Trotsky and Stalin
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-08-21Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
Edward IN THE centre pages this week, we look at the appalling role played by the so-called Communist Party in Spain, in 1936-37. Part of the background to their behaviour in Spain was the events in the USSR at that time.
A series of dramatic 'trials' were taking place, in which former leaders of the Russian Communist Party confessed to terrible crimes, and were shot. The most prominent charge was that of being "Trotsky-fascists' - that is, agents simultaneously of Hitler and of Leon Trotsky.
Trotsky was one of the leaders of the Russian Revolution in 1917. Born Lev Davidovich Bronstein, he was won over to revolutionary Marxism at the end of the last century, and became a major writer and activist in the Russian socialist movement.
In 1905, in a revolution against the brutal regime of the Kussian emperor, the Tsar, the industrial working class created for the first time 'soviets' -workers' councils. These were democratic bodies that represented the workers of a particular area, and could have formed a new government. Soviets were to reappear in 1917 when, with a Communist majority, they did form a workers' government.
Trotsky was made president of the soviet in St. Petersburg in 1905. On the basis of his experience in that — defeated - revolution, Trotsky developed a thorough criticism of the main ideas current among Marxists.
Capitalist
They argued that Russia was so economically underdeveloped that a revolution could do no more than sweep away the old system of rule by the nobility and the Tsar (emperor), anc lay the basis for modern capitalist industry.
Many Marxists concluded that the capitalist class would lead the revolution. The role of the workers' party was to urge the capitalists forward while continuing to defend the workers interests.
Lenin argued that the weak Russian capitalist class - tied I to Tsarism, and afraid of the working class -would lead no revolution. The revolution could instead by led by the workers in alliance with the peasantry. It would still be a 'bourgeois' revolution, because the peasantry, was a "bourgeois' class, owning or aspiring to own private property, and the peasants massively outnumbered the workers. But the workers' party would fight for it to be the most radical, thoroughgoing form of bourgeois revolution.
Trotsky went further, arguing that the peasants could play no independent role. They would follow the capitalists or follow the working class. And if the working class could win the leadership of the peasantry, then the anti-Tsarist 'democratic' revolution would merge with the socialist, working-class revolution.
Was Russia too underdeveloped for this? Yes, taken on its own. But in the modern world Russia could not be 'taken on its own' Foreign capital had already created large-scale BROOSE industry in Russia alongside the vast expanses of primitive peasant economy. And the Russian workers, taking power, could hope to link up with workers in more advanced countries.
This theory, which was borne out by the revolution of 1917, is called permanent revolution'.
Although for many years there was no love lost between Trotsky and Lenin, in 1917 Lenin moved towards Trotsky's ideas on the tasks of the revolution, and Trotsky joined Lenin's party, by then called the Communist Party.
It was Trotsky who organised the Communist insurrection in October 1917 (November by our calendar) that finally put the working class in power. It was Trotsky, too, who organised the Red Army to defend the revolution against Western capitalist military interWorkers against Stalinism. vention in support of Russian counter-revolutionaries.
The Russian revolution did defend itself successfully. Other revolutionary movements exploded all across Europe but were defeated or betrayed - because parties like Lenin's had not been built in time.
The Communist government was isolated in a terribly poor country, ravaged by world war and then civil war. People were starving; workers were deserting the cities in their thousands in search of food.
In these conditions, the Communist militants become more and more absorbed in the tasks of running the state and, bit by bit, more bureaucratic. Old Tsarist bureaucrats put their stamp on the workers' state. From 1923 onwards, Trotsky took up the fight against this degeneration of the party and the workers' state.
Stalin
Trotsky was defeated. The emerging bureaucracy, whose most prominent representative was Joseph Stalin, was too strong. The "Left Opposition' ,as Trotsky and his comrades were called, were isolated, and then expelled from the party. Trotsky was expelled from the USSR in 1929.
The degeneration of the Russian Communists also affected the Communist International which they had founded. The Social Democrats before 1914 had blunted and toned down Marxist theory delicately, bit by bit. The Stalinists gutted the ideas of Marx and Lenin at a hectic pace, putting written-to-order goobledegook in the empty husks in place of the original content. A terrible corruption befell the workers' movement and its basic ideals of freedom, democracy, equality and justice.
The Trotskyists were the sharpest critics of the absurd policies pursued by the Stalinists in the 1920s and 30s. On every question, the Trotskyists were proved right. For example, they were right about the ridiculous policy of the Stalinists in Germany, which said that the Social Democrats were worse than Hitler - and thus helped Hitler take power and destroy the labour movement.
They were right that the Popular Front - the opposite of the earlier policy and just as bad - would be a disaster.
They were right to criticise the Stalinist theory of 'socialism in one coun try, arguing like Marx and Lenin that socialism would have to be an international system, and that the Stalinist theory was nationalistic.
The Trotskyists were also right to say that by the mid 1930s the bureauHung Partie beyon kyists neede ('Four - and ed in l cracy.
Not in the one w to fal in thi heino ed the class lary 1956.
in the USSR, and the Communist s which it dominated, were d all hope of reform. The Trotsargued that new Marxist parties d to be built, as part of a new th') international Marxist party I that a new revolution was needRussia to restore workers' demoonly Trotskyists were "purged"
Moscow Trials of 1936-7; anyith any independent thought was I victim. But "Trotskyism' was, e bureaucrats' eyes, the most us crime - because it representeir most deadly enemy, workingsocialism.
Torture The Stalinists called the Trotskyists "fascist agents" (until Stalin signed a Trotsky in exilé pact with Hitler in 1939), and all sorts of respectable liberals and social-democrats went along with them. Today, even the CPs admit that the 'confessions that were got out of the "defendants' in the Moscow Trials were the result of physical and psychological torture. Many did not confess. and died in concentration camps.
Returned
In 1940, Trotsky himself was murdered by a Stalinist agent while in exile in Mexico.
But the Stalinists could never suppress the basic ideas of working-class socialism championed by Trotsky. In 1953 in East Germany, in 1956 in Hungary, in 1968 in Czechoslovakia, and in 1980-1 in Poland, those ideas have returned to challenge the bureaucrats.