A Wapping wedding
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-08-07Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 2 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 2
Wapping pickets celebrated the Royal Wedding by unloading reels of newsprint from lorries on their way to Murdoch's plant — but the police became literally "paper boys for Murdoch'. Photo: Andrew Wiard, public services and industry, all of which will require a genuine socialist The Left knows full well the supreme transformation with a major extension importance of analysis and debate in of common ownership and selfthe formulation of policy, but we must not allow factionalism or sectarianism 3. We insist upon an end to all discrito obscure the arguments and we mination against women, blacks and should always speak in language that is gays and minority groups, a restoration of civil liberties and we must make the That is why we must present our police responsible to the communities case constructively, and not be tempted into responding, in kind, to person- 4. We must get Britain out of Ireal attacks made upon us by others in land, all American forces out of Brithe movement, which we should com- tain, secure substantial cuts in the arms budget, and a real UN peace The Left has always rejected narrow policy, outside NATO that allows us to electoralism, when it has taken over use some of the resources released to from principle, and we must see that go to development here and in the third we do not adopt an 'electoralism within world, as part of a non-aligned foreign an electoralism' which implies that if we could only defeat right-wing candi- 5. We must protect the natural envirdates and substitute left-wing candi- onment, phase out all nuclear power dates at every level in the movement, all our problems would be solved.
The Left should always avoid personTony Benn was speaking at a public ality politics like the plague, and have meeting in London on 22 July organisno heroes and no scapegoats and remember that success will only come ed by the Campaign Group of MPs. when a strong and united mass movement can be built up. That is the only The Left must now address the nation on the central questions that concern those we represent, and to do so from inside the Labour Party, in the 1. We must demand work for all, good homes, lifelong education, a free health service, an end to poverty, and dignity for those who have retired, and be sure that neither the EEC nor the IMF are allowed to prevent us from 2. We must insist upon the reestablishment of trade unionism free from all government control, upon democracy in local government, the now very familiar. ist parties prevented it being enacted to cover the six counties. The Northern Ireland Abortion Law community as a whole.
Reform Association campaigns for the extension Report. of the 1967 Act to the north of Ireland, but Sinn Fein won't be part of this campaign, saying it legiti- do, helps and does not hinder mises the role of the Brit- sibility. ish state in Ireland. we espouse.
management. Order clear and plain.
ignored. that they are there to serve. imposed Popular pletely ignore.
Some semblance of order has been imposed upon war-torn Lebanon - by the occupying have been of the Left.
Syrian army. A Syriansponsored "security policy. plan' has won support strong it really is in Britain. from the government, the Lebanese army and and protect the animal kingdom, the Islamic fundamentalist militias.
The Syrian-backed Lebanese army now controls at least Cabinet. some of the streets in the capital of Beirut - a city devastated by route we can take.!
over 10 years of civil LABOUR wars, and Syrian and Israeli invasions.
Last month battleweary Lebanon saw a form of clear demands.
ahead of the party leadership. glimmer of hope for the future: a nationwide Discrimination general strike united Christian and • Moslem factions in closing down shops, banks, leisure Join now facilities, TV stations, newspapers and the international airport. Join the Labour Party!
The strike was in achieving these objectives. opposition to terrible Write to 150 Walworth and deteriorating econRoad, London SE17 omic conditions.
Scan page 3
Hostility to Militant should not lead anyone to support the witch-hunt. Photo: lan Swindale. THERE ARE many striking things about the current witchhunt' in the Labour Party.
One is that it is being conducted by the Party and trade union machine against a section of that machine - controlled by Militant, which ran the Party in Liverpool using traditional bureaucratic methods.
By far the most striking thing, however, is that this witch-hunt is in part being conducted by one section of the left against another.
But the left witch-hunters of today are hardly better than the old-style Labour policemen of yesterday.
The weekly paper "Tribune' best expresses the new approach of these Labour Party police-state democrats. It doesn't argue about the issues — for example the issue of what a future government will have to do.
It makes war on "Trotskyism' without even a working definition of what "Trotskyism' is.
There are difficulties, of course. Historic Trotskyism is the set of ideas that Trotsky took over and preserved when the Stalinist rulers of the USSR annexed the Communist International and changed it from revolutionary working-class politics to service for the foreign policy of the USSR.
But Trotsky has been dead 46 years. On the basis of more or less real adherence to a common stock, vastly divergent groups call themselves Trotskyist. Some, like Militant, call themselves Trotskyist who do not even subscribe to basic ideas of Leninism like the impossibility of a peaceful road to socialism.
To put it briefly, if Socialist Organiser's claim to be Trotskyist - to be in anything like the direct political and doctrinal line of descent from the ideas that Trotsky would have called Trotskyist in August 1940 — is valid, then Militant's claim to be Trotskyist is invalid. And vice versa.
As everyone knows the Daily Mirror is Britain's leading pro-Labour national newspaper. To be exact it's Britain's only pro-Labour national newspaper. However.
So naturally it was to the Mirror that I turned for a firm line on this whole apartheid/sanctions/Commonwealth Games boycott business. Ringing denunciations of Thatcher's complicity with the apartheid regime; How not to get expelled Last week's But Tribune has it both ways. Its target, "Trotskyism' , can be attacked for any of the ideas and practices of any of the various different would-be Trotskyist groups, For example, commitment to parliamentary democracy is the banner around which the Kinnockites have rallied, and the club, wielded like a bishop's crozier of olden times, with which the heretics are smitten.
It is used against Militant. But Militant believes in the possibility of a parliamentary road to socialism! Today it talks of no other road: and a full 20 years ago, in the privacy of small editorial board meetings, the leaders of the Militant tendency insisted against the now editor of SO that we could, and very probably would, get a peaceful transition to socialism in Britain.
The demon "Trotskyism' is attacked and smeared by identification with Militant, and Militant is attacked and smeared by association with the general stock of ideas of Trotskyism - in this case, ideas that it does not agree with.
It's typical of the whole level of the "debate' . It is not a debate but an ultimatum: support parliamentary democracy as we define it, or be branded as wrecker.
Take the recent column by Jack Straw MP denouncing Trotsky and the Bolshevik regime for having retaken by force a key fortress on the outskirts of Petrograd in March 1921, at the end of the Russian civil war.
Some of the rebels raised anarchist' slogans and presented themselves as newspaper proprietor of the old school, he made sure that his organs became mouthpieces for his displeasure.
Politics must be kept out of sport; the boycotters are only harming their own cause; these are Scotland's games, not Thatcher's; proclaimed the Maxwell press.
NO wanting something better than the existing workers' regime — in conditions of famine and destruction which made it impossible. But they had taken the key fortress at Kronstadt, The Russian workers' state gave them an ultimatum and then attacked the fortress. Visiting delegates for the 10th Bolshevik Party congress in Petrograd joined the Red Army and attacked the fortress across the ice, under the guns of its garrison.
That vicious act, says Straw, shows up Lenin and Trotsky.
They would have been true democrats, of course, if they had refused to defend the workers' state and instead let it dissolve into chaos.
But the argument is ludicrous. Jack Straw is not a naive anarchist. He is someone who 'came up' in politics by way of the National Union of Students in the 1960s and wants to be a minister. Like others of his ilk, he has no hesitation about supporting the armed force of the British capitalist state. jeered by an angry crowd."
The Mirror ommitted to mention that Cap'n Bob was personally responsible for inviting Thatcher (even falling out with Edinburgh District Council over the matter) and had insisted that she must be met with "the courtesy with which her position demands"
Anyway, all's well that ends well, The Sunday Mirror assured us that "the Commonwealth Games have been Take the idea that you could have a peaceful surrender by the British ruling class if enough people voted for socialism. What's the argument here?
Nowhere, ever, has any ruling class meekly submitted to its own destruction when it had the means to defend itself. The British ruling class does have the means to defend itself. It has an army, a police force, a permanent bureaucracy, etc.
On the basis of the facts of known history, in all times and countries, the idea that the ruling class would surrender to an election verdict is utterly bizarre. It flies in the face of experience and reason. To believe it you have to be very stupid, or not have thought about the question - or be the most blinkered of blinkered dogmatists.
In fact, disguised behind this old 'reform-or-revolution' debate is something else: whether or not socialism is qualitatively different from capitalism. That's what's hidden behind the dogmatic dispute. What really divides us from the Kinnockites on "peaceful methods' is that we want socialism; they want modified capitalism.
Ás Kinnock steers steadily to the right, the question is posed to the soft left: how far will you go with him? If Kinnock and his team win the next election. and behave as the last Labour government did, or worse, what will you do then?
The witch-hunt is no answer! But meanwhile it spreads. Others beside Militant supporters are expelled, people who are soft-left or even... Tribunites.
Kilroy-S riddance The resignation of Robert KilroySilk as Labour MP for Knowlsey North has intensely angered Neil Kinnock because he has upset his efforts to bring the left wing activists in the Party to heel. Long before retiring to take the Chiltern Hundreds, Kilroy-Silk took to a posh house in Buckinghamshire, which he considered to be a fitting place to represent constituents who lived 200 miles away.
The Knowlsey North constituency is made up principally of the town of Kirkby - an archipelago of mainly sub-standard housing estates built in the late '50s and early "60s to accommodate Liverpool's overflow popula tion from inner-city slum areas such as Scotland Road.
Early propaganda portrayed Kirkby as a 'New Jerusalem' where workers and their families could cavort with cows in leafy meadows. However, new slums merely replaced the old, and the years of recession have made Kirkby even more of a desert. Unemployment is chronic, housing conditions on estates like Tower Hill are among the worse in the country, Kilroy-Silk is one of those career politicians who think the working class is duty bound to provide them with a living. On becoming MP in 1974, he enjoyed a cosy relationship with the old corrupt right wing Party in Kirkby. He got on with trying to map out a career for himself in Parliament, while some of them got on with the local business, which — according to what local people believe - mainly involved bent construction deals. Kirkby once voted for an artificial ski-slope which slalomed right down to the local motorway.
After a decade or so in Parliament, Kilroy-Silk began to realise that he was not going to be Prime Minister. Worse still, an influx of activists in the local Party had the gall to criticise him for his performance as MP. These two factors decided Kilroy-Silk to throw in the towel and move onto to pastures new.
He put his resignation down to "three miserable years at the hands of Militant" in his constituency. This explanation is, as Kinnock quite rightly said, "rubbish" . There are very few Militant supporters in Kirkby. People simply oppose Kilroy-Silk because they considered him to be a bad MP.
He also had a lot of backing from the Party hierarchy against the attempts locally to ditch him: The re-selection process was suspended last November, Nevertheless, raising the spectre of Militant does make good copy, especially if you're out for a career in the media. Already Silk has a serialisation of his forthcoming book 'Hard Labour' bought up by the Murdoch press for at least £20,000. A very tidy sum for one so hard done by!
The Labour Party is better off withSilk and their like. Their actions simpy. out the likes of Golding, prove critics right who say they are merely out for what they can get. 01-639 7965.
Verest kate tormeponuss firet
----- pull-quotes -----
and the leading front runner, Tony Mulhearn, has since been expelled from the Labour Party.