Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

[Irish deal is signed. Photo: Derek Speirs, Report…]

Socialist Organiser no. 284, 18 September 1986 · scan p. 3 · about 1,752 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 3

Irish deal is signed. Photo: Derek Speirs, Report RUC clear streets after Loyalist riots in Portadown, 14 July: FOR OVER half a century in Northern Ireland the Union Jack was a sacred thing, whether flying from the flagpole at Belfast Town Hall or wrapped around a drunken old lady dancing in the streets to taunt the Taigs. Anyone who interfered with it would feel the full weight of the RUC.

It has been legal to fly the Union Jack in any place at any time - in Catholic/nationalist and Protestant/ Unionist areas alike — even when the flaunting of that flag was so intensely resented by the Catholic minority that riots followed.

By contrast, it was illegal to fly the Irish tricolour if doing that would offend or provoke Unionists, which of course it did.

Tricolour Of course most Catholics considered the tricolour to be their flag - That toohopeful banner of 20th century Irish nationalism symbolically linked the green with the orange by way of the white of a notional Irish unity. That national unity, so much desired by Republicans such as Patrick Pearse and James Connolly, who flew the tricolour over their headquarters in Dublin during the Easter Rising 70 years ago, never came about in reality. The Northern Protestants remained aloof and hostile.

The Protestant flag was and remains the Union Jack, and the tricolour became and is today not what it was designed to be, the symbol of the unity of Protestant and Catholic, of the descendants of 16th and 17th century settlers with the natives, of 'the Gael and the Gall' - but the banner of the nationalism of the Catholic people of Ireland, and in the first place of the 26 county state. In that 26 county state today, the flag's meaning is sometimes "green, white and gold".

Now the British government and the 26 county government have decided to downgrade the Union Jack and upgrade the tricolour. As part of a display of the Union Jack for sectarian purposes will be subject to the same legal constraints and sanctions as the flaunting of the tricolour already is.

This will be seen by Unionists as symbolic of the whole Anglo-Irish agreement. The problem is that be a pretty empty symbol.

Of course any move to equalise relations between the Catholics and Protestants in Northern Ireland is to be welcomed. But what this proposal shows more than anything else is the pettiness of both London and Dublin alike in their approach to Northern Here you have a society with 20% unemployment; within that, far higher rates of unemployment in most CathoTic areas; and savage sectarian discrimination against Catholics for jobs at places like Shorts engineering works and Harland and Wolffs shipyard. You have mass poverty, and a political system which broke down in 1969 and has proved irreparable ever since.

Petty

Instead of radically altering anything either in politics or society, the two Tory governments go in for petty tinkerings like the proposed legislation on the flags.

The proposed reform package is important for one reason - because it has been successfully pressed for by Dublin. This shows how well the Anglo Irish deal has survived the Orange marching season of the summer. Probably it has been strengthened by that test.

The pressure on the opposition Fianna Fail party in the South not to scrap the deal if it wins the 26 counties election due in the next year can only grow in these conditions. Those regarded as Fianna Fail's co-thinkers in the Six County constitutional nationalist party, the SDLP, such as Westminster MP and SDLP deputy leader Seamus Mallon, are openly demanding of Fianna Fail leader Charles Haughey that he too should work the Anglo-Irish deal it he wins the next electionRobinson The Orange leaders understand all this, and it has led certain prominent leaders of the Unionists to say publicly that an independent Northern Ireland would be more acceptable to them than the joint London-Dublin rule in the Six Counties which they say — and in part rightly say — is enshrined in the Anglo-Irish Agreement.

Peter Robinson, lan Paisley's deputy, has recently said it, and so has the deputy leader of the Official Unionist Party, Harold MacCusker. MacCusker said this in the House of Commons debate on the Anglo-Irish agreement fast' November, "but has returned to the theme recently.

The Ulster Defence Association been for independence since 1979.

Right now all this talk of independence is used as part of a campaign to scare Britain into scrapping the Anglo-Irish Agreement. But there is no reason to doubt that some of the Protestant leaders mean what they say.

Opinion polls have always shown that only a small minority of Protestants favour independence — which, of course, is the opposite of Unionism. Studies by economists of the likely consequences of independence show that living standards would decline by perhaps as much as 50%. And the existing Northern Ireland unit could not survive independence - it would break up.

Nationalism'

These are the considerations that inhibit the growth of a Protestant movement for independence, Yet the open discussion of independence by the most bigoted of Unionists is an indication of the way things are going, or may go, in the Protestant community. The Protestants are hopelessly small numerical minority in the United Kingdom. If Britain remains determined on the Anglo-Irish Agreement, the only recourse for the die-in-the-last-ditch Orangeists will be a movement similar to the IRA; striking primarily at the South. Already there is no shortage of threats to strike at the South, and there are signs of some attempts to organise to do it.

Talk like that of Robinson and MacCusker will help generate such a move, and is helping to harden an Ulster Protestant 'nationalism'.

Partition, which brought the Protestants home rule in Belfast (until it was abolished in 1972) enhanced and reinforced their sense of an identity separate from the rest of the Irish; and a series of conflicts with Britain over the last 17 years, and now the conflict over the Anglo-Irish Agreement, have enhanced and reinforced and perhaps created a sense of an identity separate from Britain.

In face of that, the proposed reforms - though the legislation on the Union Jack will act like petrol on the fire of Protestant resentment — are pretty small beer.

Already the Protestants, with their opposition to the Anglo-Irish deal, parallel and mirror the Catholic nationalists and Republicans. Back before World War 1, when the Orangeists armed to resist all-Ireland home rule, republicans like Pearse and nationalists like MacNeill welcomed it, and said Orange rebellion against Britain had a nationalist logic to it - whatever the intra-Irish animosities and tensions that were driving them to rebellion against a Britain that seemed to be siding with the Irish nationalist majority.

The same logic is there now, and probably growing. Talk of independence amounts to Orange Sinn Feinism.

But there is no way that the two Irish Sinn Feinisms can cohere. In an independent Northern Ireland relations between. the two of them would be settled, and their respective territories carved out, by way of bloody civil war. That would be an immense tragedy from which nothing good could come for either socialism or Republicanism in Ireland.

The Anglo-Irish deal, with its inflamTHE Tories and their press have got their hatchets out and are mounting what looks like a coordinated attack on the latest work of Alan Bleasdale, author of "The Boys From The Blackstuff" the famous drama about unemployment in Liverpool.

Their real target is the BBC, it seems.

Bleasdale's new TV serial, "The Monocled Mutineer', has been widely praised for its dramatic and artistic power. It is based on the story of a real person, Percy Toplis, during World War 1.

The attacks on Bleasdale centre on the charge that his drama is not — or so they say — a hard documentary "The Monocled Mutineer' does not claim to be a documentary, or straightforward historical narrative. It is a drama woven round a core of historical fact.

All such dramas, from Shakespeare's time to ours 400 years later, employ "dramatic licence'. The author has the right to sift and edit the facts, to telescope them and to invent scenes and events as he needs to express the truth as he sees it.

The standard is set by the needs of artistic and dramatic truth, not by the demands of accurate historiography or biography. Such a work is to be judged by whether or not it captures the essence of a historical event, period or episode.

Bleasdale's 'Mutineer' does capture and express most powerfully the fundamental truth about the unimaginable degradation and brutality to which the rank and file of the British Army -like the other armies — were subjected during World War 1. That was a naked imperialist war on both sides, a war of the trenches in which the generals would almost casually throw away half a million and more lives to capture few feet of blood-drenched mud.

Such a view of the First World War has been steadily gaining ground since the 1920s, and these days it is very widely held. You do not have to be especially radical or left-wing to share it.

But to listen to the Tory press hounds baying at Bleasdale, you would think his view of the First imperialist World War was a perverse heresy and a sacrilege against the universally venerated memory of a holy crusade for freedom and democracy.

Bleasdale himself says that the outcry is designed to secure a 'strong new chair for the BBC who will bind the BBC utterly to the will of the Tory party and the right wing. Many of these people, believe it or not, now think that the BBC is dangerously leftwing.

Tell that to the makers of the various programmes on Ireland which have been banned, bowdlerised, or reedited over the years!

But the Tory attempt to trounce Bleasdale and those who let this work appear on the TV screen, for the way they handle events that occurred seven decades ago, probably marks a qualitative new stage in attempts by the repressive right wing to turn the clock back.

Defend artistic freedom from the attacks of the Tory vandals! Alan Bleasdale!

Printers under pressure p 4 Black women organise p 5 LPYS under attack p 3 Murder most Fowler p 13

----- pull-quotes -----

forgotten, and it is often described as Photo: Martin Shakeshaft. u

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 284

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →