A woman's experience on a demolition job pt.6 A bad indictment of this society'
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-07-24Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
By Martin Thomas PRACTICAL MEN, who believe themselves to be quite exempt from any intellectual influence, are usually the slaves of some defunct economist"
So wrote the great Liberal economist J M Keynes, exasperated at the way in which many business people and politicians dismissed his novel ideas as theoretical fancies.
Something similar describes the relations in the labour movement between the 'non-aligned' activists and the 'left groups'. Those who most loudly insist that they won't tie themselves to a particular newspaper or group are usually all the more uncritical or thoughtless followers of some long-discarded policy line of one group or another.
Logical
And that is logical. The element of original thinking in most of us is extremely limited, and even the most original thinkers need the structure and assistance of a collective to develop their insights into theories. Karl Marx, after all, wrote the Communist Manifesto as a member of a 'left group' - the Communist League - and much of what is in the Manifesto he learned from the League and the tradition of organised socialist politics that it came from.
The ideas-people of the capitalist class have a framework of universities, journals and newspapers to work within. And they work more or less with the grain of society - even the boldest and most original thinkers among them, like Keynes.
The working class has no equivalent except its own parties and movements. And such is the pressure of capitalist society on the working class that most of the big parties and movements become 'schools' for ideas that soothe and control the working class, rather than ideas for its self-liberation.
The basic ideas of socialism are constantly watered down and diluted. Some workers always want to challenge that dilution. But how? Unless they organise in a 'left group' or around a paper, all they can do is react knee-jerk fashion against the right wing and pick up whatever left-seeming alternatives are to hand. That's why Stalinism has been able to divert so many revolutionary-minded workers.
Guarantee
We need to organise if we are to uphold, spread, and develop the ideas of real working-class socialism. Being organised does not, of course, guarantee clear ideas. Many left groups and papers have ignorant, confused, misleading ideas. But then the answer is to have a better group or paper.
The debates between left groups may look like mindless point-scoring. No doubt they do in fact contain a good proportion of folly. But they are the workshop in which revalutionary ideas backed by organisation will, or will not, be developed. And that makes them crucial.
July 1986 I had always, up till this time, fancied myself as being pretty sharp when it came to dealing with sexism. I had the reputation in the Post Office of being "hard".
spoken about sexual harassment and talked with other women about it, feeling subconsciously pretty confident that if it ever happened to me I could handle it. Ha! Such ignorance!
I had never dreamed of the crushing effects that it has upon you, both mentally and physically - but especially physically. Because it is not just words. A bit of clever repartee can deal with mere words. It's a whole attitude and outlook of men who want to put women in "their place" and are prepared to act on it.
Isolated
And if you are isolated amongst a lot of men who basically think the same, it is very difficult to combat.
As far as Alan was concerned, I had a "fanny" and my place was either at home with the kids or putting it out to men like him. It was definitely not in a builders' yard, and he was going to let me know it.
The hardest thing about dealing with it was the isolation. If there had been even one other woman to just raise an eyebrow to when Alan started, as if to say, "here he goes again" , I could have kept it in perspective. But there was no-one. The other men either enjoyed it or kept quiet.
And, being on your own, you start to wonder if it's you — if you're the one who's acting weird. "Maybe I'm imagining things. " 'Maybe I'm taking this too seriously" . Alan's behaviour at times was so childish it would have been laughable — if there had been someone to laugh with.
when we lere sit to a headerhut., as usual, was reading my paper, keeping my head down and talking to no-one. Alan, as usual, was talking filth. I can't remember the actual words anymore. Thank god. But take it from me, it was vile, insulting stuff and all designed for my discomfort.
After a while Dippo, who enjoyed Alan's behaviour immensely because it kept the pressure off him, the usual scapegoat, asked Alan if he'd seen the latest Unipart Calendar, and was he going to bring it in. That was enough!
Putting up with his talk and his dirty behaviour was bad enough. I was not going to have pictures on the wall that he could bounce comments off all dav long.
"If he does bring it in, it's not going up", I said. Alan smiled — at last, a fight! "Why not?" "Because I find it offensive," I said. "I find you and your filthy mouth offensive and I think you have a problem and should see a doctor"
All the while I was saying this, I was reddening and stammering and shaking. It was part of a great speech I'd worked out in my mind one sleepless night when the pills wouldn't work. But, of course, it never comes out right when you need it.
Alan beamed. *If vou're going to do a man's job you'll have to take what comes with it. " It was the first time he'd actually come out straight with what he was up to.
I got furious. I grabbed his lapel and shouted into his face, *This is not a man's job. This is my job. And if you can't take my being here, you leave.
Another part of a great speech...but after all the weeks of putting up with his innuendos, being alone and losing confidence. 1 blushed. stammered and became inarticulate. Alan went out of the hut with his mates, laughing and joking — the hero of the day.!
I started to cry. There was one man left in the room, Dave the brickie, and I was mortified letting him see me cry.
Dave was older than most of the others, married with four kids. He didn't like Alan or his behaviour. Mainly, I think, because he didn't think you should act like that in front of women rather than because it was offensive in itself. But by that time support on any basis was good enough.
Startled
We started to talk about it. When I called what was happening sexual harassment' he looked startled and suggested that I was exaggerating. He'd heard of it before but didn't recognise it in Alan's behaviour. He thought of it as bum-pinching and sexual favours for. promotion - that kind of thing. But he accepted what I Jean Lane continues her account of her experiences as a woman worker on a male-dominated demolition job. This week she tells the story of how low-level jokes and comments led up to a concerted attempt by one man to drive her off the job, and how he was defeated.
said eventually.
I then told him that if you take verbal harassment, physical sexual assault and rape altogether, then I did not know of any woman who hasn't suffered it in one form or another at some time in her life. He again looked startled.
Finally he said: *That means that out of my wite and three daughters one of them is quite likely to suffer it in its worst form at some time?" I said "Yes" . He sat down and became visibly distressed. "That's a pretty bad indictment of this society isn't it?"
We spent the rest of the afternoon working together and talking about various aspects of the same subject. He had also thought that rape was committed by sex-starved old men in dark alleys. But he was open-minded enough to accept my facts and figures about rape being carried out in the most part by husbands, boyfriends, fathers, etc., at home.
As luck would have Dave spoke his wife that night about what had happened and she backed me up. Also, that very night, there was a film on TV about sexual harassment at work - a slightly romanticised but nevertheless pretty accurate portrayal of a working class woman whose job and livelihood was threatened by it, and its effects on her private and social life. This drove the lesson even further home.
That same night I again lay sleepless in bed and then finally decided that I needed to get help. I was prepared to go to my gaffer and to the council next day to report it. Going to the union was going to be a non-starter as the bloke there was as sexist as the rest and would certainly not take it seriously.
Just getting that one supporter had made all the difference in the world and I realised that I had been stupid in trying to deal with it alone.
The next morning I told the gaffer that I had been having problems with one of the men and may want to take it through the grievance procedure.
I wanted to see if Alan was going to bring his calendar in and carry on where he'd left off. But Alan was off work that day and Dave and I continued our discussions. The previous evening Dave had persuaded his eldest daughter to take self-defence classes!
The next day Dave and I came into the tea-hut to hear Alan saying to one of the other bloke how disgusting it was that a judge should be caught kerb-crawling. (There was an article on it in the Mirror that day). I said "1 thought kerb-crawling would be right up your street, Alan" . To which he replied, "I would never go to a prostitute. " "Alan," I said, "a prostitute with any sense would never come to you" "No, because I wouldn't pay her I don't have to pay for mine."
"She'd have bigger and better reasons than that, " I said, and waited for the backlash.
But to my surprise the backlash never came. He just looked crushed and embarrassed.
Threatened
I later found out that Dave had talked to a couple of the other blokes about Alan's behaviour and, deciding that enough was enough, they had taken him out and threatened him with a beating up if he didn't pack it in.
Dave had also gone to the gaffer, quite independently from me, and told him that if I raised any complaint of any kind, he would back my statements Alan left soon afterwards having found a full-time job — night security man in a police training centre! Not many openings for-harassing women there.
-Unfortunately Dave left not long after that, fortunately he'd also got a job.
From the day Alan was threatened with a beating my working conditions immediately got better. It might not have been a very orderly way of dealing with the problem and it might not have been for the best of motives (I think it was still on the basis that you don't behave like that in front women) but it was heaven for me.
I went back to enjoying my work — lifting great slabs of sandstone, knocking out chimney breasts and driving my pick-up truck!
The pay was abysmal, but at least I could sleep at night.
I was constantly aware, however, that it would only take another Alan to turn up (and there are plenty of them about) for the whole process to begin again. Except that next time I would be wiser about dealing with it.
The final part of Jean Lane's series will appear in next week's Socialist Organiser.
----- pull-quotes -----
ARXISM need to
During my years as a socialist and of being in the women's movement I have