persuing an attack on capital initiated by the trade union movement in South Africa, it focuses the attack on apartheid alone, looking on the multinationals almost as potential allies.

The demand is on capital to disinvest - rather than grant trade union rights, pay a living wage, or provide liveable conditions. Instead of calling for the socialisation of the ownership of the means of production, it calls for their withdrawal.

The old EEC code of conduct for firms in South Africa is now discredited. Its content was weak, falling a long way short of union demands in South Africa and there was little attempt to enforce it or to punish violators.

However, the code has certain virtues. What if the labour movement here fought for a new code with much tougher provisions generated from the South African unions themselves?

What if the labour movement here liaised with unions in South Africa on the inspection and enforcement of this new labour code?

What if the labour movement pressured the government to adopt and enforce it and to impose sanctions on any company which refused to abide by its conditions?

Links What if the labour movement here committed itself to active support for unions in South Africa fighting such companies?

These are things we could do beyond putting all our eggs in the sanctions basket.

There are other ways of attacking apartheid than by appealing to capital to do it for you. The great wave of popular solidarity with the struggle against apartheid may be wasted if all its energies are directed into the sanctions campaign. The sanctions campaign is unlikely ever to be effective — given that it is capitalists and capitalist states who are going to have to enforce it.

If it is effective in seriously damaging the South African economy, the political consequences are uncertain in the extreme, unless it is closely linked to the struggle for power in South Africa and to the needs of the black workers' movement.

The sanctions campaign is no substitute for direct links and positive acts of solidarity, including workers' sanctions, with the struggles of workers, women, students and other activists in South Africa. Solidarity with those in struggle must come first.

struggle for liberation in South Africa Socialist Organıser no.277

Scan page 6

plant were attacked by iotpolice. The Battle for Orgpeave, _written by striking those pickets, or the police: wollenice against them and th erattempitbay the state to namerup 15 mmensson changer tor terruying ner majesty s suujeuts quesuon us prejune tun AAMATE charged with riot — and breaking his perspective for men.

fact that his bail conditions did not bar and outside prison, is one of class not first group of miners to stand trial on the charge of riot at Orgreave. The charge carries a possible life sentence.

*The Battle for Orgreave" is his account of what led up to that day - 18 June 1984 — and the trial a year later. During that trial the prosecution's case was exposed as such blatant lying that it was abandoned after 48 days.

What I liked best about Bernard Jackson's book is the way in which many of the lessons to be learned from the strike crop up as part of the narrative rather than as part of a lecture to the reader about the nature of the state, of justice, etc. It is refreshing to see much of what we understand as Marxism expressed in everyday working class language.

Bernard Jackson begins with the prosecution's address on the opening day of the trial: "Members of the jury, the objects I have around me here this axe, ball bearings, nails, a wooden mallet, this metal bar... . The Prosecutor went on to paint a picture of a beleaguered and battered, but patient and constrained police force tacing thousands of miners intent on doing as much damage and violence as possible: *They tore down walls and lamp posts, fences and paving stones. Spears and Molotov cocktails and nail obstacles were used...

It was all the police could do to try to stop their lines being broken to clear the field at the top side of the plant.

Jackson comments bitterly:

"At the age of 43 1 became a rioter overnight. A bully boy, a thug, a mindless hooligan and an enemy of my own country. I wasn't really aware of the change, in fact I thought I was quite happy as a craftsman miner, as President of Wath NUM and as a governor of two schools with a fourteen year old boy to bring up."

Bernard then goes on to tell something of the strike itself, of picketing at Orgreave and the events of that day, his time in prison, and the restrictions of his bail conditions, designed to keep him from actively participating in the strike.

The strike was three weeks old in GREAVE parts of South Yorkshire before it became a national dispute. Management had tried to force changes in meal break times in the pits that make up the Manvers complex, of which Wath is a part, so as to get round the overtime ban. When they tried to implement it at Manvers the men walked out and Wath (whose coal comes out at Manvers) were sent home without pay.

They went for support to the Panels (made up of delegates from each pit in the area and to the pits themselves. Support was mixed with some ready to go and others hesitant.

Canteen Notably at Cortonwood the branch secretary threw them out of the canteen to stop them talking to the men! I was told many a time at Wath: "Cortonwood didn't start this strike -but don't print it just yet. It'll all come out after"

Then when the NCB announced the closure of Cortonwood, which had promised nine years of life a few months earlier, no one had any doubts about the scale of pit closures threatened.

Picketing was successful at first: At Creswell in Derbyshire they came out to a man and other teams of pickets had similar results. That was peaceful picketing. There's over a thousand men at Creswell and they were all out, persuaded not by intimidation and violence but by a twenty man picket. But once out they were subjected to the Orgreave, June 1984. Photo: John Harris. right-wing undermining of their own leadership and gradually drifted back. So we went back and explained the case again and out they came again.' So the police put a stop to it.

"No one will ever know how many police were drafted into the coalfields but the official figure is about fourteen thousand. If anyone has ever had any doubt about the real role of the police the fact that, at the drop of a hat, so many could be removed from their normal duties should have answered them.

Fourteen thousand police taken away from preventing crime and detecting criminals. A striking miner was considered a greater threat to the state than the most ruthless villain. But WHOSC SLaLC Picketing became better organised to get round the police roadblocks. The police became more and more vicious.

*The nastiest incident 1 recall was at Creswell and it will live with me for a long time. Police lifted a very slightly built young lad and searched him. They found what little money he had on him and tore the notes up in front of his face, the small change was flung away into the fields. Iney men ser about him.

"An oldish lady immediately came running out of a nearby house shouting at the top of her voice: Leave him alone, he's done nowt.' She had her hand inside her coat and was holding something which looked like a camera.

There was no hesitation. She received a fist straight in the face and went flying backwards over a privet hedge. What she had tried to make look like a camera was a tin of food. She picked herself up and with tears rolling down her face ran back indoors."

On the day of the "riot" itself Berwho should have been supporting us, the Kinnocks and Willises, pompously condemning picket line violence when they had never been on or near a picket line, when openly and arrogantly the state was intent on smashing working class organisations. How dare they pretend to represent, to speak for the working class? History will judge them and it will not forgive easily."

After a long and frustrating wait in police cells Bernard Jackson was remanded to Armley Jail for one week bail conditions of an earlier arrest. The him from Orgreave, which was BSC property, was not considered relevant.

He describes the experience of jail, the treatment by the warders, the lousy food, the cold. The only people who showed any warmth on learning he was a miner were the other inmates. "It reminded me of a demonstration which had taken place outside Leicester Police Station when some of the first miners were locked up. The union area involvement because a realisation had dawned on me — the thing I missed most, after my family, was picketing. I was now a non-combattant. I had been removed from the fight."

And Bernard says he learnt a few things: "I'd never met many black or Asian people before, but there were plenty of them in Armley, and they were at the bottom of the pecking order, particularly for the screws. I found them as friendly and supportive as the other men in there, and the anaction of mindina tank on a neu the problem faced by blacks, inside race. The struggle against racialism and the struggle for socialism are one and the same - of that I'm now convinced.

"And these are the people for whom the government is set on providing more and more prisons. As their policies increasingly produce a society of haves and have-nots, a way has to be found to control the have-nots. It is the prison which does it. For the first time in my life i saw with utter clarity the

----- pull-quotes -----

Mo on South Africa

18p postage from SO, PO Box 823, London SE15

WORKERS' LIBERTY Breaking the chains

offerior. Bernard Jackson was one of the

face with riot dragged the through police

was smashed in the a riot shield and then shield and by the neck back lines.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 277

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →