Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

[The passing of the NGA resolution in making…]

Socialist Organiser no. 282, 4 September 1986 · scan p. 12 · Tony Benn · about 953 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 12

The passing of the NGA resolution in making it appear that it will all is a great victory for the Wapping be easy when we know that interargument! In my opinion many unions will totally ignore it.

It was a damn good lobby of the TUC on Monday. There were large numbers of people there, primarily print workers. Those of us who were there representing the sacked miners found inspiration in the determination of the printworkers to carry the fight on.

Gavin Laird had to run in, like a startled rabbit. Seeing trade union leaders having to run away from workers really summed up for us what the TUCis about.

A lot of the delegates going in looked just too polished and pink to me, as if they were doing very well out of the slump. Some of them are bloody Tory hacks. If they're workers' representatives then things have got to a tidy pass.

I can't for the life of me understand trade union people voting for state imposed ballots which will hang like a millstone round our necks and which we'll find difficult to throw off in the future. It may be all well and good for delegates to sit back and argue something in the abstract, but those delespeech she did because of what is happening to her members — that's a gates should realise that it could be themselves who get shackeld by their own legislation.

You can't and shouldn't legislate to try to stop disputes and strikes. Whatever the law says or does, workers will continue to express their feelings when they find themselves up against a blank wall - they will withdraw their labour and begin to fight back.

/EEK Paul Whetton is secretary of Bevercotes NUM, Notts.

Labour's proposed trade union laws are a scandal. When Tory judges pronounce penal sentences against workers we won't be able to point the finger against the Tories any longer — we're going to be staring at our own elected representatives, who started the vicious circle off in the first place.

I was very surprised when the NUM withdrew its amendment to the resolution on the Labour Party-TUC document. I wasn't part of the discussion strong enough." That's the reaction you get from ordinary working people. and was very disappointed. I think they're playing into the hands of Lynk and co, who accuse the NUM of lack of democracy — the NUM rank and file had no say in the withdrawal of that amendment.

When the resolution moved by the NGA against the EETPU was carried, it was a victory for printworkers, of a kind. But when you examine it and see what it really means, all it does is give the EETPU a slap on the wrists. So What they really need is the commitment to get the printworkers their jobs back. Talk about compensation means accepting that they're not going to get their jobs back, they're going to be paid off instead. The issue is not just giving sacked workers a few quid -that's exactly what the Tories and bosses want. The issue is jobs.

OK, the EETPU should in my view be expelled because of their actions, but it is a distraction in so far as it gets away from the real argument which is how the Wapping strikers can win and get their jobs back. The tragedy is that the TUC debate wasn't about getting the sacked printers their jobs back. people. It indicates the strength of support in the trade unions for those who take action, just as last year and the year before the TUC supported the miners.

Labour

A Labour government will have to take note of that, as will the TUC General Council itself.

On the first motion - supporting the joint Labour Party-TUC Liaison Committee document — no doubt the dominant consideration was the desire to show unity at this period so it was passed.

But the problem created by the new document is that it could easily bring a Labour government into conflict with unions when Labour is in power, and therefore there will have to be pressure maintained to see that does not happen.

I think the desire for unity will be the dominant consideration at the Labour Party Conference as well, and that will be reflected in the speeches and probably the resolutions and motions carried.

At the same time the situation does require, and will require when Labour is elected, very strong policies that will need to be made clear. The danger lies national canital xx7111 1a1 даинои а _VIUlent attack on a Labour Government, whatever sort of government it is. -And with the experience of Mitterrand in France, Gonzales in Spain, Soares in Portugal and even Hawke in Australia, it's quite clear that the function of the left in the movement is to see that we do not have the same experience here, a mere re-run of what happened before in Britain under Labour.

The vote on the NGA resolution is a practical matter; the other vote was on a general statement. The NGA resoluton is an absolutely clear statement land re-statement of the need for solidarity in struggle, and that is always relevant, whoever is in power.

Whether there's a Labour government, a Tory government, or a hung parliament, the working class solidarity theme is the critical one.

Indication And I think it's an indication of the way things are going that when you are talking about words people are prepared to go along with a general statement that may appear to attract public support. But when you are dealing with a concrete situation, like miners or printment has a majority for solidarity.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 282

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →