Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Wrong on Trotsky

Socialist Organiser no. 281, 28 August 1986 · scan p. 4 · about 494 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 4

Laurens Otter (Letters, SO no. 280) makes some harsh criticisms of SO's account of the Kronstadt uprising. It is true, of course, that the editorial - on "Tribune and Trotskyism' - did not give an exhaustive account of events at Kronstadt in 1921, where the Bolsheviks suppressed a revolt by sailors.

But the general point comrade Otter is making does not seem to me to be justified. This is that "bureaucratic degeneration (in the USSR) had already begun before Lenin's death" whilst "Trotskyism is always anxious to pretend that (it) began with Stalin"

sheviks suppressed had been the In fact, this last point is false. In terms of personnel the Kronstadt sailors of 1921 were not the same as 1917. The revolutionary sailors had gone off to defend the revolutionary government and had been replaced by But this is not the main point.

Laurens Otter does not address the concede that much, and I'm not sure I absurd to compare their actions, or the issue as it was faced by the Bolsheviks. do - their revolt was going to aid the bureaucratic deformations of the state Kronstadt was the fortress defending (which they frankly acknowledged, let Russia from naval attack from the us remember) to the monstrous nationBaltic. At the time of the revolt, the sea Bolsheviks at that time had a perspec- alist tyranny of the Stalinists a few was frozen, but soon the ice would tive of developing an international revolutionary movement. 'Hanging on' In retrospect you might want to say, Once Russia became accessible by in Russia was a vital component of a given the defeat of the international sea, if Kronstadt was not on the side of European revolutionary strategy. They revolutions, of the Left Opposition, of the government, invasion was inevit- correctly saw the fate of the Russian subsequent revolutions, that it was not able. The chances of defeating such an and world revolution as inextricably worth the cost, and the world would invasion - after years of war already - were remote. To have surrendered —To have given up on the Russian Kronstadt would have been to have revolution would have meant giving up could not, even conceding this point on any revolution anywhere, because too, have had the virtue of retrospect.

If anyone wants to argue that the its overthrow would have been a defeat revolution was not worth the political - and felt as such - by the whole cost of attacking the Kronstadt sailors, they should do so honestly. I think it Because of that - that Lenin and was worth it. If only innocently on Trotsky based their actions upon an the part of the majority - if we can international perspective - it is Lenin and Trotsky share the guilt.

Kronstadt, says comrade Otter, is a case in point: "The rebels the Bolreal. army firing on Kronstadt.

counter-revolution.

Much more fundamentally, the years later.

connected. have been a TOM RIGBY international movement.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 281

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →