The colour schmaltz
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-08-14Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
Steven Spielberg directs Whoopi Goldberg they get from that love, but in such a broken and sick after eight Belinda Weaver reviews through rose-coloured lenses.
Steven Spielberg's view of Southern black women in America early this century collapses under the weight of sugary sentiment he piles on. The result is a piece of inauthentic film-making which fails to do justice to Alice Walker's popular novel.
Incest The film begins with Celie and Nettie, two young sisters who suffer at the hands of a brutal, incestuous father, playing in a field. Remember this photogenic field - it crops up again.
Celie, already the mother of two children taken from her at birth, is married off to Mister, a bullying widower, who is in love with Shug Avery, a singer. Nettie escapes to Africa in the company of missionaries.
Celie slaves for the hateful Mister for years, bearing his insults and beatings, until she meets Shug, who gives Celie the confidence she needs to leave and make her own life.
Shug also helps Celie find her sister Nettie's letters from Africa, which Mister has hidden for years.
In the novel, Celie and Shug have a lesbian relationship, in which Celie learns to value herself through feeling loved. In the film, this is reduced to one brief kiss, so Celie's rebellion seems to come from nowhere.
Visually, the film is glossy and prettied up. Poverty mustn't be photogenic enough for Spielberg — all the characters seem fairly well off. Mister is affl uent, though he has no hands working his land. Celie is richer and better dressed after she leaves Mister, but we don't know how. Africa is neat, clean and tidy and full of photogenic animals and scenery.
The film celebrates the bonding and love between women, and the strength CRITICS often complain about the time given to old movies on TV. I can see their point.
Naturally, lots of them are rubbish. But, me, I trawl TV for old movies — good, bad and indifferent, '30s and '40s Hollywood, '40s and '50s British, the lot.
This column is about me and my attitude to the repertoire of old movies way that what should be moving becomes cloying and overdone.
Fight
When Sophie, the wife of Mister's son, Harpo, angrily tells Celie how she has had to fight all her life against men - it's an affecting scene. But Sophie, the one true rebel in the film, a black woman who stands up for herself against sexists and racists, ends up toon, perhaps. I cried and taken out.
I remember going once or twice with my father as a child. My memory is that it gave me a headache.
Then the cinema was closed off to me, declared forbidden and sinful, when I became an altar boy, a little short of nine. Altar boys helped the priest say mass, and we were meant to be very holy. In Western Ireland in 1950. that meant a lot.
Redeems
The message of the film is conservative: that true love redeems; that God will fix it (and the money side too, it seems); and that fighting back before God's good time only gets you into trouble.
Restrained scenes are rare. When Shug leads revellers out of the bar and into the church, with everyone singing along the way, and then is reunited with her estranged pastor-father, you know you're watching a film by a director whose motto is 'Nothing succeeds like excess'.
Develop
None of the characters really develop. Celie is at one minute a mouse, the next defiant. Shug appears at first as a drunken slob, then she becomes a beaming fairy godmother figure. And When I was invited to return to being an altar boy procrastinated and then said I didn't want to. I exchanged one form of emotionally charged theatre for another, I suppose - though I remained religious for three or four years longer. I kept going to the pictures — four times a week, if I could scrape the money together. The cheapest seats were 8 pence about 3 new pence).
Besotted
so on.
Embarrassing
The cast do as well as they can with an embarrassing script. Whoopi Goldberg as Celie and Margaret Avery as Shug try to convey some character under all that sweetness and light.
A major film with an all black cast is a first, but Spielberg should never have got near it. He should go back to outer space where he belongs. never was, come to think of it: I was over 14, and, you might: ay, quite grown up, before I worked it out for myself.
My feelings and fantasies used on the cinema.
Less than a year after my discovery I found myself transported to Manchester — where the city's central and local cinemas were so numerous as to be given a page each night in the local papers. I was in heaven. But I read in the magazines 'Picture Show'
----- pull-quotes -----
'The Color Purple' THE COLOR Purple' is filmed