[The unions can "engage in political action' at…]
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-08-28Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 7
The unions can "engage in political action' at all sorts of levels. But a serious involvement in the political struggles requires not just participation, but leadership — and that requires a strategy and a programme.| The more coherent the political strategy, the more effective the workers' political intervention, the more inexorable the logic of forming a party to embody that programme and strategy.
The Workers' Party idea follows from all this. The alternatives of Callinicos and others amount to an acquiescence in populist domination of the movement in the present, in the name of building a revolutionary party in the future. The alternatives, in other words, give the populists a free run.
The formation and building of Marxist nucleus is nevertheless a priority. Indeed, without that the slogan of a Workers' Party has no revolutionary content whatever. If we don't always follow the references to a Work- ers' Party with a call for a revolutionary organisation, that's because we don't think you have to say everything all at once. And it makes little sense to appeal to the broad spectrum of trade unionists to form a select Marxist nucleus! 'A workers' party provided there is a revolutionary nucleus' isn't a very good slogan.
Assuming that the Marxists are in a minority, then their job will be to organise within the party, win it to a Marxist programme, and thereby win a majority. (This of course does not rule out all sorts of possibilities -splits, expulsions, etc. etc.)
Callinicos objects that a party based on the unions would by definition not be revolutionary, as it would include all different layers of the class, whereas the revolutionary party includes only the most class-conscious.
This completely misses the point. Of course the revolutionary party, in the sense of the Marxist organisation, is demarcated ideologically from the rest of the movement. It is principally an ideologically selected group: a collecttive body attempting scientifically to understand the world, the better to know how to change it.
In that sense, a party based on the trade unions cannot, by definition, be a revolutionary party' even with a Marxist programme. In terms of formal detinitions, therefore, Callinicos is right. The revolutionary party, i.e. the Marxist party, properly understood, would be an ideological organised group within a trade-union-based party even under conditions where it commanded a majority.
This issue does not to me seem very interesting. The point about building a Marxist party is to develop an ideological current. On the formalities of that there is no dispute between Callinicos and us.
There is, however, a great deal of political substance in dispute, and the differences over the Workers' Party idea express a good deal of what distinguishes us from the SWP.
Our point of departure is that mass revolutionary parties will be built out of actual living developments in the workers' movement, or they will not be built at all. They cannot be called into being by self-proclamation. ('We are the revolutionarty party...')
Developments within the workers' movements, outside of major upheavals, tend to be excruciatingly slow. But Marxists cannot bypass those real developments by an effort of will. Our task is to seize on actual develop: ments and be 'part of the movement. to participate in the workers' own experiences, and to help them remake their own movement.
That does not mean (after the style of the Mandel tendency) looking about for the latest flagship of the 'world revolutionary process' and jumping aboard, leaving Marxist politics somewhere in transit. We try to build ourselves as a hard, distinct, ideological core — but as part of the labour movement, rather than counterposed to it (or, in Britain, counterposed to its political wing, the Labour Party).
United front An important spoke in the Comintern's programmatic wheel was the idea of the united front. This relates to the Workers' Party discussion. Should revolutionaries make proposals for action to the workers' movement as a whole? Should we set objectives for the movement as a whole?
We think categorically, yes we should, The Workers' Party would be precisely this: an objective for the movement as a whole. It seems to us that it is only by this approach that revolutionary politics can be made relevant to the working class.
To conclude: there are, of course, technical objections to the idea of a Workers' Party — principally that it would be illegal (an objection with
----- pull-quotes -----
Party. pro- #rather than =union objective =mi i the itants in