Is vengeance socialist?
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-09-18Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
Lane was making — that 'light' senten- old people and children as well as ces express outrageous attitudes to against women which we read about so women, rather than a comprehensive frequently in the press. I can sympahumanitarianism on the part of the thise with those who want to take 56% | of people in Britain want nuclear power scrapped, while 34% want to keep it and 10% 'don't know' according to the latest Gallup poll..
Opinion has swung massively since before Chernobyl, when only 28% wanted an end to nuclear power. Fully 68% of Labour supportIRAN I ANF wrote in 'Woman's Eve' judges.
SO 282):
"As long as men like (Judge) Miskin see rapists as harmless men who just forgot to ask first, sentences will be light. And as long as women are seen as sex objects for men's enjoyment, rape will continue"
Now of course it is true that sentences handed down by a judge, for lane as for other crimes, can vary according to the moods and prejudices of the judge. Unusually light' sentences for rape probably to express the prejudices against won on of judges who are usually male, upper-class, and elderly - and sometimes the downright misogyny of some of them.
Cn far cn much to the noint Jean OU 3U yt But agitation against light' sentences necessarily implies that we advocate harsher ones. Do we? Surely we should not.
Some feminists do, or seem to. But the whole sharp condign punishment' , 'hang-'em-flog-'em-jail-'em-for life' approach to crime is more backwoods-Tory than socialist.
Surely we advocate eradicating the social causes of crime and treating offenders humanely.
This need not and does not imply any indifference to defending potential victims against criminals.
Emotionally I can understand the impulse to string up people who commit the scarcelv believable acts against
direct action against shopkeepers who direct action against shopkeepers who
sell substances for children to snift.
The question is, though: do we react blindly and emotionally, or do we keep in mind the horrible social context in which these crimes happen? If rape is generated by the place of women in the whole culture, is the answer to it to demand the head (or, like so many who responded to the Woman's Own survey, the balls) of the culprits?
That isn't the answer. It is blind vengeance of the sort that repels us when it is generalised towards all criminals at Tory Party conference.
Yet if vengeance is the right response to rape, then why would it be wrong as a response to the savage attacks that take place during robberies of old people? Logically it could not be.
TOM O'KEEFE; Manchester.