Bolsheviks and Kronstadt
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-08-21Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
However hypocritical the Tribune leader-writers may be in their use of the incidents at Kronstadt where in 1921 the Bolshevik government suppressed an insurrection, SO cannot expect to get away with such dismissive remarks about Kronstadt without 50 years ago Trotsky's reply to critics on the left wing of his own movement was that while it was not impossible that he had been wrong, other political issues were too pressing to allow him You fail to mention the heroic role of *during both the February and October revolutions of 1917 and during the defence of Petrograd against the white The sailors of Kronstadt stood out in their heroism for the revolution, heroism matched only by the workers of the Vyborg quarter of Petrograd. In con- would carry on in the original spirit of with Trotsky, bringing his paper from sequence — so as to ensure the safety exile, into Russia, and distributing it of the revolutionary government - the In point of fact the anarchists among Soviet supreme council decreed that no the Kronstadt sailors had been killed: Within your own little circle of serviceman should be moved from some just prior to the 1917 Revolution, acquaintances no doubt you can get Kronstadt to any other sphere of mili- some died in the October revolution, away with cheap jibes such as those in some were later killed by white guard your editorial; no doubt when you sell forces. So though anarchists condi- your paper to the politically naive and tionally support the Kronstadt pro- inexperienced, and when you retuse to So the rebels the Bolsheviks sup- gramme, it was not an anarchist pro- print the tacts in response, you will get pressed in 1921 had been the heroes of gramme and we had no direct or away with it. But you will not break out indirect impact on it. The left in Kron- of that isolation or keep those you influYou say "some of the rebels raised stadt - at the time of the Kronstadt ence once they shed their inexperanarchist slogans" "but they had rising - was represented by the ience, if you continue to ignore the taken the key fortress at Kronstadt" "Maximalist Socialists" and the "presented themselves as wanting Kronstadt Programme was certainly in something better" "a naive anarchist" . This asserts and implies a numIt is suggested that only a minority supported the revolutionary platform Kronstadt was not an isolated rising, of the Kronstadt Soviet; that there was but part of a nationwide resistance to a putschist attempt which had resulted policies that Lenin himself acknowin the seizure of a fortress in which ledged were a retreat to state capitalthey had no right to be; that the programme was opportunist and adven- Trotskyism is always anxious to turist, advanced by newcomers to the pretend that the degeneration of the Soviet Revolution began with Stalin, revolutionary scene rather than by tried and tested revolutionaries; that and refuses to discuss the fact (admitall the Kronstadt Soviet revolutionaries ted by Lenin) that bureaucratic degen- and all anarchists — are merely eracy had begun before Lenin's death.
It is really no use your branding Stalin The Kronstadt Soviet platform was the grave-digger of the revolution, passed unanimously and was endorsed without acknowledging that when he by all organised groups on the island came on the scene there was already a fortress and among the sailors, including the vast majority of the Kronstadt You really need to explain why with in tour years of hailing Vyborg and The platform reiterated the original Kronstadt as the power houses of the aims of the October Revolution, listed revolution, Lenin and Trotsky sent the various obvious departures from the Red Army, led by ex-Tsarist officers, in letter and spirit of this programme. to crush both. You cannot gloss over Taking full account of the lack of the fact that the Democratic Centralist resources it demanded the rectification Opposition (1919 vintage) within the of various government measures which army, liquidated by Trotsky, largely were in conflict with the October pro- consisted of revolutionaries who had gramme. It advocated policies which frequently risked their lives working Red sailors the revolution. line with that party's policies.
Resistance ism. corpse to be buried. there. facts.
Fraternally, LAURENS OTTER, Wellington, Salop.