Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Zionism is not racism

Socialist Organiser no. 278, 7 August 1986 · scan p. 11 · about 419 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →

Reader request 5 Nov 2026 (the Sunderland Poly and UJS articles): in the Socialist Students in NOLS column, unsigned; transcribed from the scan; the machine reading had run in other pieces on the page (Beware a sell-out! and A deal for teachers?, which now have their own pages). "transformtion" and "Histradut" as printed.

Proofed text: read against the scan word by word; spelling, punctuation and wording are as printed.

Scan page 11

Third and final part of a SSiN leaflet put out at Glasgow University

The third assumption running through the arguments of those who spoke for SWSS and the Labour Club was that Zionism simply equals racism. Since organised racists should be 'no platformed', it follows, with inexorable logic, that Zionists should be banned, as happened at Sunderland Polytechnic.

(The SWP is now, after the event, distancing itself from the 'ban the Zionists' position, however illogical that may be from their point of view, as that position flows logically out of their core argument).

Now it is true that the state of Israel pursues racist policies and is heavily based on racist institutions. However, the racism of the Israeli state no more invalidates the right of a Palestinian-Jewish nation to exist than Britain's vile racist immigration laws invalidate the British people's right to self-determination.

Furthermore the 'Zionism is racism' resolution passed at the UN in 1974 arose from the experiences of the Palestinian Arabs in the Middle East. It had very little to do with the attitudes of Diaspora Jewry, who, in the majority, are Zionist in a very minimal habitual sense.

The Jewish student who, brought up as a 'Zionist', joins a Jewish Society out of a vague sense of belonging can hardly be written off as a 'racist', can she?

What we on the Left should say to Zionist Jews is this: although Israel plays a villainous role in the Middle East, we recognise the right of the Palestinian Jews to self-determination; we expect a similar recognition of Palestinian Arab rights; meanwhile, regardless of what you think about the Middle East we will help you to combat anti-semitism and will try to eradicate it from our ranks — ranks that we hope you will join.

Unless we take such an approach, most Jews will remain wedded to Zionist ideology.

Unique in all the world, it would seem, judging by the General Meeting, the SWP finds in Israel a working class (putatively) bereft of any socialist purpose. Turning its eyes away from the real possibility that Jewish workers could break with the Zionist Histradut in action, Glasgow University SWSS seems to look to the armies of the bourgeois Arab states as the agents of social transformtion in Israel.

Leon Trotsky — who favoured Jewish self-determination in a socialist world — would recoil in horror at such attitudes. He would surely have argued that a 'two-states' solution was the only conceivable path to working-class unity, and thence to socialism.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 278

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →