Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Wall of death

Socialist Organiser no. 283, 11 September 1986 · scan p. 7 · about 1,790 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 7

People in East Berlin weretold that their "Anti-Fascist Wall of Protection" was necessary to prevent the imperialist Western forces from invading and plundering their "socialist fatherland" Though it has been East Berliners crossing over to the West who 50UT ing. Photo: Andrew Wiard, Report. established and operating plant with a well-developed multi-union structure. There had been four main unions on the site, TGWU, AUEW (now the AEU), EETPU and ASTMS, with five convenors and a union office provided by the company. A national Fisons Joint Consultative Committee also operated. When Norsk-Hydro took over they discontinued the JCC and announced a "New Personnel Package". This involved the establishment of an advisory council made up of management and directly elected employee (not necessarily trade union) representatives, complete flexibility of labour, moves towards "harmonisation" (of staff and manual conditions), introduction of continuous production and a new disciplinary agreement. Management forced through these changes by banning membership meetings on site and balloting individual workers. The TGWU agreed to the deal in the face of opposition from the other four unions on site, and won the single union franchise.

Necessary

Philip Bassett, Labour Editor of the Financial Times, argues in his book ('Strike Free: New Industrial Relations in Britain") that no strike, single union deals are a necessary, logical response to certain fundamental changes that have taken place in the last decade or so, "which are driving unions towards adapting themselves or going under, and their current, ex-, or potential members towards refocusing the question, stressing individualism over collectivism, 'What's in it for me?' ". These changes ("some...are permanent, some are too fundamental to be reversed" , he says) include:

*Labour market — Unemployment, obviously, is the key determinant...but almost as significant have been changes in employment - shifts from manufacturing to services, from men to women, from full-time to part-time."

*Work — "The collapse of old, collectivist industries like steel and shipbuilding, the growth of new, individualist ones like high-tech and services ...work has moved from the old industrial citadels of the North and Midlands to the market towns and fast-food chains of the South."

*Trade unionism — "For many new employees unions — and by extension (by voting, too: witness the appalling Labour/Union performance in the 1983 general election), the Labour Party — are just not important. an irrelevance.

/Attitudes to is a fundamental shift in attitude: a rooted individualism which while not precluding collective action, insists on itsebeing on its own terms - hence, especially, the perceived primacy of balloting as the principal means expression= Permanent The changes Bassett points to are real enough, and some (like the shift from manufacturing to services) may indeed be permanent. But he massively over-estimates the erosion of trade union organisation in general (another new book, "Unions, Unemployment and Innovation" by Batstone and Gowlay, argues that "union density remains high and the formal structures of workplace union organisation appear generally to be intact) and he appears to have no understanding of just how quickly individualistic, anti-union attitudes can be transformed, given a changed economic situation, or a well-organised, imaginative and militant counter-attack by the unions.

In an article in the New Statesman, Bassett quotes a young woman worker explaining why she hasn't bothered to join the EETPU under the single-union arrangement in her factory:

"It's a couple of quid a month going to I don't know who, and I don't know what it's doing, and I don't think a union can really help me anyway. It's the first time I've worked and I don't think I will."

Bassett asks, 'if the new employees find a union like the EETPU too militant, and necessary only when they've done something wrong...what hope is there for Britain's other unions?" But Bassett apparently misses the obvious point contained in the remark he quotes - that the woman can see no reason for paying money over to an organisation that she has no contact with on the shop floor, that appears to be indistinguishable from management and that does nothing to further her interests.

Model

It is the same story at Nissan in Washington New Town, where the AEU single-union, no-strike agreement is often held up as a model in "progressive" industrial relations: only 6% of the workforce have been impressed enough by the union's work on their behalf to see the need to join up.

Unconfirmed reports also say that Nissan recently locked the workforce in for six hours after supervisors stopped work over a grievance. Incidents like that — as well as the Bowman Webber strike - point to the way forward for militant trade unionism. Fancy deals, "industrial consensus" and phony "worker participation" will never prevent disputes breaking out on the shop floor. The fundamental aim of no-strike deals is not so much to guarantee that no strike will ever take place, but to ensure that workers cannot organise an effective strike — or any other form of effective action.

At Xidex Corp's plant at Brynmawr a secret ballot of the workforce threw out a pay freeze proposed by the company. The no-strike agreement at Xidex gave the EETPU official exclusive power to reach an agreement, which he did without a further ballot.

If the unions not only reject the business-unionism of the EETPU and AEU, but go onto the offensive and prove their worth in fighting for pay and conditions, consulting the rank and file at all times (remember, most no-strike, single union deals have been created on behalf of a workforce that is not yet even in place) and - most importantly - open their doors and reform their structures to accommodate young people, women and part time workers, then the tide can be turned. It's worth bearing in mind, amid all the ballyhoo about no-strike deals, that the high-tech industry is still largely non-union. An estimated 38% of Japanese firms in the EEC are non-union, and a further 44% have company unions. That is the opening that exists for genuine trade union organisation.

Bassett estimates that 9,000 workers are presently covered by these deals in Britain. The International Labour Organisation reckons that it is 20,000. At the very most, the figure amounts to one-third of one percent of organised trade unionists in Britain. But the threat is growing, and the recent TUC Congress demonstrated that both Norman Willis' and Neil Kinnock's vision of industrial relations under a Labour government are not so very different from what Eric Hammond and Bill Jordan are doing now at Sanyo, Toshiba and Nissan.

The tide can be turned, but it will require a break with the entire "New Realism" philosophy presently in the ascendant in the TUC, and the creation of a new, militant, rank and file based current within the unions to defeat Hammond, Jordan and their more bashful counterparts at the GMB and the TGWU. have been the victims of the Berlin Wall.

Tranks comrades!" and "Be grateful, comrades!" read the slogans on the official placards distributed to the crowds in East Berlin "celebrating" the 25th anniversary of the building of the Berlin Wall last month (August 13).

The Berlin Wall - or "AntiFascist Wall of Protection" . as it is officially called in East Germany — is a symbol and expression of Stalinist oppression. Erected in its initial primitive form on 13 August 1961 - ironically, the 90th anniversary of the birthday of the great German revolutionary Karl Liebknecht — it was an attempt to stem the flood of flight from Stalinist The official version of events, faithfully wheeled out this year as in previous years, is slightly different, "Neues Deutschland" • the daily paper of the East German government explained: "In the years 1960-1 the imperialist forces stepped up their aggressive preparations against the DDR (East Germany)...Border provocations increased. The attack was tested in a series of NATO manoeuvres...At the same time, there was an increase in the whipping up of unrest and acts of sabotage directed from Berlin (West).* Plunder Hence the building of the Berlin Wall: "The attempt to plunder and destabilise the DDR was dealt with promptly and decisively. The dream of Springer (West German press baron, now dead) and those behind him. came to nothing. The Day "X" (date of a supposed putsch directed by the "West) did not take place. Those who secured our state-border saved peace.

This too was the theme of the speech of Erich Honecker, general secretary of the SED (East German Communist Party) on the occasion of the "festivities" of 13 August: "With this historic deed was guaranteed the freedom of our people (!) and the foundation laid for the further flourishing of our state"

In mockery of those murdered trying to cross the "Anti-Fascist Wall of ProDefenders of socialism and peace? tection", Honecker declared: "It is our point of view that it is better to negotiate ten times, even one hundred times, than to shoot just once."

Honecker concluded his speech with the traditional chain of argument: the Berlin Wall preserves peace; the best guarantee of peace is a strengthening of the "socialist" camp; therefore labour productivity must be increased: On the basis of this understanding, millions of workers of our country aim for the realisation of the decisions of the 11th Congress of the SED under the slogan 'My place of work is my place of struggle for peace i.

Deterrence

Honecker's speech was followed by a military demonstration, led off veterans of the "Deed for Peace", by 1961, and followed by various sections of the East German armed forces, whose potential for deterrence was only marginally undermined by their resemblance to "Dad's Army"

Crowds lining the route of the demonstration broke into "spontaneous applause for the workers in uniform' especially in the presence of the "Neues Deutschland" photographer.

The day's happy events concluded with an official reception for those who had participated in the action of 13 August 1961. Veterans stressed that, far from resting on their laurels, they continued to work for the consolidation of their "socialist fatherland". One proudly boasted of how his factory hac faithfully met monthly production targets for the last 162 months.

Culminating point of the day's events was surely the speech of Horst Lenke, one of the officers in command in 1961: "To be honest, the full significance of 13 August 1961 was not completely apparent to me at the time. But one thing was clear to me: the party declares that the situation cannot remain as it is at present - action must be taken. With other fighters we secured the border, and we did that with joy and confidence. And you, dear comrade Erich Honecker, can appreci ate that best of all, for it was you who led this action." (Applause).

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 283

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →