Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

[Socialist Organiset no. 284. 18 September 1986. Page…]

Socialist Organiser no. 284, 18 September 1986 · scan p. 10 · Martin Thomas · about 1,799 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

Socialist Organiset no. 284. 18 September 1986. Page 10 IN THE last few weeks I've looked at how the working class is exploited under capitalism.

The Marxist alternative to that exploitation is not just higher wages, but the replacement of the whole system of wage-labour. In other words, to replace money as the regulator of life by democratic planning for human need.

Trotsky put it like this;

"Money... is an inheritance from the class society which is incapable of defining the relations of man to man except in the form of fetishes, churchly or secular...

(However) "Money cannot be arbitrarily 'abolished'... (It has) to exhaust (its) historic mission, evaporate, and fall away. The death blow to money fetishism will be struck only upon that stage when the steady growth of social wealth has made us bipeds forget our miserly attitude towards every excess minute of labour, and our humiliating fear about the size of our ration.

"'Having lost its ability to bring happiness or trample men in the dust, money will turn into mere book-keeping receipts for the convenience of statisticians".

Needs

In a fully-developedsocialist society, it will be simply 'from each according to his or her abilities, to each according to his or needs' . Under a workers' government trying to organise the transition from capitalism to socialism, money will have to play some role - but a diminishing one.

The major means of production will not be bought and sold. Some basic necessities will be distributed free. Until enough of everything is produced for everyone, and a general spirit of social solidarity is developed, workers will receive wages and buy food, clothing, and other consumer goods accordingly. But as the sphere of free distribution is extended, so the role of money will dwindle.

Crush

Under capitalism, in contrast, money is all-powerful. It can buy everything; or lack of it can crush the brightest hopes.

As Marx put it: *It transforms fidelity into infidelity, love into hate, hate into love, virtue into vice, vice into virtue, servant into master, master into servant, idiocy nto intelligence, and intelligence nto idiocy In previous societies people generally worked until they had produced enough to live on - and then stopped. In many societies the desire to be richer than other people was looked on as weird and immoral. But in capitalist society money represents everything desirable society can offer.

It turns reality on its head. It is not that money is considered valuable because it can be exchanged for the products of human labour; the products of human labour are considered valuable because they can be exchanged for money - because they are 'worth' £100, £1000 or however much. Sometimes one even speaks of people as 'worth a million' One of the basic messages of Marxism is that the role of money in capitalist society, and the way it organises relations between people, are not facts of nature, but social structures which can be changed. Since its split last year with its long-time leader Gerry Healy, the Workers Revolutionary Party has been rethinking its politics and discussing with other - socialist groups.

This week we publish an article from Simon Pirani of the WRP on Ireland, as part of a discussion which will continue.

Socialist Organiser's last major statement on Ireland (Ireland After the Accord by John O'Mahony, Socialist Organiser, April 10th) falls into the fatal trap of attaching conditions to the demand for British withdrawal.

"We are in favour of British withdrawal but as part of a political solution which actually allows self-determination", says O'Mahony, that solution' being a federal united Ireland - ir which the minority areas will have autonomy - combined with the closest link between Ireland and Britain acceptable to the Irish majority Thus O'Mahony responds to the pressure of social-chauvinism, SO powerful in the British Labour leadership.

These conditions according to O'Mahony, to defend what he calls 'a natural Irish minority, the Protestants, which according to democratic norms would have every right to special treatment as a minority by way of having autonomy in its own heartland areas.

This minority, he claims, 'partly for reasons for protecting itself against the Irish majority — allied with a powerful section of the British ruling class against the Irish majority' This is a distortion of Irish history, throughout which Britain has not only (from the mid-1880s) lavished economic favours on Belfast, but also (from 1787) given the sectarian Orange gang arms, uniforms and legal protection. It was British colonialism that spawned religious sectarianism, not the other way round as O'Mahony suggests.

'Socialist Forum: Ireland 69-85, published by Socialist Organiser, takes this unscientific methodology still further, claiming that in Ireland the basic problem is the split bourgeoisie (page 21). The basic problem in fact British colonialism, which had taken a hold on Ireland for several hun. Was dred years, and had encouraged sec. tarian divisions for decades, before the native bourgeoisie emerged. Surely the great problem of the Irish working class is that forcible partition took it into the imperialist epoch with one of the most basic tasks of the bourgeois revolution - national independence not yet carried out. This gigantic historical fact throws some doubt, to say the least, on Socialist Forum's blase statement that Ireland has had its 'bourgeois revolution' This 'analysis' is bad enough. Still worse is Socialist Forum's absurd claim (page 35) that as a general principle Marxists favour regional or provincial autonomy for markedly distinct areas within a state, together with the most decentralised possible local government. A quotation from the Central Committee of the Russian Social Democratic and Labour Party (Bolsheviks) resolution of 1913 is used to prove that the 'federal united Ireland' slogan and calls for 'autonomy are 'Marxist' The RSDLP resolution was a pro gramme of 'democratic' demands (it calls. for instance, for a democratic republic' in Russia, rather than socialism) advanced by the Bolsheviks as a means of putting the working class at the head of the 'democratic revolution' at that time. The reference to wide regional autonomy and fully-democratic local government' referred to the specific conditions in Russia, which had a host of national minorities quite MUEL ULSTER SAYS unlike any other European nation. (The Bolsheviks continually faced the problem of these minorities' rights after they took power, and Stalin's reactionary insensitivity to them caused one of his major conflicts with Lenin in 1922).| Furthermore, the resolution's reference to fully-democratic local government is not a 'general principle', but a particular demand, flowing from the general principle of support for the self-determination of nations and for the rights of national minorities.

Demands regarding local government in Ireland would have to be worked out by Irish Marxists, also proceeding from this general principle but under conditions which are in no way comparable to Russia, firstly because the Protestants are not an oppressed national minority but in fact have been given privileges over a long period by Britain to encourage sectarianism, secondly because the national question only arises in relation to the oppression (and partition) of the whole of Ireland by Britain.

Of course any socialist programme for Ireland would have to have into account the problem of the divided working class, demand the total freedom of religion, the rights of divorce, abortion, etc., and show the way forward for the working class to achieve these things.

Emphasis

But it is completely wrong for British Marxists in Socialist Organiser to make 'autonomy' for Protestants a central part of their programme. In Britain our task is to put more emphasis on Irish self-determination than Irish Marxists would, to combat the social-chauvinism which justifies Labour leaders organising the imperialist occupation.

British Marxists have something to learn (with due regard to the limitation of historical analogies) -from Lenin's The Right of Nations to SelfDetermination'. . There he attacks Rosa Luxemburg not for opposing the reactionary nationalism of the bourgeoisie in Poland (the oppressed nation), but because she opposed the inclusion of the demand for Poland's right to secession in the Marxist programme in Russia (the oppressor nation). "

Of course Socialist Organiser is not the first British organisation to 'forget" the national question in elaborating a "Marxist' policy on Ireland. The Socialist Labour League, forerunner of the WRP, which always lyingly boasted that it was the 'only' organisation calling for the withdrawal of British troops, actually called for troops to be withdrawn while at the same time supporting the partition of Ireland by imperialism.

In December 1968, and again in July 1969, the SLL called for, in policy statements: 'A workers" and farmers" government in Northern Ireland, breaking from Westminster, posing unity of action immediately with the workers of the South and of Britain"

In 1970, this partitionist rubbish was quietly dropped. But the SLL continued to stress exclusively that the achievement of socialism in Ireland was dependent on 'working class unity" counterposing this rigidly to the demand for a united Ireland, i.e. national self-determination. Only since last year's split with G. Healy has the WRP seriously considered this position.

Principles

At the heart of this discussion is the question: how do Marxists develop our theoretical principles to approach specific problems in the class struggle!

Lenin's attitude to national struggles was based on the understanding tha two opposing tendencies were at wor under capitalism: firstly the awakenin of national movements, creation nation states and the struggle ag national oppression (this predomin ates in the beginning of capitalist development); secondly. break down of national barriers. of the international unity of capital . cE economic life generally. poltics science, etc (this téndency character ises a mature capitalisın that is moving towards its transformation socialism'). (See 'Critical Remarks o the National Question', chapter 3).

Marxist principles - working-class internationalism on one hand; right of equality of languages and national self-determination on the other - are based on these conceptions.

The particular problem in Ireland is that while capitalise is ret definitely ULSTER SAYS NO-_ in the second, imperialist stage, the Irish national question - which posed itself for solution long before many nations had reached the first stage of capitalist development — is unresolved. Furthermore, the northern "loyalists' who were first financed and armed by the British two hundred years ago to prevent a national uprising led by the petty bourgeoisie, are still being used for that purpose today. after the problem of national oppression has come and gone in many other countries.

Vital These particular circumstances make it more, not less, vital for British Marxists not to place conditions -either of 'autonomy' for Protestants, or even 'working class unity' - on their demand for Irish self-determination.

locialis: FORUM Amber 2 A socialist view of Ireland Available from SO: PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA, 5OP PlYS PAP

----- pull-quotes -----

-11 eland 69-85

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 284

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →