The best solidarity
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-08-14Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
South African workers demonstrate outside British Tyre & Rubber in London. Photo: only serious answer to this is to couple Swindon. BOB FINE's articles on sanctions are described as "a sustained attack on the whole sanctions campaign" by Gerry Bates in SO 278. Worse, they are "socialist' cover for the right wing"
It is wrong, says Gerry Bates, to criticise the 'sanctions campaign' at all: *the whole of the left must support the ANC and its call for sanctions unconditionally".
More What is the substance of the matter? Bob Fine, and Gerry, and me, support the call for sanctions. The point Bob was making was that to call for government sanctions alone is not enough. Effective solidarity with the struggle demands more.
It must be transparently obvious that we are not going to get very much in the way of sanctions out of this government. They may do more than they are doing, but that still won't be much.
No doubt this inaction does "demonstrate the nature and role of British imperialism" . But the South African workers require of us a bit more than that, I think. We need to act: to organise in the unions for the imposition of sanctions from below.
Working-class action is not only more likely than sanctions from the government. It can be far more effective. And workers' sanctions will be subject to real working-class control.
We decide the objectives, duration, etc. of sanctions, rather than a government whose only intention will be to manipulate events to its own advantage.
There is a further point of real contention here, though. How should socialists respond to the anti-sanctions argument that black workers will suffer? Of course we can respond by denouncing their hypocrisy - and Bob's articles did that.
But there is a grain of truth to the argument. It is also true that sanctions could affect British workers' jobs. The lan Swindale. the call for sanctions to a call for the defence of jobs — in Britain and in Moralism And the only serious way to defend jobs is for workers in Britain and in South Africa to bulld the strongest possible rank-and-tile links. Sanctions "from below' can be organised jointly, worked out in collaboration — as much as we can - with South African workers, Working-class internationalism is an answer to those who oppose sanctions, and to the strategies of international capital - British imperialism especially. Moralism is no answer.
And Gerry Bates' exhortation to us to simply 'agree with the ANC' and stop thınkıng about the sanctions campaign is essentially no more than that.
BRIAN SULLIVAN, PORN PORN