Class: words and meaning
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-08-07Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
WHEN WE call Derek Hatton Flash Harry", is that a disgrace? In the '60s, when left-wingers would jeer at the dapper, gentlemanly turn-out of the railworkers' leader Sid Greene, was that shameful?
Trivialities
Is the traditional Trotskyist jibe against the pious 'gentlemen' who lead the labour movement a game with irrelevancies? When Fred Engels bemoaned the fact that the engineers' leader of his day, Tom Mann, was 'secretly more proud of his friendship with the Lord Mayor of London than of his position with the workers' , was he descending to trivialities?
I don't think so. And for that reason I think Helen McHale (SO276) is wide of the mark to condemn our jibe at Brenda Dean as a 'lady' True, 'lady' (like "gentleman') is used in a variety of senses - but I don't think any reasonable reader could doubt that SO was using it in the class sense (of which all the others are, after all, derivatives).
COLIN FOSTER, Islington, Editor's note: At this point / think should confess that the use of svelte in the controversial article was illiterate. It was used to mean smooth, sleek, well-groomed. My dictionary says it means, centrally, slender, light, slim. For readers who knew the right meaning, it would make the epithet read like an (inaccurate) comment on Ms Dean's body. Sorry! But it's interesting that none of those who found the epithet offensive have pointed out this misuse of svelte".