Jim Denham looks STRIKE DEALS
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-09-11Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 6
The "New Realists" of the TUC are looking to shackle their members to binding arbitration, no strike deals. What are the implications for effective shop floor organisation to resist management's erosion of working conditions in the new indusCONU Md Depu against sale of solvents to children. DIET tries?
"Of course there are people, sects and nuts, who actually believe that in being involved in strikes workers find out how to struggle and this leads them on for the revolution. My view is that the trade union function is to deal with matters in a way which doesn't involve workers in industrial action."
Eric Hammond In January of this year, the workers at Bowman Webber, a firm making mirrors in Harlow, struck for two weeks over the sacking of three workers, one of whom had been elected an EETPU shop steward the night before. What was unusual about this action was that it took place in a company that was covered by a no-strike deal with the EETPU. The sacked workers were reinstated, but the story has an interesting postscript: shortly after the strike, pendulum arbitration (the EETPU's favoured form of "strike substitute") was used to resolve another dispute over pay for doubleshift working, and it came down in favour of the workforce - the only occasion when this has happened in recent British history. Even the Guardian commented that, "whatever deals are made between unions and management, workers are still going to find that collectively withdrawing their labour will from time to time be necessary", The EETPU is, of course, the best known exponent of the single union, no-strike deal. But it is not alone: the AEU is openly emulating the electricians, and the GMB and the TGWU are tagging along as well, though the latter two unions have yet to formally lendorse the "no-strike" position.
Logical
The single union, no-strike deal is the logical conclusion of "New Realism" and few union leaders would disagree with the basic philosophy behind it, as expounded by Eric Hammond in the quotation above. Where the EETPU and the AEU have broken ranks with the rest of the TUC "New Realists" is in explicitly renouncing the strike weapon and substituting binding "pendulum" arbitration in their agreements. This means that production must continue through all stages of the dispute procedure, and if no settlement can be reached 'in company" , leads to binding arbitration as the final stage. At this last stage of the procedure, an "independent" arbi10/ EETPU rank and file at Wappe trator (usually from ACAS) is brought in to choose between the final positions. of the employer and the union - hence the "pendulum" tag. Supporters of the "pendulum" claim that it encourages moderation and "reasonableness" both sides, with employers putting forward their most generous offers and unions their most modest claims. In practice, however the union sides moderation is rarely matched by the employer, and the employer almost always wins.
The TGWU and the GMB currently reject the pendulum, but there are more ways of killing a pig than stuffing it with strawberries. John Edmunds at the GMB has launched a glossy single-union package deal to high-tech employers with arrangements designed to create "industrial relations consensus", including complete work flexibility, a comprehensive disputes procedure, and guaranteed "continuous production Last year the TGWU signed a single-union deal at Norsk-Hydro Fertiliser tormerly Fisons) Immingham. This was arguably a more treacherous deal than anything yet done by the EETPU or AEU, in that it took place in an