Utopia in Palestine
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-08-14Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
tons are overnaued and society not ratlonally be a proposal or an This is precisely what the 'secular stine conflict. It can only be a proposal democratic state' slogan boils down to. that could, possibly, take effect someTo be at all possible it would re- time in the future, after the conflict 400,000 council houses bought TONY GREENSTEIN (SO 278) has, once again, missed the point in his defence of the secular, democratic state in Palestine' argument.
Of course, Marxists seek to use even limited democratic demands as tools for mobilisation; and any mobilisation necessarily poses new social questions, so that a struggle for purely democratic demands may develop into an assault on the entire social system. But it is not the Marxist approach to say: this is our democratic programme, but it is utterly meaningless unless all social relabegins afresh. quire a complete change in consciousness of the vast majority of the Hebrew-speaking nation. Currently they are opposed even to autonomy for the Palestinians, let alone an independent Palestinian state: but they would have to accept, on Tony's own account, the extinction of 'Israeli Jewish nationhood' They would not only have to reject nationalism, but discard national identity - something Marxists generally reckon to be possible only after generations living under socialism.
Israeli Jews The "secular democratic state!
canimmediate solution to the Israeli/Paleis solved. Yet Greenstein et al talk about it as if it could be implemented immediately?
How? By what means are the Israeli Jews to miraculously change their consciousness overnight?
Smashing
This question is not answered, because it cannot be. In reality, the 'secular, democratic' state could only come into being in the foreseeable future on the basis of the military defeat of Israel in a way that could not be 'democratic' at all. The result would not be the happy intermingling of the two communities, but the opposite. 'smashing the Zionist state, meant by This is all that can be meant by the subjective intentions.
CLIVE BRADLEY, London.