One Lack Died Nobody Charge
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-08-07Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 5
Put resources into the estates 69% of all adults on the estate, and 83% of young black men, have no job.
The estate is 50% black, but that is not exceptional for Tottenham. The whole borough of Haringey has a 44% black population, and Tottenham, its most working class area, has a higher proportion.
Broadwater Farm differs from many other estates mainly in having better tenants' organisation. The Youth Association has organised an office for itself, meals and outings for pensioners, a day nursery and a play centre, an annual festival, and a number of cooperative enterprises on the estate.
But the Youth Association was not and is not some sort of revolutionarv organisation threatening the State. In February 1985 it organised a reception for Princess Diana./ Figures According to police figures, crime rates on the estate dropped sharply after 1983. The Gifford Inquiry got its own crime survey done by a team who had recently surveyed the neighbouring borough of Islington: 12% of people on Broadwater Farm had had their homes burgled in the previous 12 months, as against 23% in Sussex ward, Islington; 6% had had their homes vandalised, as against 42% in Sussex ward Nevertheless, 57% of people Broadwater Farm thought that crime was a 'big problem' - fewer than the 94% who considered unemployment a "big problem', but more than the 29% who were similarly concerned about police behaviour.
The crimes they were most concerned about were sexual assaults on women and heroin dealing.
In summer 1985, according to the Gifford report, drug dealing increased markedly on the estate. The tenants' groups wanted the police to arrest the pushers. The police were dubious about going in in force, and suggested that the tenants' groups should invite them in. The tenants' leaders replied that it was the police's responsibility, not theirs.
This impasse was a result of the whole pattern of relations between the police and the estate. The report quotes a local Tory councillor, no less: *The police do not like the youths.. The Police, because they are scared, rather than going in twos to investigate crime in the ordinary way, start to go in mob-handed"
And a community worker: the police would usually be reluctant to respond to calls by residents, but every so often Diana Minns, The Report's analysis of the police action at Broadwater Farm is, so far as I can see, as near to the truth as anyone will ever get. I also think the Report is important for what it says needs to be done on estates like Broadwater Farm. It shows that the action that Haringey has taken already - albeit late -like the setting up of Neighbourhood Offices, are a guide for other estates and also for other authorities with such large fighting on the estate in October last year.
Martin Thomas reviews the report of the Gifford Inquiry into last October's events.
*they'd send in the SPG (the special riot squad) and clamp down on everybody, especially black people.
About 60% of the people on the estate believe — on the basis of their own or friends' experience - that the police use threats, falsify statements and are unfair.
In October 1985 these feelings were heightened by the police shooting of Cherry Groce in Brixton, the riots which followed there, and a police stop-and-search operation on Broadwater Farm on 1 October which selectively stopped blacks. There were a lot of rumours in the area about a riot being planned, though there is no evidence that anyone did anything towards planning a riot other than talk big about it.
On 5 October Floyd Jarrett • a young black man and member of the Broadwater Farm Youth Association, though he didn't live on the estate -was arrested for driving a car with an out-of-date tax disc. The police went to town on him, hauling him into the station, and then driving round to search his mother's house (not on the estate). They burst into the house without knocking — using Floyd's keys — and jostled Mrs Jarrett. She fell over. She was already very ill, and the fall killed her.
Shocked
People on the estate were shocked. But their first response was not to rot. In the afternoon of 6 October, tenants' leaders met the police — getting a stonewall in response to their questions — and there was an angry, but not explosive, demonstration outside the local police station.
In the early evening there was a meeting on the estate. From it, youths set out to demonstrate outside the police station again. Before they got out of the estate, they met three police vans. The youths - according to eyewitnesses — banged on the vans with their hands, but not with weapons.
The police jumped out and drew truncheons. Soon there was a full-scale battle — riot shields, barricades, petrol.
chair of housing estates.
I'm reasonably satisfied with the report. It's a bit woolly in parts, but that's probably inevitable with this kind of report. It reads very well. It does pin down what happened chronologically.
In part it does put the blame on the Council - the Council did use the Farm with too little sensitivity. We're now putting resources in, and I hope that the new resources will help.
But it's not just a lesson for bombs. The fight continued for hours, until rain started around 11 pm. During it a policeman was stabbed to death.
For three months after that night, police saturated the estate. "You could not move without seeing a policeman in riot gear, " as a local Methodist minister told the inquiry.
359 people were arrested, almost all from the estate, which has 1800 adults.
162 were charged. Those arrested were taken to police stations anywhere in Londen except the local one, and held incommunicado without access to solicitors, family or friends.
One 17 year old youth, after being held for 2½ days, made a 50-page confession about what he had supposedly done during the riot — but the prosecution had to be dropped when it was proved that he had been out of London on the night of the riot!
Another black youth who was arrested had all his clothes confiscated and was told that he had been identified by his jacket. In court a cleaning ticket was produced which proved it wasn't possible for him to be wearing it on the council, told SO Broadwater Farm. It shows that only local authorities can redress the shortcomings of large estates. The government would like to break them up and privatise them, but that's not an answer.
I think the formula in the Report - a local office with decentralised services, both housing and others - proves that local authorities are the best people to be putting resources into such estates. AN night of the riot.
One black carpenter who works for council on the estate was peeling 'I love the Met' (Metropolitan Police) stickers off his car when police harassed his. He swore at the police. A few days later, six or seven police grabbed him, insulted him, and threw him into a police van, where they kicked him. Council unions organised a demonstration in protest when he was taken to court and he was acquitted. A case against the police is now in progress.
At the same time, a local (white) Labour councillor demonstrated the racist bias of the police by driving several times slowly round the estate with a photo of his cat in place of the tax disc on his car. He was never stopped.
Lord Gifford — a Labour peer - and the other members of his inquiry reckon that all this can be avoided by more consultation between senior police and tenants leaders — more community policing".
Since, according to the report, five members of the inquiry took fees of over £12,000 each from the council (the sixth, a Catholic Bishop, took no money, I suppose they have a vested interest in the idea that more committees, consultations, and inquiries will solve all social ills.
Yet the evidence they present indicates the opposite. The local police chiet, Chief Superintendant Couch, is in fact a keen advocate of community policing' . But so long as working class communities suffer the sort of economic oppression faced by Broadwater Farm, and so long as the police force is organised as a hierarchical force for the defence of private property with no democratic accountability, conflicts like October 1985 will not be exceptional. *The Broadwater Farm Inquiry: Report of the Independent Inquiry into disturbances of October 1985 at the Broadwater Farm Estate, Tottenham. The Inquiry was commissioned by Haringey council. been proven groundless by both the RPSCA and the police. A photograph of a hanging dog was used - taken from a video shot in South Korea in 1982.
Fabrication
The RSPCA press officer claims that the paper's quote of an unnamed RSPCA inspector was "absolute fabrication" • Even the Limehouse police Chief Superintendant wrote to the paper and local organisations, stating that the story "had no foundation in fact"
Ms Elly Wong of the Chinese Association of Tower Hamlets issued a statement describing the article as "irresFace ponsible and baseless" and attacking the paper for inciting racial prejudice.
But the paper persisted in implying that the original allegation had some truth. The Chinese Association has lodged a complain to the Press Council.
The police have told the Parliamentary Home Affairs committee that they have virtually no cases of racial harassment against the Chinese. This totally contradicts the everyday experience of the Chinese families running take-aways and restaurants.
Narcotics
Some years ago a programme on the narcotics trade provoked a protest by an activist in the Chinese community who paraded outside Thames TV with a placard saying 'I'm a heroin courier!"
Perhaps the East End Advertiser would be interested in carrying a real story about the hard drug smugglers in the Far East — the British traders who grew it in India, sold it in China and got British gunboats to defend their right to Free Trade in the Opium Wars of the 1840s.
Youth Fightback special on racism, availak le from 33 Hackworth Point, Rainhill Way, London E3. 20p plus p&p Organiser 278. August Page
Scan page 6
Daisy Mules of the Sinn Fein trade union department speaks to Michele Carlisle about women in Ireland and Sinn Fein's policy. She discusses strip-searching; the recent divorce referendum in the South abortion [Daisy Mules moved a successful resol at the last Sinn Fein conference for a woman's to choose]; and the relation between tion and the national question. Photos Camerawork Women's liberation in Ireland is a very complex issue. Nearly every aspect of women's oppression — violence, discrimination in jobs and education, lack of financial independence, lack of contraception and abortion rights and so on — are inextricably tied to two all-pervading themes: the power of the Catholic church and the national question.
Any long-lasting solution to women's oppression in Ireland must not only deal with the capitalist economic system but must be able to take on both these giants.
The practice of strip-searching women prisoners in Armagh and now Maghaberry prisons is one of the most striking examples of how the issues of women's oppression and the national question are intertwined.
Daisy Mules of Sinn Fein sees strip-searching as an act of violence, very strongly akin to rape. It is not for security — all that's ever been found is a ES note, a bottle of perfume and a letter — but is aimed at women on remand to try and break them and force confessions". She argues that Sinn Fein would see it as a winnable campaign and urges British people to continue taking up the issue.
Another issue which people thought to be winnable was Garrett Fitzgerald's Fine Gael attempt at constitutional reform in the South to allow divorce in cases when a marriage had broken down for at least five years.
The people of the South voted by two to seven to reject this change. Thousands of women will be affected by this result, with no rights to maintenance or help, no right to remarry, no right to a home and no way out of a violent marriage. In the Republic, the only divorce available is a state annulment, which renders the children of that marriage illegitimate, and is very difficult to get.
"The Divorce Referendum was a more tragic event than even the abortion amendment," says Daisy Mules. *It was a bigger setback because it affects more people — mostly women. It commits many women to lives of misery, women who cannot leave their marriages because they have nowhere else to go."
*In Irish law a married woman does not have the right to a house or a home. Her home is her husband's home. So if he decides to run off to Timbuctoo and she stays in Ireland, her home is in Timbuctoo. It's a nonsense, but that's the law".
The anti-divorce lobby emphasised the effect that divorce would have on the tamily and, hypocritically, on women. The Catholic Church claimed that it wasn't giving an 'official line', but in reality it was clear that all good Catholics were expected to vote no. The result was a great victory for the Church.
The Referendum has also been used by Unionists as justification for partition. "Before the Divorce Referendum we heard Paisley ranting about a civil war in the North. He's used the result of the Referendum quite cleverly because it has let him off the hook. Now he says they don't need a civil war because there will never be a united Of course, Paisley himself is opposed to divorce, just as he is opposed to abortion. Sinn Fein is one of the few political groups in Ireland with anything resembling progressive policy on abortion rights.
However, Daisy Mules would be the first to admit that the policy is confused and contradictory.
1. Sinn Fein is opposed to the attitudes in society which compel women to have abortions.
2. Sinn Fein rejects the use of abortion as a form of birth control.
3. Sinn Fein accepts the right to abortion when the woman's life is in danger.
4. Sinn Fein accepts a woman's right to choose.
-This is a very muddled policy. But for Ireland it was a very progressive step. It has caused a lot of potentially dangerous dissension and has forced people to reconsider Sinn Fein and what sort of movement it is."
The policy is likely to be challenged
----- pull-quotes -----
ON ONE POLICEM DIED 359 ARRESTED Photo: Stefano Cagnoni, Report.
from RACISM YOUTH fightback Whece it comes Howte destroyd
WOMEN IN IRELAND inn Fein an women's lib
Soare Re Pork Chops 29.