[rae Tony Greenstein's accurate characterisation of Israel as…]
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-09-04Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
rae Tony Greenstein's accurate characterisation of Israel as a settler-colonial state (letters, 7 August) drew my attention to the inadequacies in Belinda Weaver's comments on the vice-regal sacking of the Whitlam Labour government in 1975 (SO, 7 August).
Australia was, like Israel, . "established by driving out another people, institutionalising racism into every aspect of its functioning..supporting reaction both in neighbouring states and worldwide."
From the founding of the Commonwealth in 1901 to today the Labour Party and the dominant section of the trade union movement have underpinned the essential characteristics of settler-colonialism as outlined by Greenstein.
The exclusion of non-Europeans from most unions in the 19th century, the championing of the White Australia Policy, the Hawke Labour government's sabotage of Aboriginal Land Rights and Australia's role as a miniimperialist power in the Pacific and South East Asia bears strong resemblance to Israel's role in the Levant and North Africa.
The vice-regal sacking did not give birth to an Australian republican movement; that movement, expressing the bunyip-nationalist fantasies of smallholders, fascists, recruiting officers, cheap populists of the neo-Stalinist species, and their academic and literary acolytes has existed since Europeans began a genocidal nightmare still haunting that continent.
Australian nationalism, of which republicanism is an intrinsic part, is as reactionary as its British parent.
The triumph of Afrikaaner republicanism simply cleared the decks for a renewed frenzy of settler-colonial atrocities.
An Australian socialist society, embracing the interests of its multi-ethnic population shall, in consigning settler-colonialism to the trash-can of history, automatically divest itself of any, residual association with Britain's royal mummers.
ROD QUINN Chalk Farm, London