Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Two strikes: Which is the future?

Socialist Organiser no. 283, 11 September 1986 · scan p. 5 · about 1,416 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 5

and supporters, Dundalk, 14 August. Photo: Derek Speirs, Report.

Socialist, Organisor no!l September 11 1986, Pagét 283 FROM ONE point of view it was the sort of workers' victory we haven't had often in Britain for some years now, but which was common in the early "70s.

Management tried to control the workers in a big factory. Over a thousand workers struck. The management backed down from the confrontation, settling for a 'compromise' that gave the workers most of what they wanted. Militancy had won.

This workers' victory was at Short Brothers engineering works in East Belfast. And to win it the workers had to risk their jobs in an area where unemployment is over 20% (it's 13% in Britain).

Here the parallels end, for the issue between bosses and workers at Shorts was the right of the Protestant 95% of Shorts workforce to display Unionist bunting inside the factory. The Catholic 5% of the workforce rightly consider the presence of this bunting to be a hostile sectarian act directed against them.

Under the combined pressure of the USA, which provides important contracts for Shorts, and the British government, Shorts management -decided to try to take things in hand.

The same management has been nominally committed to employ more Catholics for years. Yet the proportion of Catholics and Protestants remains roughly what it has always been. It became urgent to deal with sectarian demonstrations when — in what looked like the prelude to an attempt to drive out the minority of Catholic workers — the clock cards of Catholic workers were removed and it was buzzed around the aircraft factory that some of them were IRA sympathisers.

Trappings That was when management issued the ultimatum to the workers to remove the Unionist trappings from the walls of the workshops.

The workers' response was another example of the nightmarish amalgam of bigoted communal politics and working-class militancy that has been on display in Northern Ireland intermittently since the workers at Harland and Wolffs shipyard struck early in 1971 and marched through the centre of Belfast to demand the introduction of internment without trial for Republicans.

Decades of sectarian job preferment have given the Protestants an industrial predominance greater by far than their two-to-one majority over the Catholics in the whole Six County population.

The virtual collapse of the Six Counties' manufacturing industry -40% of the jobs have gone — has hit Protestants most, since they had more of the jobs to lose, but it has not shaken their dominance in what industry remains.

Northern Ireland has also recently Peter Robinson with lan seen industrial action of a better sort, when 4000 civil servants walked out in protest at sectarian threats to murder their fellow-workers. This province-wide movement was triggered when civil servants at Lisburn DHSS office walked out in response to a threat against Catholics working there from the so-called Ulster Freedom Fighters, a nom de guerre for the legal Ulster Defence Association.What happened at Shorts is typical of the whole past of the working-class movement in Northern Ireland, a movement riddled with sectarianism and crippled by it. Does the civil servants' strike against sectarianism show us what the future will be like?

Can the working class in Northern Ireland unite across the sectarian divide?

Without a doubt the workers should unite; they should get together as a class across the sectarian divide; the trade unions should fight for equality of employment and against sectarianism. But the bitter truth is that the odds are very heavily against this happening, in the foreseeable future, on a wide enough scale to affect developments.

The civil servants' strike was one of the most hopeful signs in Northern Ireland for a long time. The other "signs" in Northern Ireland are very grim.

The traditional Unionist marching season is over without there having been any spectacular blow-up, but that is partly because the RUC and the Army bent with the Protestant wind - as they did, for example, wher they let a sectarian march go through a largely Catholic area of Portadown, as a compromise . The mass Protestant opposition to the ten-month-old Anglo-Irish agreement remains implacable.| Unionists have adjourned local councils and are planning to withdraw from them. The Ulster Clubs have declared a rates and TV licences strike.

While the Ulster Clubs and the UDA continue to grow, the Unionist parties are disarray, especially Official Unionist Party. The UDA claims to have 15,000 members -which, translated into British political terms, is equivalent to 900,000. The largely rural Ulster Clubs cannot be far behind it.

The constitutional nationalists of the SDLP have offered talks to the Protestants about setting up a "devolved" government in Belfast, but the Protestants are not interested so long as it is within the framework of the Anglo-Irish agreement, which gives Dublin a major political voice in the running of Northern Ireland. And the SDLP is not interested in devolved government without the Anglo-Irish agreement...

The Provisional IRA continues its military campaign, and that campaign has taken an ugly sectarian turn with threats to kill any worker whose job includes any form of direct or indirect servicing of the British army or the RUC.

200 council workers struck in Derry after the Provisionals shot a young council electrician, Mervyn Bell, dead.

The Provisionals have for a long time extended their definition of military targets to include all state personnel, right down to former members of the Ulster Defence Regiment. Such a definition claws in thousands of Protestants who are far from being hardcore military people, and inevitably has a sectarian dimension.

The new threat means spreading the definition even further to a very large range of workers, both Catholic and Protestant, but especially Protestant. There is no way this could not lead to an intensification of sectarianism.

And so it did. The Provisional IRA's threats produced counter-threats from the specialists in naked sectarian assassination, the so-called 'Ulster Freedom Fighters' wing of the legal Ulster Defence Association.

This symmetrical dual threat helped to trigger the civil servants' strike. However, a big campaign of sectarian killings is more likely to strengthen the IRA and UDA in their respective communities because it will seem to increase the value of their protection.

It would be wrong to see the IRA and the UDA as identical movements. The IRA is based on the long-oppressed Catholic community, and a struggle for liberation by that community which is fundamentally Just. The UDA detends the reactionary cause of Protestant supremacy.

But the latest IRA threat is thorpughly reactionary, implicitly sectarian, and indefensible from any socialist or working-class point of view.

Just as the affair at Shorts sums up the tragedy and the paradoxes of the divided Northern Ireland working class, the events in Dundalk a few weeks back, when Peter Robinson and a large group of militant Orangeists came to the town for Robinson's court appearance there, can be taken as representing on a small scale the terrible danger of sectarian civil war that looms as a real threat before the people of Ireland, Catholic and Protestant alike. The Orangeists clashed with Republicans and were showered with stones and petrol-bombs.

It was a commonplace scene from Northern Ireland, but something new in the South. Almost symbolically, it showed the conflict creeping south.

Justice is on the side of the Northern Ireland Catholics who rebel against the undemocratic partition of Ireland and the fact that they are trapped in a Protestant-dominated state. Yet just to side with the Catholics is not enough. Within the existing political framework, they are in a blind alley.

They cannot possibly overwhelm the Protestants, even if that were desirable; at most they can trigger the catastrophe of all-out civil war. They are isolated even from the Southern workers who, though mostly Catholic and nationalist, do not have and cannot have any wish to be dragged into a war with the Protestants.

Working-class unity is difficult to create: but the conclusion that we should instead just cheer on the nationalist struggle, in the hope that working-class unity will come after some nationalist victory, is a blueprint for disaster.

A democratic programme is needed which recognises the two basic democratic rights: the right of the people of Ireland as a whole to determine their own future, and the right of Ireland's Protestant minority not to be overrun by a Catholic-sectarian state. That means British withdrawal and a united Ireland, with some federal system to give local autonomy to the Protestant heartland area.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 283

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →