Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

1936: Year of the Popular Front Lessons of Spain

Socialist Organiser no. 281, 28 August 1986 · scan p. 10 · about 1,218 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

South Africa today: there must be no repeat of the disastrous policy of the popular front OF MARXISM What are the lessons of e Popular Front for toay?_ Clive Bradley conudes his series on the panish Civil war: le military base of the Spanish scists, for the first six months of e war, was Spanish Morocco. 'anco recruited from the Moors' Morocco.

Morocco had been conquered by ain, with the help of France, tween 1912 and 1926. Although the eat days of the Spanish Empire — the e conquest of most of America uth of what is now the USA - were ig over, the Spanish ruling class still t in its own feeble bid in the ramble for Africa'. A junior partner the powerful imperialist states to its rth, Spain nevertheless did its best reap the fruits of modern imperialism.

Morocco The Republican governments after e fall of the monarchy in 1931 had no tention of relinquishing control of orocco. Even when the Moroccan ader Abd el-Karim offered to organe an uprising against Franco, if Leon um would release him from his Popu- Front prison in France to do it, the ›pular Front in Madrid turned him wwn.

An uprising against Franco would evitably have taken place under the inner of Moroccan independence om Spain. The Popular Front could lly have built an alliance with the loroccan people through a radical emocratic policy of self-determination r Morocco. This they refused even to insider.

Indeed, in February 1937, the Forgn Minister delivered a note to Briin and France on the subject of lorocco. It said: "The government is sposed to make certain sacrifices in le Spanish zone of Morocco, if the ritish and French governments nould take steps to prevent Italoerman intervention in Spanish ffairs:

They were prepared to give Morocco › the British or French imperialists, ut not to the Moroccan people. As ley rejected an alliance with the foroccans, so the Moroccans rejected nem.

Morocco thus remained a military ase for Franco and his international ascist allies. And so the imperialistic olicy of the Republican government ontributed to its military defeat. What motivated this suicidal policy? in anti-colonial revolt in Morocco ould not be seen in separation from an nti-colonial policy throughout Africa. tepublican Spain may have been the ulwark of democracy' - but that lemocracy had strict limits so far as he capitalists were concerned.

For the colonial subjects of Spain, Britain or France there was to be no emocracy. And allowing democratic iational rights for Morocco would nerely be the 'thin end of the wedge' Accepting the limits of capitalism, he Popular Front was forced to act as a apitalist government. A break with he imperialist policies of the capitalsts was far more than the 'alliance of lasses' could bear.

It was the same story in France: Leon lum's government never countenanred independence for the French colones.

In Spain, the Popular Front adopted similar attitude towards the national ninorities in Spain itselt. Basque anc atalonian nationalists were viewed rith intense suspicion by the Republian overnments after 1931 *Ail the aspects of Popular Front policy, in Spain and France, have important lessons for the labour movement today. The Popular Front was an appalling failure. But not only have the lessons not be learned, the essential The Popular Front led Spanish workers to defeat policies have been repeated time and time again.

For a socialist-dominated government that accepts the limits of capitalism, attempts to work within them, and ends up with an economic mess, demoralised workers and a growing fascist menace, we need look no further than the France of Francois Mitterrand since 1981.

That was a modified variant of the Popular Front. But Popular Frontism has explicitly been copied across Latin America and the so-called Third World for decades. There have been many "Spanish civil wars' . Again and again, the Popular Front has delivered the workers into the hands of their enemies.

Chile

In Chile in 1970, a 'Popular Unity' government was elected, led by Salvador Allende, on a policy of uniting the people against imperialism and the top layers of the Chilean ruling class.

The masses moved into action; and the forces of the right, backed up from the USA, mobilised to counter the potentially revolutionary struggles of the workers and poor peasants.

The Socialist and 'Communist leaders trusted the army, the military wing of the capitalist state, to 'defend democracy' from the Chilean fascists.

In 1973 the Chilean generals repaid that trust with a coup that led to the deaths of 30,000 or more working class militants. A regime was imposed that is only now - 13 years later - showing signs of weakening before a reviving working class.

Yet the disastrous Popular Front policy is being urged on the Chilean masses again.

All historical experience proves that it is when the organised working class sets the pace of the struggle for democracy, or in defence of it, that the middle class, the peasantry, the urban and rural poor, are pulled en masse on the side of historical progress. If the workers are forced to hold back, or if working class action is kept channelled into safe grooves that divert them from a challenge to capitalism, then the middle classes - confused and demoralised — are easy prey for reactionary movements. —In 1930s Spain a revolution was in progress around the themes of democracy. The 'democratic' Republicans in fact proposed extremely limited objectives for that democratic revolution.

Independence for Morocco? | A radical redistribution of land to the peasants? Breaking the power of the Church? Democratisation of the Army? These purely democratic issues were too radical for the bourgeois radicals.

The Trotskyists proposed that the workers take the lead in struggling for the most radical and consistent democracy; that the democratic revolution be given its tempo and motive force by the class struggle.

On the basis of that democratic struggle, distinct working class organisations could and should develop that could themselves take on the role of a. government - more democratic than even the most radical capitalist democracy.

The relevance of this policy for the world today is enormous. Of course there have been many changes since 1936-39. But all the core ideas of the Trotskyists' policy are still relevant and valid. All the core ideas of Popular Frontism are demonstrably talse and dangerous.

Consider South Africa today. A revolutionary movement mobilised essentially around democratic issues; a struggle whose pace has been set, increasingly over the past ten years by the organised working class; there are many parallels with Spain.

And the South African Stalinists advocate a policy strikingly similar to that of their Spanish antecedents -putting the struggle against apartheid' where the Stalinists of the 1930s put 'the struggle against fascism'.

Blood The latter-day Stalinists who want us to 'celebrate' the unmitigated disaster of fifty years of Popular Frontism have good reason to want to hide its lessons.

If we look closely we will see that Stalinism has working class blood on its hands. The object of recalling the real history of the Popular Front is to see to it that next time revolutionary workers do not suffer the same fate. By. learning from the defeats of the past we can prepare for the victories of the future.

ODE

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 281

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →