Our Rosa
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-09-04Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
ROSA Luxemburg was a leader in the international socialist movement early this century. Born in Poland in 1871, she was active in underground socialist groups from the age of 17. Forced into exile, she lived for a time in Zurich, attending university, organising in the working-class movement, and discussing with the leading exiled Russian Marxists of the day, Axelrod, Plekhanov and Zasulich.
Rosa was active both in German Social Democracy, and the Polish Social Democratic Party, which was affiliated to Russian Social Democracy. Most of Poland was then part of the Russian empire. —Rosa moved to Germany in 1898 to work in the socialist movement there. The German Social Democratic (i.e., socialist) Party was the largest and best organised of the international socTalist movement of the time, the Second International.
Rosa was the leader of the left wing in the international socialist movement before 1914, and of the revolutionary opposition to World War I. She wrote important books and pamphlets against reformism; on the use of the mass strike as the basis for the struggle for socialism; and on imperialism andthe nationl question (on both of which she differed from Lenin).
The new film 'Rosa Luxemburg' , by German director, Margarethe von Trotta, is a personal view of the life of this political woman. Von Trotta calls the film a 'fragment', claiming Rosa's life was too full to be condensed into two hours of film, Von Trotta is obviously personally sympathetic to Luxemburg. In the discussion after the film's showing on 26 August at the National Film Theatre, von Trotta recalled her first sight of Rosa's face on placards carried by rebellious German students in 1968. She was attracted to Rosa's 'sad, interiorised' face.
Von Trotta wanted to rehabilitate Rosa, by finding the reality beyond the two common stereotypes - from the right wing, the view of 'Bloody Rosa' bloodthirsty revolutionary, and from the left wing, that of the political martyr.
Humanise
In West Germany, Luxemburg is a controversial figure. When her face appeared on postage stamps in the -1960s, some postal workers refused to handle, and some recipients refused to accept, letters bearing the stamp.
Von Trotta wanted to "humanise" Rosa. She turned to Rosa's thousands of personal letters - written to her lover, Leo Jogiches, to Luise Kautsky, to Sonia Liebknecht and other friends "and comrades, rather than to Rosa's political writings, for the 'real' Rosa.
Rosa endured many personal trials, as evidenced in her letters. As a young Polish Jewish woman active in German Social Democracy, she had to overcome strong prejudice from those who resented her sex as much as her radicalism, intelligence and political clarity. She had to struggle not to be sidelined into 'women's issues' , rather than the burning political issues of the day.
But she still played an active role in all party debates, and in the mass movement. She relentlessly fought the reformist ideas of Bernstein, a leading Party theoretician, and tried to pull the Party away from parliamentarism and cautious reformism into the revolutionary struggle.
The early parts of the filth show passionate, fiery Rosa. We see Rosa at party forums and at mass mettings, fearlessly putting her views. These early scenes, despite confusing leaps back and forth in time, show Rosa the speaker and activist, inspiring and fearless as she fights the caution and backwardness of the 'grand old men' of German Social Democracy, which included August Bebel, a former colleague of Marx and Engels. She was not afraid to fight Kautsky, then known as the Pope of Marxism, as early as 1910, even though Lenin and others continlued to respect Kautsky till 1914., We see her refusing to dance with Bernstein, the proponent of reformism, at a Party celebration. "I can't dance with you tonight, and polemicise against you tomorrow' ', she tells him sharply.
In another scene, she describes herself and Clara Zetkin, a fellow left-winger as 'the last real men of German Social Democracy' . Bebel and Kautsky are not amused.
Returning from Warsaw in 1906, Rosa is filled with excitement about the revolutionary possibilities in Russia, where the revolutionary movement in 1905 established workers' councils (soviets) as alternative forms of working class power for the first time. She tries to inspire the German Party with the example of the Russian workers.
These scenes are well worth seeing the film for. We look forward to Rosa's excitement over the coming Revolution in Russia in 1917.
Sad woman
But we wait in vain. The second half of the film lurches into despair. We see Rosa almost broken by the outbreak of war in 1914, and by the betrayals of the Party leaders who failed the revolutionary, internationalist test by falling in behind the war effort. From then, Rosa seems defeated.
1917 only brings her the news of the death of Kostya Zetkin, the son of her friend and comrade, Clara. It does not bring the news of the Russian Revolution — though Rosa wrote:
*Theirs (the Bolsheviks, led by Lenin and Trotsky) is the immortal historical service of having marched at the head of the international proletariat with the conquest of political power and the practical placing of the problem of the realization of socialism, and of having advanced mightily the settlement of the score between labour and capital in the entire world.
In Russia the problem could only be posed. It could not be solved in Russia. And in this sense, the future everyWhere belongs to Bolshevism.' This is a severe lack in the film, and I asked von Trotta why it had been left out. She replied that she had at first planned to include it, had planned scenes and documentary footage, but had been overwhelmed by the compexities of the issues and Rosa's response to it. I'm not convinced: while Luxemburg did criticise aspects of the Revolution, her basic identification with it was uncompromising and clear.
But part of the reason for its being left out can be traced to von Trotta's own politics, which are not class politics. The Russian Revolution was a victory of the working-class, and Rosa Luxemburg hailed it as such. Her politics were class politics.
But the film is otherwise. Rosa Luxemburg, who-was a fighter for the working-class movement all her life, who firmly rejected reformism in favour of revolutionary struggle for a working-class overthrow of capitalism, who was vilified as 'Bloody Rosa' by her enemies, is presented in the second half as a sad woman, a pacifist who this hated violence, a poetical writer more Rosa Luxemburg at home with plants and animals than on the barricades and party platforms of the international socialist movement. The opening credits describe Rosa as a pacifist.
There is no doubt that Rosa was at times despondent, especially in her letters from prison. She had a deep love of nature. But her actions show that, despite periods of doubt and despondency, she never deserted the cause of socialism.
Fighter
Rosa was against militarism - we see her speaking early in the film at a mass meeting. She spoke out so strongly against the First World War that she spent the greater part of the war in solitary continement in prison, so that her views could not be heard. She correctly saw the war as one where the German ruling class would send the working class to fight and die to safeguard their profits.
Just as the German ruling class wanted to protect their economic interests abroad, so they would at home, should workers ever try to overthrow the capitalist system. Rosa was never opposed to the use of force by workers. in an uprising against the capitalist system. Her whole life shows that. Rosa was no meek pacifist.
In her speech on the Spartacus programme at the founding conference of the German Communist Party in 1918, Rosa showed she was far from tired or beaten.
T hope that, as in my own case, so in yours also, the augmenting talks we have to undertake will neither abate zeal nor paralyze energy. Far from it, the greater the task, the more fervently will you gather up your forces.
Nor must we forget that the revolution is able to do its work with extraordinary speed. I shall make no attempt to foretell how much time will be required. Who among us cares about the time, so long as our lives suffice to bring it to pass?"
In showing us a beaten, despondent Rosa, von Trotta is denying history.
Von Trotta's politics are primarily those of the West German peace movement. She sees the threat of nuclear war in Europe as the major issue today for West Germans. Von Trotta wants the peace movement to grow. She is pessimistic about the chances of success - 'and with our history, no wonder', she says.
These pacilist, pessimistic politics permeate the second half of Rosa Luxemburg' , and they kill off the film. The purpose of Rosa' 's rehabilitaion is for von Trotta to make use of Rosa as a symbol for the peace movement -Rosa, the victim of militaristic violence.
The film repeatedly shows Rosa as a victim - of men; her lover, Jogiches, denies her children, and answers her love letters with political tirades; of militarism, whose brutality silenced her forever by killing her and dumping her body in a canal; of the socialist movement, which supposedly propelled her into violence she did not want and of the German Social Democratic Party, which supposedly knew of the plot to kill her and fellow comrade, Karl Liebknecht, but which did nothing to stop it.
Murdered
Rosa was brutally murdered, but making her a victim and casualty, Trotta is downgrading Rosa's and politics. Rosa was part of the s ialist movement - a movement com itted to the overthrow of brutal capit ism. Rosa fought, and fought to w She knew the struggle would be one the death, with the bourgeoisie fig ing tooth and nail to protect its pri eges and wealth and power. Her me ory should be an inspiring and posit one, not one permeated with defeat.
The film is a fragment — Rosa's i volvement in the Spartacus moveme after her release from prison is treat hurriedly and confusingly. Ma Many things remain unclear. But precis because it is a fragment, people m be moved to seek out Luxembur writings for themselves. The film ca be criticised for not telling the whi story.
But it should be criticised for telli an untrue story, which at times does. Those who go on to read Luxe burg's writings will discover the r Rosa Luxemburg for themselves. BABY By Tracy After being away for three weeks! decided to do a fair bit of television watching last week.
I thought "To Have and to Hold" was a documentary about surrogate motherhood. However it turned out to be the first of a three-part drama, a soppy and boring one at that, but then the middle classes always leave me bored.
Anyway, it's basically about two sisters, affluent at that. Ann, married, successful in career, apologises for saying 'damn' and can't have children. So her sister Viv, all Body Shop products, Habitat furnishings and allotment decides she should help her sister out and have a child for her.
Anyway everything appears to be fine and dandy until the husbands hear about it. Ken, Viv's husband, is the typical religious, self-opinionated man just like Ken Barlow in tact, maybe it's the name) who objects because of his stupid pride...
If his special little batch of sperm can't do the job properly, then it's out of the question.
What's sad about the programme is that Ann feels "lost" and "empty" because she can't have children - Ann with her wishy-washy liberal views even goes on to say to Ken while trying to persuade him at first to adopt: "I'd love it, black or white or whatever" Desperation this, racist desperation at that.
Fortunately for both women they are middle class, have economic independence from their husbands and a certain degree of control over their lives. However in the real world the question of surrogate motherhood is not so rosy.
Working class women ate particularly susceptible to this as rich white people will want to buy their own children. For working class women it is a way of making a tew quick thousand, easter than trying to get a decent job in fact.
For the rich it's another way of exploitingth i leave you with the cheque book will you buy a child on the way home from the coffee morning"
So they've finally decided to talk about racism on television. Not only talk about it, but a whole programme, "The Black and White Media Show" dedicated to it!
1 sometimes wonder why any of us bother to watch television as it contin ues to insult us all in one way or However the racist abuse on television is in my opinion the most blatantly cruel abuse faced by any one section of our class.
Comedians, i.e. the stand-up types, are skilled at the racist game, and it is clear that TV tells lies about our class and peddles these racist myths and ideologies.
available from 33 London E3. 20p Socialist Or aniser no,282 4 September 1986 Pa
Scan page 10
QF MARXISM DEPORTATI
----- pull-quotes -----
views 'Rosa Luxemt stor Margarethe von
on the Box
Youth Fightback special on racism,
Hackworth Point, Rainhill Way,