METTERS Arguing federalism
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-09-11Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
A recent debate in my Labour Party ment, civil war would follow - prosNottingham East — cast some light on In this scenario the Republic of Ire- pects for socialists and the Irish workthe discussion on treland m recent British imperialism. The logic of this is land doesn't exist, it is dominated by ing class would be set back for generaA motion was presented condemning that no nations exist. All nations are In demanding that the British disarm the lack of women's rights in Northern dominated by imperialism — not Brit- the Protestants before they, Sinn Fein themselves acknowledge this searching, blaming the entire situation The final argument was that federalon partition and the British occupa- ism puts conditions on troops out and By default, therefore, Sinn Fein also tion, and, finally, calling for self- such conditions imply a progressive acknowledge a progressive role for the role for the troops. SO should avoid In amending the resolution to allow falling into this simple but dangerous Thus, our programme implies no for a federal structure 1 faced a great progressive role for the troops out at Federalism is not so much a condi- any stage, whilst Socialist Action and We cannot tell the Irish what to do, tion of troops out as a facilitator for the International group cannot fulfill came the cry. Obviously, said I, but we troops out. It helps bring it closer their programme without the progrescan seek to influence ine debate because it aims to provide a possible sive involvement of British forces (to framework for working class unity in Unconvinced, my opponents return- Ireland. It has nothing to do with The amendment 1 proposed was ed with economic, arguments. HIA1T implying a progressive role for the defeated, but many non-aligned left still has capitalist interests in Ireland. wingers were partly convinced by our Adverts for firms to go to the North are CURLEE cheap ZOOUC 1s a maior incentive. In fact British imperialism In the unlikely event of troops but controls the whole of Ireland, including being realised without a political settle Lenin and Trotsky with soldiers who h The claim made by Rigby - that the with a cross-class coalition government the Tribune article and accepted SO's Kronstadt sailors of 1921 were not (i.e. a Popular Front). The sailors of claim that it was hypocritical. I was at those of 1917 has been frequently Willelmshaven and those of Kron- pains to quote Lenin's insistence that advanced by Trotskyists, but never stadt sought the same objective and there were bureaucratic deformations supported by evidence. An abundance (and incidentally he didn't say "workof evidence of the contrary has been The objective fact of the October ers' state" he said "workers' domingiven, not least by the Kronstadt Com- Revolution was workers' power ated state capitalist state"). So most of mune itself, but also by Rosmer, through the soviets. The Bolsheviks Ciliga, Ida mett, Serge and Avrich. constituted a large part, but not the But what makes Bough's letter I confined myself simply to pointing whole, of the subjective face that went classic is his claim that not until 1938 with that workers power. When were complaints made, and that this ment itself decreed in 1917, that Trotsky talked of a "river of blood" was done by agents of Stalin. Sylvia Decause of the importance of the "separating the party of Lenin from Pankhurst in Britain, Otto Ruhle and Kronstadt fortress to the protection of the party of Stalin" ', he was right that others in Germany, the Anarchist the capital, none of the revolutionary the party was not consciously counter- International Working Men's Associasailors should under any pretext be revolutionary until after the death of tion internationally — all published the details immediately after the rising in moved from Kronstadt, a decree that was never rescinded and was fully But an equal river of blood separated pamphlet form. The IWMA and varthe soviets of 1917 from those of 1924, ious other anarchist groups republishThe only new troops and sailors were soviets in 1917 ower and role of the ing it at frequent intervals thereafter. replacements for the dead and the 4% It was a matter of considerable of the garrison that did not vote for the debate in Bordigist and allied circles. demands of the Kronstadt Soviet were What happened in 1938 was that people like Ciliga and Victor Serge, asmawn tommese tew acemems. The 1921 revolutionary sailors there- who had suffered as Trotskyists in fore had a record - pace Rigby - Objectively, that was the counter- Stalin's concentration camps and had tried and tested revolutionaries; and it revolution. Stalin's actions in taking escaped from Russia, insisted that the Is unis tnat adas welgat to ten lasis the counter-revolution into the very matter be raised in Trotskyist circles. tence that you do not defend a revolu- party itself merely set the seal on a To describe people who underwent the tion by betraying its fundamental prin- process that was already virtually com- torture that Ciliga and Serge suffered, ciples; they were then as they for their loyalty to Trotsky, as agents of always have been - - the real defenders Stalin may have made the process irreversible, that is a different matter.
Rigby again resorts to the amalgam in trying to pretend that those who admire the Kronstadters are claiming Rigby should realise that his argu- that the soviet revolution should not ment boils down to an amalgam: Kron- have been defended. Reformists stadt sailors opposed the government deplore the October Revolution and say as did the counter-revolutionaries; it should not have been defended; Lefttherefore, given the opportunity, the ists deplore the betrayals by Lenin of sailors would have sided with the the revolution and support revolutioncounter-revolutionaries. This is the ary action against the Bolsheviks:
stuff of 1920s and 1930s Stalinist argu- therefore they say the revolution ments against Trotskyism. If it is valid should not be defended and are in the one case it is valid in both, if it is His imputation that the Kronstadt sailors were less committed than the Bough also claims didactically but Bolsheviks to the international revolu- with no evidence that the Kronstadt tion is either indicative of ignorance or sailors of 1921 were not those of 1917, is deliberate falsehood. This was the and also fails to note that I took the time when in Germany, the KPD and trouble to disprove the claim in my first the Comintern Representative were turning their backs on workers' risings cole in the suppression; T have not read I did not stress Trotsky's individual in order to further their collaboration the 26 counties.
issues of SO.
Ireland, calling. CC LO SUTO determination.
allow great trap.
tions.
ish but international.
troops.
disarm the Protestants).
In any case, self determination arguments. condition of troops out.
LIAM CONWAY, Nottingham lad taken part in suppression acted in solidarity.
Bough's letter is irrelevant..
Process