South Africa: the Case for a Workers' Par the Workers' Ol
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-08-28Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 6
Black trade unionists in South Africa have talked about creating a society based on 'worker control'. Yet the political arena seems to be dominated by very different ideas, ranging from the extreme right wing and Botha through liberals who want formal equality while maintaining the substance of capitalist privilege, to the 'two-stage' theory of the African National Congress (democracy first, socialism later). How can the workers make their own independent voice heard? Clive Bradley argues the case for a workers' party. THE IDEA that the trade unions should form a political party in competition with the existing bourgeois parties has a long Marxist pedigree. Engels raised it in connection with Britain, subsequently supporting the formation of the Independent Labour Party, and arguing for it in turn to fight for a trade-union-based party.
In the 1930s, the American Trotskyists made a lot of propaganda for a Labour Party, and the American rotskyists continued to do so after World War 2.
The essential idea is simple: the workers' organisations should break with their existing reliance upon, or alliance with, the bourgeois parties (Liberals in Britain, Democrats in the USA). They should strike out an independent path.
It is worth quoting Trotsky at some length.
*The question of the labor party has never been a question of principle for revolutionary Marxists... before the crisis of 1929, and... until the appearance of the CIO, we could have hoped that the revolutionary, that is, the Bolshevik party would develop in the United States parallel to the radicalisation of the working class... Under those conditions it would have been absurd to occupy oneself with abstract propaganda [for a] 'labor party' But:
*The situation since that time, however, has radically changed... The powerfully developing trade unions, under the conditions of a deepening crisis of capitalism, will project themselves all the more irresistably upon the road of political struggle and thus upon the road of crystallisation into a LAUNCH OF THE SUNDAY DECEMBLElaunch ally to celebrate labor party".
('The Problem of the Labor Party", in Discussions On The Transitional Program, Pathfinder Press, p.107).
Development
The crucial factor that put the Labour Party question on the agenda was the development of CIO industrial unionism, in the context of a major 'decline of American capitalism' Some of Trotsky's comments are useful:
"Are we in favour of the creation of a reformist labor party? No. Are ve in favour of a policy which can give o the trade unions the possibility to put its weight upon the balance of forces? Yes.
"It can become a reformist party it depends upon the development. Here the question of program comes in..
... I would not say that the labor party is a revolutionary party, but that we will do everything to make it paid even ice of he site i possible. At every meeting I would say:
WORk adl of COSATU Picture: DAF consider it is the only revolutionary party. But I am not a sectarian. You are now trying to create a big workers' party. I will help you, but I propose that you consider a program for this party...
... we must be part of the movement...
Engels' comments are equally instructive:
*The great thing is to get the working class to move as a class; that once obtained, they will soon find the right direction, and all those who resist... will be left out in the cold with small sects of their own".
(Marx/Engels Selected Correspondence, Moscow 1975, p.376).
Movement
The point here is not textual authority; it is to establish the basic framework and political method of the classical Marxists.
To be 'part of the movement'; to assist the development of the working class from the point of view of its most advanced ideological current; to help the working class learn, rather than make lectures to it: this, we think, is the essence of their approach.
The idea of a workers' party in South Africa is not one we would advocate at all times. It depends upon 'concrete circumstances' . What are these?
• A significant layer of the working Class has began to discuss a new, independent politics that is a major departure from the populist-Stalinist traditions of the past. The idea of a workers' party has come from sections of the workers themselves — it is an issue up for discussion.
• This layer of workers is the product of one of the most important developments of industrial trade unionism anywhere in the world.
• Its political development is the product of a lived experience of class struggle - looked at with great freshness and creativity.
• As yet, the tendencies towards bureaucratisation of this movement are not very far advanced. On the contrary, the unions have developed democratic practices that are consciously seen as prefigurations of future society.
• Alien class forces and ideological movements — i.e. the populist/Stalinists — are hell-bent upon controlling and neutralising this movement as a whole.
Challenge
The dominant culture of the independent unions has been distinctly syndicalist. This was only viable so long as (a) they were regarded with indifference by the populists; (b) the general political struggle was at a low ebb. Since 1984, neither of these conditions has held. The populists are desperate to derail the development of an alternative political pole; and the rise of the mass movement has been enormous.
Moreover, the rise in the movement has given greater political weight to COSATU's founding congress the populists, which in turn gives them greater weight in the unions.
In these conditions either the nascent working-class politics that have developed are drawn out, given a coherent programme, and the socialists in the workers' movement actively combat alien class ideologies; or the populists will be victorious.
The Workers Party theme codifies the development of working-class politics very sharply. It proposes a political rather than narrowly trade-union objective to the socialist militants in the unions (and more generally), and provides an important opening through which revolutionaries can make propaganda — or even direct proposals — for a coherent Marxist programme.
It takes actual developments within the workers' movement as its point of departure, and connects with them. Rather than abstractly counterpose a revolutionary party' to the emerging political movement, it seizes on those real developments in the class and takes them a step further.
What are the alternatives? Alex Callinicos of the Socialist Workers' Party (SWP) and others have put great stress on the need to build a Marxist nucleus — a small propaganda group. We absolutely agree on the priority of this, and I will discuss it further in a moment.
But what will the nucleus say? What will it argue for?
One possibility is for the small Marxist group (and by small I mean anything less than several tens of thousands) to concentrate on Marxist propaganda in various forms: education, discussion, and promotion of major Marxist ideas (permanent revolution, for example), propaganda for socialism.
This would combine with an intervention into the unions, workplace and community struggles, etc.
This perspective for the building of a revolutionary party would seem to be simply one of one-by-one recruitment. Gradually the party could grow out of the various struggles until it takes on mass proportions.
One particular problem with this perspective strikes us as central. If the populist/Stalinists dominate the political struggle and dominate the trade unions, this will be a setback for any future Marxist movement.
In other words, a challenge to the populists now — i.e. the development of a serious political alternative — will radically determine the possibilities for a Marxist party in the future. And the formation of a Marxist nucleus with a perspective of one-by-one growth is no challenge to the populists now.
In fact this perspective is based upon an acceptance that for now' ; the populists/Stalinists will dominate workers' movement. 'Our day will come... but for now alien class forces will ideologically dominate the workers' movement.
It is of course possible to argue for the trade unions to engage in political action without forming a political party. A case can be made for this in terms of avoiding an unnecessary provocation of the Stalinists. As a tactical issue that is of course very important. As an alternative perspective to that of a party, it is not a good one.
----- pull-quotes -----
orkers' "The W poses a politic poses politica narrowly trade the socialist ions.