Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

How it all started

Socialist Organiser no. 277, 24 July 1986 · scan p. 9 · about 964 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

Belinda Weaver reviews 'Women's W Men's Property', edited by Stephanie and Peta Henderson (Verso, £6.95). *It is not the woman who begets the one who is called the child: she is merely the nurse of the germ she has conceived. The one who begets is the male; like a foreigner she preserves the young shoot". So speaks Apollo in Aeschylus's Eumenides.

Rather extreme! As an attack on women, it reflects the fantasies of a male community (Ancient Greece) which knows it needs women for childrearing, but which dreams of doing without them.

How male dominance came to the point of denying women's role in child-bearing is examined in a new book, *Women's work, men's property: the origins of gender and class" • a collection of five articles edited by Stephanie Coontz and Peta Henderson.

Oppressed

Feminists today know we are oppressed. But many disagree on why. Is it human nature, in which case not much can be done about it? Or something about the way society is organised? But each society in recorded history has inherited and adapted women's oppression from the society before it. So how did it all start?

The authors emphatically reject biological or "natural" explanations -male hormones make men more aggressive; women are smaller and weaker, etc.

The authors believe of women's oppressio the development of social production and exchange.

The role of women in production -what work they did and for whose benefit - is the basis for sex stratification rather than women's powers of reproduction.

Women were downtrodden before the emergence of private property and the state. Male domination of women was a foundation for traditional class society.

The authors do have some differences. Chevillard and Leconte, for example, consider the way in which women's work became men's property in the earliest societies to be class oppression; Coontz and Henderson call it sex oppression.

Chevillard and Leconte assert that male domination occured as a violent break with the past; Coontz and Henderson state that it evolved gradually.

Leibowitz's study of early humans shows how an informal division of labour, i.e., men hunting, women gathering food and caring for young, became rigid and codified once products began to be exchanged between groups.

Since people wete excha narriages) between groups as m goods chan cook and process hides, for example.

This does not explain male domination since both sets of skills were necessary and valued.

Coontz and Henderson argue that the system of patrilocality, where women join their husbands' kin group after marriage, led to the oppression of women. When the woman joins the husband's kin group, she enters it as a producer, but not as an owner.

The goods produced by in-marrying women are usurped by male group leaders for use and exchange. To increase goods available for exchange, women are pressured to produce more.

Patrilocal systems were more efficient economically than earlier matrilocal groups (for rather complicated reasons, so they spread by example.

Chevillard and Leconte assert that patrilocality appeared as a violent break from the past. Matrilocal systems (where men joined their wives' kin groups, and where women, not men, controlled the surplus products) must have been overthrown by wars in which men came out on top an were th us able to establish a their socially inferior status, and they were angry and rebellious.

Euripides's Medea, who murd lered her children in revenge for her husband's taking another, younger wife, shows that men were aware that women could react violently to forced subjugation.

Women's position in slave societies like Ancient Greece was like slavery. Female slaves were often worse off than male slaves, whose children could at least be born free. So-called "free" women were excluded from public life, could not own property and were forced to live secluded in the home, where they shared some tasks with slaves.

Revolt In lineage societies, women must provide for themselves, their husbands and children. Women do all the work (including agriculture) but can own nothing. Men expropriate the fruits of women's labour and busy themselves with warfare and ceremonies, and in the dry season "to overcome their boredom...men make tools, armaments or do their hair"

Women are forbidden to bear arms which suggests that men fear female revolt.

History shows thi were fin Nothing.

The American Trotskyist James P. Cannon once compared boxing to a poisonous weed that grows on the dung heap of capitalist society.

Despite what people claim about other sports being just as dangerous or worse than boxing in terms of injuries and accident related deaths, there is no other sport which is as brutal and vulgar. It upsets me and sickens me.

At the end of the day it is basically about two people beating the shit out of eachother for as long and as hard as they can take it. Yes, of course there is skill and judgement involved like in any sport, and like other sports the ultimate aim is to win.

But it's how you win. In boxing you get the applause, prestige and millions by hurting, disfiguring and knocking the sense out of someone you admire for their own skills. God only know what they do to their enemies!

Now don't get me wrong. I'm not a pacifist or anything like that.

am favour of the working class defending themselves from the state, but boxing seems to me like violence for the fun of it - some sense of fun, I'll say!

Untortunately the violence didn't stop in the ring.

Some 40,000 people were at the ringside at Wembley Stadium to watch the biggest single sporting event in European history.

After the match, angry fans hurled chairs at Witherspoon when he was leaving the stadium.

Worse still, a bloke who wen ept to see Bruno defeated and West

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 277

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →