Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Guardian's two worlds

Socialist Organiser no. 282, 4 September 1986 · scan p. 11 · about 550 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 11

Its NUM The Guardian has at leas kinds of readers. There's the Poly ocracy - the brown rice and samdals brigade with the 2CVs; there's the yuppies, with their mediarelated jobs. Volvo estates and tasteful Hijitat furniture; then there are the lefties of all varieties from shop stewards to student union activists to Socialist Organi ser columnists.

That's not to say that the categories cannot overlap, or that a shop steward wouldn't buy Habitat furniture. But it can cause the Guardian identity problems.

Pro-Alliance editorials often sit uneasily with left of Kinnock 'Agenda' articles and the erratic (and increasingly irregular) cartoons of Steve Bell who makes no pretence of even-handedness.

When the Guardian comes to discuss the labour movement its identity crisis really comes to the fore. It doesn't adopt the sneering, hostile stance of most of the British press, but it cannot decide whether it's really a voice from within the movement (a role that the Mirror likes to adopt) or a friendly but objective outside observer.

The run-up to the TUC Congress (when the real business is done) saw Keith Harper and Patrick Wintour (Labour Editor and Labour Correspondent respectively) playing the role of insiders, keeping Guardian readers abreast of the latest wheeling and dealing behind the scenes: "Pay split at TUC dashes Kinnock hopes"' was one confident prediction, Press Nearer the mark was Harper's description of Ron Todd's role: "Mr Todd is fervently committed to the return of a. labour government above all else, and has repeatedly said that he is ready to forget differences on some priorities with Labour in order to get Mr. Kinnock elected."

While Harper and Wintour gave us the low-down on the pre-Conference manoeuvring, the Guardian's leader writers took a lotty overview: guarded approval for the joint Labour PartyTUC 'People at Work' document (also plugged by Labour's employment spokesperson John Prescott in Friday's "Agenda' page) was combined with a characteristic sigh of regret: "Why won't those pig-headed trade union leaders treat with the Alliance?"

Thursday's leader pointed out quite rightly —the "considerable similarities of approach between the SDP document and the Labour-TUC document" , and sadly complained that "in a well-ordered platonic world one might now expect the SDP and the unions to sit down and discuss these proposals from positions of mutual respect. That isn't going to happen."

Platonic

On Monday, the first day of Congress, the leader returned to the same theme: "It may go against the instinctive Labour grain but this week's Brighton assembly should not overlook, for example, the apparent willingness of the Social Democratic Party, as signalled in its policy document last week, to move away from that role as the hammer of the unions which some in its leadership had earlier looked to be set on. "

That's the sort of thing the Volvo/ Habitat crowd (and quite a few of the 2CV and sandals brigade) want to see: a responsible, moderate trade union movement taking business with Mr. Owen and Mr. Steel.

And who knows, come the next election we might end up with a hung parliament and Mr. Kinnock having to sit down "platonically" with Mr Owen and Mr Steel as well. That really would be cause for celebration in Habitatland: • Socialist Organiser no.282 4 September 1986 Page 11 Urganiser no.404

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 282

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →