Settler states
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-09-18Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
Rod Quinn's letter (SO282) shows the uselessness ot Tony Greenstein's theory of settler-colonial states' Yes, South Africa is a settler-colonial state and so are Israel and Australia. Tony Greenstein draws the conclusion for practical politics: Israel=South Africa._ Rod Quinn adds: Australia= Israel.
The drift of Greenstein's argument is fairly clear. To deal with the 'settlercolonial' plague in Israel, the Israeli Jews must be treated like the whites in South Africa. Socialists should defend individual rights for them, but as a nation they should be submerged in an Arab state, just as the whites will be submerged in a majority-rule South Africa.
Im not sure what conclusion Rod Quinn intends. Australa s settler population of 15 million cannot possibly be submerged by the few thousand surviving Aboriginals. Even after the socialist revolution - and even after making what compensation is possible to the Aboriginals for the terrible suffering of their people — Australia will still be a settler society.
In fact - despite all the horrors of European settler-colonialism between the 16th and 20th centuries — 'settlercolonial' does not always mean reactionary.
After all, there are many other settler-colonial states. Take Cuba and other Latin American states: have their nationalisms been always and entirely "antianna.) Talotho ISA. was its war for independence from Britain reac tionary?
Australian nationalism is reactionary, but not because Australia is a settler society. And the Australian working class cannot be equated to the working class in South Africa or white the Jewish working class in even Israel.
When Australian workers reacted to the sacking of their Labour government by Elizabeth Windsor's agent by demanding a republic, that was not reactionary (whatever the nationalist prejudices maybe wrapped around it, but progressive.
COLIN FOSTER, Islington thought I would write to tell other LPYS members about how we are building our branch.
A couple of weeks ago we held an allday gig at the Racehorse pub in North: ampton. Twelve bands played. "Brilliant" , said the NME, and despite the rain 300 youth attended.
There's very little entertainment for youth in Northampton — unless you want to get ripped off by the clubs, where drinks are £2 a go, the DJs are macho bores (and many black youth don't get in anyway).
There were political speeches and it was a pretty good way to tell youth how crap the Tories are.
Comradely, PAT MARKEY, Northampton LPYS Letters are welcome: send to PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA. 300 words or less, please, or we may have to cut them.