[Lenin and Trotsky with soldiers who had taken…]
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-09-18Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
Lenin and Trotsky with soldiers who had taken part in suppression ers now want no nukes.
Opinions on nuclear weapons have also changed, though less dramatically. 44% now favour unilateral nuclear disarmament; two years ago it was only 20%.
It's odd that more people should want to get rid of nuclear power used peacetully, because of the accompanying risks, than oppose nuclear weapons Cpi which carry all the same identical risks, and more, and are meant to be dangerous! But such is the fact. LAURENS Otter seems incapable reading what people actually write.
I never said that those who raised hue and cry over Kronstadt in 1938 were agents of Stalinism. They were a 'People's Front' of Mensheviks, Anarchists, Social Democrats and the bourgeoisie.
I never said that 1938 was the first time the question had been raised. In fact I said that what differentiated Kronstadt from the many other such episodes at the time was that the Anarchists and Social-Revolutionaries flocked to Kronstadt to make political capital out of it.
But it is instructive that such a broad range of groups chose to re-raise Kronstadt in 1938. The reason was that they had all been exposed as bankrupt. The Anarchists in Spain had shown the hollowness of their abhorrence of the state by taking part in the Popular Front government.
The collapse of the post-war boom, and the continued crisis of capitalism, have once again shown the bankruptcy of Social Democracy, and it is no wonder that the Kinnockite Tribune seeks to divert attention away from its own politics by raising the myth of Kronstadt.
On the question of the composition of the Kronstadt garrison, Otter provides no real proof that the sailors of 1921 were the same as those of 1917. He refers to a government decree of 1917. But there were many decrees I think that the article on the Brent teachers' dispute in last week's Socialist Organiser (283), did not quite give a full picture of the situation.
The population of Brent is over 50% black and nearly 85% of the pupils at Sudbury Infants are black. Yet only 200 of the 3000 teachers in the borough are black. Since 1982 the Council have strengthened its campaign to combat racism in the schools with courses in race-awareness and a policy to employ more black teachers.
But to the Council Maureen McGoldrick was considered rather as a troublemaker. It was rumoured that she was about to make an official complaint concerning under-staffing at the school — a serious problem throughout the borough. The council's answer was issued which, although never formally rescinded, were also not implemented.
I think Trotsky, as creator of the Red Army and Commissar for War, was better placed to know whether the troops were moved to other fronts than is Laurens Otter, and Trotsky says quite clearly they were.
The uprising was a petit-bourgeois reaction to the hardships of the civil war, and against the dictatorship of the proletariat, The view of one of those quoted by Otter - Victor Serge - was that the affair could have been averted if the NEP had been introduced one year earlier. Yet according to Otter the NEP was part of Lenin's counter-revolution against which the Kronstadters were rebelling.
Quite clearly the facts are at odds with the myth that Laurens Otter tries to perpetuate.
ARTHUR BOUGH, Stoke-on-Trent.