Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Red and

Socialist Organiser no. 283, 11 September 1986 · scan p. 8 · about 743 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

There is a pressing need for a book that presents the arguments for combing. socialism and environmentalism, rescuing the former from its worship of capitalist technology and the latter from its preoccupation with matters far from the experience of most working Such a book would show that it is capitalism which presents the major threat to the environment in all its meanings. It would show that only a society based on socialist production could (and would?) live in harmony with its physical surroundings.

With this need in mind, I read *Red and Green' * Right away, there were problems. In the first chapter, Joe Weston of Friends of the Earth attempts to rescue the environment from the middle class Greens, defining it in a socialist way. The Greens see the environment as more or less identical with "nature" to them, the enemy threatening the environment is not capitalism but "industrialism" This view actually helps capitalism, since it allows it to recruit the support of the workers it exploits in its continued destruction of the environment of those workers. The alternative, say the capitalists, would be even worse poverty if the environmentalists got their way.

Weston rightly but irrelevantly attacks this view of some Greens. After all, the problem is to win the labour movement. Weston would probably not even win over any Greens with his rubbishing of their ideas. The complacency of such misleaders as Kinnock, who claim they have always been environmentalists is left intact.

The literary style of this and other contributions is that of ar academic treatise, hardly sur prising since four of the sever authors are lecturers. This does not aid understanding among ordinary readers.

Continuing the redefinition of the environment, we find chap ters 2 and 3, on the struggle for peace and on information tech nology. Unfortunately, the firs is incoherent and the second incomprehensible. A sample from its conclusion will illu strate:

"...the approach of many socialists and futurists misconceives technological change and ..the greens' insistence that we place questions of context and polities at the centre of technological change is essential to understanding its substance and significancel The next sentence talks about beginning to "demystify' technological change!

We are on to something better with a chapter by Michael Rudelift, a lecturer and writer on Third World development. He takes a penetrating look at the environmental crisis in the Third World through the example of Mexico. Is it the tault of ignorant peasants! Redelift puts the blame firmiy on the outsiders who imposed their rules first, the unashamedly plundering conquistadores and, later, multinational capitalism.

In a striking passage, Redclift quotes from a Spanish eyewitness of 1519 who describes an ingenious and productive system of agriculture in the Valley of Mexico, supporting a far greater population than that of England. He contrasts this with a government report of 1984 describing the same area, now a barren, eroded, deforested, polluted rubbish tip. Unfortunately, Redelift later allows his argument to become enmeshed in academic jargon.

In the best (and shortest!) section, Jeremy Seabrook paints powerful picture of the actual environment of the working class poor in the inner city, showing its effects on their lives.

Having defined a socialist environmentalism, the book now turns to how to fight for this. David Pepper, a lecturer and member of the Labour Party and Friends of the Earth, argues for an "anarchist" (he means "decentralised"") socialism, as opposed to "centralist" socialism. Many of his criticisms of the latter are really criticisms of right wing reformism - its tallure to see capitalism as the enemy; its lining up with the boss class in resisting attacks on polluting technologies.

Dr. Kim Howell, research officer of South Wales NUM, rightly identifies energy as the key environmental battleground, calling for greens miners. power workers and "union bosses" to muck in to gether to come up with credible alternatives to present energy sources.

The book limps to a conclusion with Joe Weston's "New Priorities for Environmental CamPe has thr Whese his hands at . These amount, after the violence of the oppressed black youth of Birmingham, to little more than a call for campaigns to improve conditions in the inner city neighbourhoods.

Though 'Red and Green' is» not entirely without merit. it has too many flaws for it to fill the gap described at the start of this *Ed. Joe Weston, Pluto Press. E4.95.

The Ver Politics of the Earironment Edited by Joe Reston ELL PLUTO

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 283

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →