Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

How World War 3 could start

Socialist Organiser no. 282, 4 September 1986 · scan p. 10 · about 1,211 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

Solid line: 007's actual route. Dotted: its flight plan nia. He got onto the California - continue to prevail.

Martin Thomas rev The North-West Pacific che area where the USSR shot down the Korean jumbo-jet KAL 007 with 269 passengers and crew on 1 September 1983 — is, so R.W. Johnson argues, the most likely site for the beginning of World War 3.

The world's four biggest powersthe US, the USSR, Japan and China -are eyeball-to-eyeball in the area. And the US has plans according to which it would respond to moves by the USSR elsewhere, for example in the Middle East, by an attack in the North-West Pacific The US has massive superiority in this region. Although the area's resources are important for the USSR, its military strength there is hampered by poor communications through the barrenness of Siberia. The eastern USSR is further from Moscow than Jamaica is.

So the US could launch a devastating attack here even with conventional weapons. The US warlords' calculations are that it could be a 'limited" war, stopping short of a full-scale nuclear holocaust. Few people would live to tell the tale if their guess should prove wrong.

Such is the framework in which Johnson analyses the shootdown. He pinpoints one other basic background fact. In July the US had discovered a major new USSR military radar installation at Krasnoyarsk - well inland, but apparently covering part of the north-west Pacific region. The US was anxious to find out exactly what this radar could do.

None of this proves that the KAL 007 fight had anything. to do with US surveillance; and indeed Johnson stresses that it is impossible to prove that KAL 007 was not just off course by accident.

But Johnson does argue that surveillance is the most likely explanation for the plane going • over USSR airspace.

KAL 007 had no surveillance equipment itself. But it was flown off course USSR KAMCHAT Sea of Okhotsk Nukke PENINSULA "SLAND CHINA 1826 hya KURILE : Anytim ppi MONERON, I"TO" North Pacific Vladivostai HORKAIDO / Nokka -IN KOREA JAPAN Tokyo in order to trigger all the USSR's air defence and radar systems, and to give the huge US surveillance facilities in the region a chance to monitor them.

It is commonplace to use reconnaissance planes — and civilian planes — for such probing. What was unusual about KAL 007 was that the probe was so deep, rather than a quick stab in and out of USSR airspace.

Motive

The motive, argues Johnson, could have been to bring the Krasnoyarsk radar into operation. That required both a deep probe and simultaneous jamming of the USSR's coastal radar — something the US could have done quite easily.

To use a military plane for the deep probe would have been risky: it the USSR shot it down or forced it down, the US government would suffer a big propaganda blow. A civilian plane was better. The USSK would be much more worried about shooting it down. Quite likely it would escape scot-free - in fact KAL 007 nearly did so, being shot down only just before it left USSR airspace - and if it were forced down, even a slightly dubious story about being accidentally off course would be good enough to stop the USSR making a big propaganda coup, Such is the theory. There is no proof of it, but it does fit all the known facts. On the other hand, Johnson says, no theory so tar put torward about KAL UNITED STATES 65° ALASKA Eielson• (USAF) 349 hrs Anchorage Rethel KOMANDORSKI SAKHALIN 1787 tre A Minno E° ALEUTIAN ISLANDS - SANeeve 087y tight plan 007 being off course accidentally the facts.| Johnson cites:

*Notes on KAL 007's flight plan made before take-oft by the pilot, indicating the deviations in advance and requesting more fuel than normal.

*The fact that the plane was off course at its first radio beacon, soon after take-off. For technical reasons it was very difficult indeed for this to happen without the crew noticing.

*The fact that the plane made a turn just before the Soviet island of Sakhalin. This could not happen by a wrong setting in the navigation system. The plane also made inexplicable variations in speed, and gave deliberately false radio reports of altitude.

*The anxiety of the US to avoid investigation. The US official body which was legally obliged to investigate the disaster was stopped from doing so, and the inquiry was instead put in the hands of a UN body which was bound to produce a diplomatic fudge causing minimum offence to the US and USSR.

Johnson also examines dozens of other details pointing in the same direction. And he gives a vivid sketch of the interrelations and the psychol ogy of the top US government people who might have ordered a surveillance mission.

The key man was William Clark, at the time National Security Advisor Clark is a Reagan crony from Califor-u Supreme Court without ever finishing law school, and into command of Us foreign policy without even schoolboy general knowledge of world politics. | On an operation like this he would have bypassed Secretary of State George Schultz, and probably Reagan himself. Clark would have worked closely with CIA director William Casey, a friend with a similar flamboyant right-wing philosophy.

Such are the people on the US side who could throw us into World War 3.

Johnson also examines the USSR side.

The USSR's official accounts of the shootdown were even more dishonest and contradictory than the US's.] Truth The truth of the matter, reckons Johnson, is that the USSR Air Defence Force (a separate body from the main airforce) felt that they would lose out in the manoeuvring within the bureaucracy if they let the plane escape scot free. They had not done a good job of tracking it. They intercepted KAL 007 only a short distance inside USSR air space. Probably they were not sure what it was. Rather than checking, and risking an escape, they shot.

At the time of the shootdown we had a dispute on the SO editorial board. Our coverage made its main attack on the Ussk for shooting down the plane — while denouncing Reagan's hypocrisy and the cold-war arms drive, and pointing to the possibility that KAL 007 had been used for US surveillance purposes.

Some comrades felt that the USSR was not really at fault: KAL 007 was certainly on a surveillance mission, and it is right to shoot down spy planes. Our main attack must be against "anticommunism' Johnson gives no comfort to this point of view. *The Russians...shot the plane down;..they...lied about it for days; (and) killing hundreds of innocent civilians was unjustified whatever 007's reason for being off course. If it was really true that the Russians...misIdentified the plane as a (reconnaissance plane) it was still their duty to make a correct identification before loosing off missiles...

This moral and political case remains untouched. What Johnson does show: us is a light cast by the KAL 007 affair on the frightening probability of an alldestroying World War Three, so long as Ne let the worid's resent filers

----- pull-quotes -----

'Shootdown' , by R Johnson (Chatto & Windus, £10.95)

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 282

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →