Ultra-violet and lies
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-09-04Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
Subscribe Get Socialist Organiser each week delivered by post. Rates: £8.50 for six months, £16 for Please send me 6/12 months' sub. I enclose £..... To: Socialist Organiser, PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA. FRIDAY 5 SEPTEMBER. The Great Nuclear Debate*, organised by Friends of the Earth and Greenpeace, 7.30pm. Central Hall, Westminster.
SATURDAY 6 SEPTEMBER NOTTS NUM MINEWORKERS GALA. Assemble 10.30 am, Mansfield _eisure Centre, Chesterfield Road, Mansfield, to march to Nest Notts College of Further Education. Speakers nclude Mick McGahey and Dennis Skinner.
THURSDAY 11 SEPTEMBER, Campaign Group News ally, 'Campaigning for socialism'. Speakers include Tony Benn, Eric Heffer, Joan Maynard, Eddie Newman. 1.30pm, Free Trade Hall, 'eter St., Manchester.
SATURDAY 13 SEPTEMBER. El Salvador Solidarity Campaign Picket. 12 noon. US Embassy, Grosvenor Sq.. London.
THURSDAY 18 SEPTEMBER. N.E. Region National Wher Socialist Organiser stands for West. We aim to help organise Party and trade unions to figh working class socialism. Name...
Address. : the left wing in the Labour it to replace capitalism with to your a year. THIS WEEK, I conclude my article on the ozone layer by looking at the consequences of the increased ultra-violet radiation resulting from its destruction. Then George Davey Smith reveals the truth about "lie detectors' UV radiation is produced by very hot objects. It is more energetic than ordinary light but less than X-rays. We cannot see it though some insects can.
Some types of UV are particularly well absorbed by DNA, the genetic code of living things The UV damages the DNA, killing small organisms like flies, fish larvae, bacteria and algae and causes skin cancer in larger animals.
The first humans, evolving in Africa, had a black pigment in their skins to filter out UV, though a small amount of UV had to be allowed through to make Vitamin D. As humans migrated to less sunny parts of the world, those with mutations giving them less skin pigment would have survived better. Those with dark skins would have got rickets through Vitamin D deficiency.
Nowadays, we can get our Vitamin D from our food so skin pigment is unimportant. However, light-skinned people have ess protection in very sunny ands and need to take precauions to avoid the danger of skin An increase in UV (following a irop in ozone levels) would indoubtedly cause a rise in skin cancers, perhaps even in those vith the darkest skins. There vould also be an increase in slindness due to cataracts. These effects could be countered wearing extra clothing. goggles, etc.
The effect on other life forms vould be more serious. Plankton microscopic plants and animals) loating in the top metre of sea vould either die or would have o migrate lower in the water here they would get less light ind would grow less. A 10% ncrease in UV would also kil! off Ill fish larvae in the tog ten netres of sea.
These effects would seriously isrupt life in the oceans which lepends ultimately on the plankon. This, and other effects, rould also disrupt life on land.
CFCs should therefore be mmediately banned, but even if hey are, those already present 1 the atmosphere will cause an creasing loss of ozone for ecades. ie detectors are used exensively by law enforcesent agencies in the Unitd States and evidence com them can be presentd in court. They are also sed by private companies i screen potential employes, interviewees being sked if they have ever emmitted thefts or similar rimes.
Their use in the UK at GCHQ and her intelligence agencies has recentbrought them to public attention, id expansion of their use into the iminological field is apparentiy suppted by some influential policemen and politicians.
Calling these machines lie detectors makes it seem that they somehow actually detect people lying. Of course, they do nothing of the sort. What they do record are changes in heart rate, blood pressure, respiration rate and skin conductance (the ability of the skin to conduct electricity, which is influenced by the degree of sweating) while the subject is being interrogated.
Conflicting reports of how accurate machines are have always appeared.
Accuracy of lie detection can be considered in two ways.
The probability that a liar has a positive test (i.e., is discovered) is called sensitivity. For example, a sensitivity of 80% means that eight out of ten liars will have a positive test - but two out of ten will have a negative test (i.e. will be falsely classed as truthful).
The probability that a truth-teller has a negative test is called the specificity A specificity of 70% means that 7 out of ten truth-tellers have a negative test — but three out of ten truth-tellers will be incorrectly classed as liars.
Comparies who sell lie detectors (called polygraphs in 'legitimate' scientific work) claim high accuracy -nearly 90% sensitivity and specificity.
However, there are many problems with evaluating the machines.
How are independent criteria for truthfulness established? Do the observers have any other clues as to the subjects' truthfulness besides the polygraph recording?
Do the observers know what proportion of their subjects are liars?
-All of these could bias the results in favour of lie-detector accuracy. Given the companies' commercial interest in selling the machines, it is not surprising that independent investigators nave found lower accuracy - sensitivities ranging from 60% to 80% and specificities from 50% to 70%..
Poor
Since polygraph recordings have not been able to consistently pick out individuals with early hypertension (high blood pressure), coronary heart disease, and neurological conditions, from normal subjects, it is to be expected that their ability to detect liars is poor.
A group of US doctors who recently reviewed the evidence concluded that: *There is no rational scientific basis for any machine to detect liars consistently, since there is no known consistent physiological response unique to the cognitive state of lying".
Even assuming the highest accuracy level, the machines will wrongly identity many people. Furthermore, the degree of incorrect identification will average assumption regarding accuracy (76% sensitivity and 63% specificity) in a group of 1000 people, 50% of whom are liars, there will be 120 liars missed and 185 people wrongly accused of lying.
However, in a group of 1000 of whom 5% are liars, there will be 351 people wrongly accused of lying. and 12 liars missed. Truthful persons incriminated as liars here outnumber actual liars by seven to one.
In a pre-employment screen the proportion of criminals is likely to be low, and so a very large number of people will be slandered by the test, their employment chances ruined.!
This article allows the categories. liar' and 'criminal' to be taken on their own LOLITS• Clearly SOCaLStS CanTOL allow them to go unchallen. ged. "Criminals and liars" are often people struggling to survive under capitalism.
The true thieves (capitalists and their servants) get off scot free, often even when actually caught cheating for sums vastly greater than the 'criminals*.
Even on its own terms, the polygraph is misnamed when called a liedetector, as it performs this task very poorly. Its use should be opposed universally, except perhaps on politicians at election time.
But then again, we already they albilie..
----- pull-quotes -----
Activists? DIARY
STAND workers liberty, East and
increase as the proportion of liars in the sample is decreased. Using an