After-effects of war
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-08-14Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
GEORGE Davey Smith contributes this week's Science Column. Other SO supporters are welcome to contribute articles [or even to suggest articles] on any topic they feel to be important or just interesting. Letters commenting, questioning or offering information are also welcome. Shorter contributions are more likely to be printed.
WARS are bad for the health, and not only for the soldiers who get shot and the civilians who get bombed!
Two recent reports have demonstrated the indirect health effects of war.
Infant mortality rates vary greatly across the world, from rates of around one death per 100 live births to rates of one death per five live births. Low economic development, inequality of wealth, poor maternal and infant nutrition, inadequate water supplies, and a high unemployment rate, have all been shown to be related to a high mortality rate.
Percentage
A research team from Harvard recently looked at the relationship between infant mortality and the percentage of the gross national product (GNP) a country spends on arms. They found that the percentage of GNP devoted to military expenditure (mil/GNP) was positively related to infant mortality even when allowing for the other factors involved. in other words, the more of its income a country spends on arms, the more of its babies die.
The validity of this finding was strengthened by demonstrating that the change in mil/GNP over the period 1972 to 1979 was related to changes in infant mortality rates - i.e., an increase in mil/GNP was followed by an increase in infant mortality.
Every second a child dies or is permanently disabled by a preventable disease - one that could be avoided by immunisation, clean water supply, or adequate nutrition. Each second E20,000 is spent on arms. One hour of the world's spending on arms would pay for the compiete cost of the successful 20 year campaign to eradicate smallpox.
The annual budget of the World Health Organisation is equivalent to three hours' world expenditure on arms. Furthernore, one in five of the world's icientists are working on miliary projects.
In a classic example of the riminal condemning the crime, he then US president Dwight D Eisenhower said in 1953 that 'every gun that is made, every varship launched, every rocket ired, signifies in the final ense a theft from those who ire cold and are not clothed. : The werld in arms is-not spend- The wald in armie ic not anond ing mor ey alone. It is spending the swe of its labourers, the genius of its scientists,, the houses of its children...
and, it seems, the lives of its infants.
The soldiers themselves appear to suffer detrimental effects from war well after the combat has finished. Higher rates of drug and alcohol abuse, depression and other minor psychiatric disorders, aggressive behaviour, arrest on criminal charges, and marital discord, have been seen in veterans of the Vietnam war compared to non-combattants.
The possibility of delayed effects from the chemical warfare substance Agent Orange are also now being investigated.
Veterans
However, simple comparisons of veterans with civilians may be biased because men who enter military service are generally from poorer backgrounds (draft evasion is easier with money), and may be prone to some of the disorders anyway. Or less aggressive people may try to avoid the draft.
Conversely, unhealthy individuals are excluded from military service, and this may bias the results the other way.
Actually, an ingenious way around this problem of selection bias is available when studying men entering the army between 1970 and 1972. A macabre draft lottery was held, in which people born on certain days were eligible for service, whilst those with birthdays on other dates escaped.
Therefore, looking at date of birth on the death certificates indicates whether a person was or was not eligible for the draft. A 13% increase in suicide and an 8% increase in death by car accident is seen in the drafteligible group.
This vastly underestimates the risk for the individual because only 25% of eligible people actually entered the military, whilst 9% of men who escaped the draft showed what true all-American boys they were by volunteering to help Uncle Sam. Therefore the 13% excess suicides and 8% excess car accident fatalities are presumably concentrated in the 25% of draft-eligible men who actually entered service.
Suicide This is borne out by investigating the military careers of people dying. In people who actually served in the army, the suicide rate is almost double the rate for those who didn't, andmotor vehicle fatalities are 50% higher.
The authors of the lottery" study calculate that 1250 extra deaths have occurred in those drafted into the army between 1970 and 1972, on top of around 4,000 deaths occurring during the actual war.
If the non-fatal effects - alcoholism, accidents, depression, etc. — are taken into account, it is clear that the social and medical effects of war far outlive the aetual fighting: