Kronstadt and Stalin
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-09-04Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
Back to IF THE Tories are campaigning for 'Victorian values', we can't have the Labour Party defending more enlightened modern ideas, can we? It might get some voters thinking there are streaks of red on the old Pink Flag.
So no wonder that Neil Kinnock has told "Everywoman' magazine that "I'm a father, and no matter how much I try to convince myself towards the course of enlightenment, , I know damn well that, put to the test, I'm what people would call a reactionary"
Perhaps a moderate slogan like 'Back to 1950s values' would be in order?
Casualties turned away... LAURENS Otter's letter on Kronstadt consisted of untruths and half-truths.
In 1938, 17 years after the sup pression of Kronstadt, a hue and cry was raised over the role of Trotsky in the affair. Trotsky replied to what he rightly called a 'people's front of anarchists, Mensheviks, social-democrats, and the bourgeoisie.
Why at that time should they raise the question of Kronstadt? Because they all wanted to discredit Trotskyism as the only genuine revolutionary current.
It appears that in the year of the 50th anniversary of the Popular Front Laurens Otter wants to revive it with his support for Tribune.
Different
Let us examine the facts. Otter's references to the great role of Kronstadt in the revolution are irrelevant. Different people made up the Kronstadt garrison in 1921. As the civil war started in 1918, detachments from heroic Kronstadt were sent to help Moscow. Others went from Kronstadt to the Don and the Ukraine..
Trotsky records that by 1919 complaints began to arrive from various fronts saying that the 'new detachments from Kronstadt were "unsatisfactory, exacting, undisciplined, unreliable in battle, and doing more harm than good"
By 1919 the revolutionary forces of Kronstadt and the Baltic had been exhausted. Those who rebelled in 1921 were not in any way the same as those who had played a heroic role in 1917.
The actual rebellion itself was in effect no different from the many other such anti-Bolshevik movements of the civil war.
Village
The l workers were divided into hostile camps depending on their links with the village, and the army too was tied to the village. More than once an army detachment had to be disarmed. These problems stemmed from the civil war, and the backwardness of Russia, but the fact remains that the rebellions were in essence counterrevolutionary and had to be quelled - peacefully if possible, by force if necessaryKronstadt differed from other such episodes because the anarchists and Social-Revolutionaries from Petrograd flocked to Kronstadt, in an attempt to make political capital out of it. It is from the printed material of these groups that the legend of Kronstadt was developed.
We should dispel the myths about Trotsky's personal role in the suppression of Kronstadt. Trotsky took no direct part in it. The decision was taken, with Trotsky's participation, at the Tenth Party Congress, to suppress the rebellion by military force if the fortress could not be induced to surrender, first by peace negotiations. then by an ultimatum.
After the decision Trotsky stayed in Moscow and took no further part in the affair. He proposed that dealings with the Kronstadters should be put in the hands of the Petrograd party leaders who had recently enjoyed their confidence, and with whom Trotsky was at that time in factional dispute over the trade union question.
Stalin
Finally: Laurens Otter says that Trotskyists only date the degeneration of the Russian Revolution from the time of Stalin's coming to power. To put things this way is a nonsense.
Firstly, it is to see history simply as a matter of the role of personalities.
As Marxists we see history being made not by individuals but by the class struggle. Stalin was able to come to power because of a change in the balance of class forces resulting from the decimation of the best layers of the working class during the civil war, and the consequent demoralisation and exhaustion. If it had not been Stalin, it would have been someone else.
By 1921 the Soviets were hollow shells, and Lenin described the Soviet Union as a workers' state but with bureaucratic deformations.
After the end of the civil war, Lenin proposed the New Economic Policy, restoring some market economics, to alleviate some of the tensions between town and country that had led to rebellions like Kronstadt. (Laurens Otter is wrong to see Kronstadt as a movement of opposition to the NEP: the rebellion took place before NEP was introduced).
The NEP, however, strengthened the rich peasants, and ultimately weakened the position of the working class.
It was these historical conditions that led to the triumph of Stalinism, and not a particular personality.
ARTHUR BOUGH, Stoke.