Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Flexibility: why the bosses need it

Socialist Organiser no. 281, 28 August 1986 · scan pp. 9–10 · about 1,090 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

IN APRIL 1984, management at Lucas Electrical, Birmingham, proposed that clerical and manual workers should be brought together in a single grade of *Materials Controllers'. —Was this event part of a major change now taking place in the class structure of Britain, and therefore in the potential for working-class struggle?

The Centre for Alternative Industrial and Technological Systems (CAITS) thinks it was. In Flexibility -Who Needs It? they argue:

*The range of drastic measures wrapped up as "flexibility"" which the bosses are now attempting to push through are "the most serious challenge to trade unions for decades"

Anywhere

In "functional flexibility', workers go anywhere and do anything, and they get paid roughly the same rate. Demarcation lines are out. At Nissan's new factory at Washington, Co.Durham, the only grades are 'manufacturers' and 'technicians'.

Numerical flexibility is a new name for casualisation. Alongside a group of core' workers, the bosses want a pool of 'peripheral' workers, usually unskilled and on part-time or fixed-term contracts, to be recruited and fired when and where they are needed. Such workers are usually women or young The study rightly points out that there is no reason in principle why trade unionists should defend demarcation lines, or oppose workers learnJohn Bloxam ing a wide variety of skills. Indeed, in principle we support such changes provided that they are not at the expense of workers' wages and conditions.

The point is that under capitalism they are introduced under capitalist control to give the capitalists advantages over the workers. Redundancies are always part of the 'flexibility' packages. The drive to tear down demarcation lines goes with a drive to weaken union organisation.

The element of new training is flimsy, too. In place of the old apprenticeship system, you get YTS schemes or 'training' on the job, done by older workers - who are themseives then often made redundant.

Any job can be done by anyone, as long as it can be done 'safely' . But safety is a relative term. *There is evidence that health and safety standards deteriorate"

The CAITS study is labelled A Trade Union Guide' , and it is a useful summary of a whole range of attacks aimed at trade union organisation and conditions. But it often raises more questions than it answers.

For example, any shop steward trying to convince his or her members to oppose 'flexibility' measures would be greatly helped by having tacts on the increase of accidents. But the study just mentions "evidence' with no details.

More important, little picture is given of the spread of casualisation or struggles against it.

In Japan, the bosses' model for "flexibility', over half the workers are a 'NUMERICAL' FLEXIBILITY • FUNCTIONAL FLEXIBILITY 'floating reserve", , non-unionised, with inferior wages and conditions, on contracts of three to 12 months, and doing the worst jobs.

In Britain, if you leave aside industries like building where casual labour has always been rife, it has been confine, until recently, to a few jobs like teaching. Now it must be expanding.

A recent report - quoted in Labour Research - into the 1.8 million vacancies filled by job centres in 1984 found that 32% were for temporary jobs.

The town hall workers" union NALGO reports an increase in the number of temporary contracts in public services. At British Alcan, 48% of the workforce were made into permanent temporaries', with contracts to be renewed every six months.

Last year, with the assistance of the UCW union leaders, the Post Office pushed through a big increase in their number of casuals. But that agreement has still not been fully implemented and remains the source of many la struggles.

The CAITS study thinks the prospects are gloomy. The pamphlet offers guidelines for trade union negotiators, making some sensible if limited suggestions. Limited? Yes, because their basic answer to 'flexibility' is that it should be negotiated by trade unions and not imposed.

Fine: but negotiate what, and how?

The pamphlet does not even mention a future Labour government, let alone discuss what the labour movement should demand of it. At a minimum, Labour must legislate the same rights for part-time and temporary workers that full-time workers have.

But the basic reason for the authors' gloom is that they don't think that workers are going to fight the attacks. And if you don't think it's going to happen, then there is little point in discussing tactics for resistance.

Yes, unemployment, defeats, and bureaucratic betrayals have made it much more difficult to fight. But there are already many examples to prove that workers will fight back.

The history of capitalism is the history of repeated radical changes in techniques of production and organisation of labour — and of the working class eventually getting the measure of each new system and fighting back. This time it will be no different.

Without the perspective that the workers will fight back, studies of "flexibility' are like diagrams of a watch which don't take account of the spring. •Flexibility: who needs it. tl.95 from CAIIS, North London Poly, Holloway Rd., London NZ. souled, well-heeled and fat-bottomed "salt of the earth" rank and file PLP. man (and occasional woman) who was the political ballast on which the last two Labour governments rested; anc there are an awtul lot of them left, unfortunately.

Unlike most Labour MPs who have recently faced reselection, Tommy gets his comeuppance.

The selection meeting is tied and decides to have the candidates in for five more minutes each of questioning. Meanwhile, moment Tommy's secretary has arrived with Clive is, was, makes Clive agree to withdraw sake of party unity"

But Clive is brave and sincerely wants to clean up the Labour Party. He goes back in to say he's with drawing - and then tells them why.

One candidate is left — but not home and dry. The meeting votes down a motion to endorse him. Tommy's wife and son call him a rat and walk out.

We last see him, drunk in the House of Commons bar, talking to a Tory who is eager to 'take over' his "clever' , mercenary secretary.

"Long Live the King" was not only good drama and fine performances. was plainly on the side of reselection and by implication on the side of those who want it.

And that's a lot rarer than drama on TV!

Tracy Williams will definitely be next week.

Organiser no. 281, 28 1986, P

Scan page 10

«ABC

----- pull-quotes -----

John Stride's Tommy was a compos- ite portrait of the dead head, dead-

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 281

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →