Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Where Militant went wrong

Socialist Organiser no. 283, 11 September 1986 · scan p. 10 · about 1,926 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

20,000 marched in '83. What went wrong? Photo: John Smith, IFL By Colin Foster Militant's supporters in Liverpool are in full retreat. What was once the front rank of the local government fight against the Tories is now the parade-ground for a witchhunt which hits not only Militant but also many others on the left.

Every socialist must fight that witchhunt. But we must also understand how the defeats took place that set it going.

The leading Militant supporters in Liverpool have been expelled from the Labour Party. Constituency Labour Parties have had to accept these expulsions on pain of being suspended and one of them, Broadgreen CLP, has been suspended nonetheless.

When Labour's right wing expelled live members of the Militant editorial board in 1982, they had a hard time of it. This purge has been much easier, and the Labour leaders have been able to use it as a springboard for a broader attack on the left.

The Labour Party Young Socialists is under attack: the proposed restrictions on its rights and functioning will hit not only Militant, but also other socialist youth.

Militant have not even tried to stir up a wide campaign in the labour movement against the witch-hunt: instead they have relied on the courts.

In 'Militant' of 28 March they wrote: *The Labour Party rank and file (?) scored a magnificent victory last week when the witch-hunt was stopped in its tracks" (by a court ruling). Short-sighted self-delusion! The Labour leaders soon found a way round the legal difficulties. The use of the courts has boomeranged, making it easier for the witch-hunters to bring in a new streamlimed procedure for expulsions.

Meanwhile Liverpool council, once the proud spearhead of the fight against the Tories, is making cuts with Militant's support. On 28 July the council's chair of finance, Tony Byrne, told a local Labour meeting that it would be 'necessary' to cut about £12 million. £10 million of this would be 'painless', but the other f2 million would not.

The Labour group is still resisting pressure to exclude Derek Hatton and Tony Mulhearn, but it can only be a matter of time before it gives way.

And the Liverpool council workers? unions, once solidly united in determination to confront the Tories, have mostly swung behind Neil Kinnock.

Now the best leadership will some times suffer bad defeats. The Liverpool labour movement faced tough odds in its fight against the Tory government, because the national leaders of the labour movement were hostile to that fight.

But the setbacks in Liverpool over the last year have not just been defeats due to overwhelming opposition or understandable mistakes. They were not quite the worst sort of defeats, defeats without a shot being fired. But they were defeats in which loud preliminary cannonades, shots over the enemy's head, were followed by disorderly retreat instead of actual battle.

The story starts in May 1983. On 5 May, as in three years out of every four, one-third of Liverpool City Council's seats were up for re-election. Labour won control of the council with tremendous gains — 11 extra seats, a 40% increase in the Labour vote!

The new Labour council started well, building new houses. creating new jobs, going well over the budget prepared by the Liberals for 1983-4. By October the Тогу government was already warning the council about overspending'. The council responded with a vigorous campaign among council workers and the local community. 20,000 people joined a march on 19 November.

By February 1984 Derek Hatton was explaining to Militant that "the crunch" would come "probably at the end of March".

A campaign committee mapped out plans to include a possible | all-out strike from 29 March.

But Labour's majority in the chamber was only three - and ber of Labour right-wingers declared that they would never vote for an unbalanced budget.

On budget day, 29 March — despite a one-day strike by council workers, and a huge, enthusiastic demonstration at the Town Hall — there was not a majority on the council for Labour's unbalanced budget or the Liberals' alternative budget.

The campaign continued right through to the council elections on 3 May. Labour gained another seven seats, securing a solid majority for its unbalanced budget.

Council workers were ready to strike, and many other workers to support them. The miners' strike was at its height, Dawdled But things started going wrong. Instead of stepping up their campaign, pushing through the unbalanced budget and going fast and hard for confrontation, the Liverpool council leaders dawdled. The campaign dwindled. The unbalanced budget was not put to the council again. Instead, the council leaders went off to talk to Tory minister Patrick Jenkin.

Early in July the council leaders announced a deal with the government. The Tories would give them a little extra money and permit various financial tricks to shift the problem into the next year. Liverpool could then get through with a 17% rate rise.

Militant hailed this as a great victory. This was a terribly short-sighted view: a chance to open a second front alongside the miners, and win a real victory, had been passed up in favour of postponing the problems.

But Militant had better luck than it had any right to expect. At the next budget-making time, in spring 1985, the miners were still on strike, and other Labour councils were talking of struggle. Liverpool would have a second chance to come to the crunch with the Tories under favourable circumstances, And it botched it again. 'Militant" talked about struggle, but gave no specific indication of what sort of mobilisation would be needed. It did not suggest that it would be more than the demonstrations and rallies of 1984. And it gave no hint of any urgency about bringing the struggle forward so as to give aid to So until June 1985 Liverpool remained in the background. Militant believed (14 June) that the "councillors remain technically in a 'legal' position" . But now the miners had been forced back to work, and the other rebel councils had backed down (all except Lambeth, which succumbed on 3 July).

All credit to Liverpool for lasting out longer than the others. But what would they do now?

Councillors proposed a 20% rate rise which with some financial juggling would allow Liverpool to scrape through the year. The unions said no. So Liverpool set an unbalanced budget — 9% rate rise, £265 million expenditure, £148 million income - on 14 June. It demanded from the government the return of E29 million grant and E88 million penalties.

So far, so good. Maybe chances had been missed, but now, as Militant put it (21 June), "After two years of shadow boxing..the gloves are off."

Instead of general calls for a "mass camaign", — Militant said boldly: "Strike to defend councils".

Low-key

Despite everything, Liverpool still potentially in a strong position.

As late as 21 September, the bigbusiness magazine, the Economist, wrote:

"Suppose the Militants persist in saying no? Mr Baker's (the Tory minister's) trouble in this game of chicken is that he dare not, in the last resort, force Mr (Derek) Hatton (the council deputy leader) off the road...Yet, except by giving way himself, he has little power to avoid it, if Mr Hatton and the council labour force - not necessarily the same thing — insist.

Yet the council's campaign remained low-key compared to 1984. Instead of becoming bolder and sharper as the crunch came nearer, the coverage in Militant became vaguer and softer. The urgent calls for strike action were replaced by appeals for general support' in a long-term campaign.

What was happening? What were the council's plans? Workers in Liverpool and elsewhere weren't sure.

Then in the middle of September, the council said it planned to issue 90 days' redundancy notice to all 'employees! Workers blockaded the town hall to stop the council meeting. The concil leaders retreated, and the Militant-led council shop stewards called for an all-out strike against the Tories from 25 September. Amidst confusion and resentment at the redundancy notices, the strike vote was lost 47%-53%.

With characteristic unrealism, Militant (27 September) spoke blandly of a minor setback and "the success of our campaign"! The same day, 27 September, redundancy notices started going out. NALGO struck in protest.

On 11 October the council was forced to withdraw the redundancy notices because of legal action brought by the NUT. Instead it found a new 'legal device' ...to lay off the whole workforce from 1 to 28 January.

Such blunders allowed Neil Kinnock and the soft left to crucify Militant.

What better proof that 'Marxists' were irresponsible posturers?

On 20 November the National Executive Committee decided to set up a kangaroo-court 'inquiry" into Liverpool District Labour Party, thus beginning the process that would lead to the expulsion of the leading Militant people on Merseyside.

Meanwhile in Liverpool council services began to wind down for lack of cash. The workers were increasingly disillusioned and resentful, and still did not know exactly what was going on above their heads.

Swiss banks

Finally, on 22 November they found out. The council backed down, with a deal which was (as Militant of 29 November puts it) "based on capitalisation of housing expenditure" . It got a E30 million loan from Swiss banks. The condition was attached that the council must stay legal in the future. The package included cuts, though small ones!

And the workers soon discovered: I) that these cuts had in fact already been made, by the partial rundown of services in the period when the council was running out of cash; 2) that the loan had been negotiated as far back as August. In other words, the retreat had already been made, undercover of blustering slogans about an offensive, before it was announced.

It is not possible to 'lead' workers like this for long without suffering the consequences.

Why did Militant make these blun ders?

After July 1984 Militant substituted bluster and puffed-up self-satisfaction at the "victory" won (they said) by "the Marxist leadership" for sober assessment. In October 1984 that drove them into a stupid confrontation with Merseyside's black communities, when they tried to put a Militant supporter, Sam Bond, into the council's top race relations job.

And there was more to it.

According to Militant's addled version of Marxism, iron laws of history drive the working class ever onward towards Marxist politics. The job of the organised Marxists (i.e. Militant) in the meantime is to make general propaganda and build their own following.

Victory is inevitable in the long term; so why take risks now? If the situation is favourable now, it will certainly be more favourable in the future. And it makes no sense to risk positions, prestige and propaganda platforms for the sake of 'ephemeral' struggle.

So Militant tried to maintain a delicate balance: on the one hand giving Liverpool a profile as a fighting. socialist council; on the other trying to keep the council in office and themselves in the leadership of the council.

Contrary to all intelligent tactics, they tried again and again to postpone the crunch and extend the time in which the council stands in opposition to the government but not quite in collision with it.

When it came to the test, Militant's politics proved to be in the tradition not of Lenin and Trotsky, 'but of the middle-of-the-road trimmers who cover up their delays and dithering in workaday class struggle by loud 'Sunday socialism

----- pull-quotes -----

LIVERPOOH, tinitv is sireneth

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 283

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →